Live data from Hacker News

Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

tiktok.com

101–110 of 454 posts

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#101

Doesn’t look like a layoff, but more like she was fired. Depending on the law that is either allowed or not.

Here in Canada you require a cause (under most contracts) and this would be a disaster for the company if the employee took legal action. I guess in some states you can fire people without cause?

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#102
post #25

I get why Brittany's mad: Cloudflare appears to be handling this about as bad as possible. But those two HR randos aren't gonna have anything worthwhile to say, either. I don't want to be judgmental of Brittany because it's a sucky call to have to take. But my recommendation in this situation is to say "I disagree with that assessment of my performance, but I understand you are terminating my employment. What details…

Presumably these Cloudflare HR employees do have the data for why this person was laid off, and they might even have it in front of them, but yeah legally they can't give them any more specifics. As far as I'm aware, evidence of good performance could be used to strengthen their case to collect unemployment (if Cloudflare tries to fight Brittany's unemployment claim); it could also be used as evidence in a discrimina…

> … legally they can't give them any more specifics.

Could you please provide a source for that? That can be an important distinction for an employee. For example, when answering the question "Why did you leave your previous job?" It's important for the now ex-employee to have accurat information.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#103
post #25

I get why Brittany's mad: Cloudflare appears to be handling this about as bad as possible. But those two HR randos aren't gonna have anything worthwhile to say, either. I don't want to be judgmental of Brittany because it's a sucky call to have to take. But my recommendation in this situation is to say "I disagree with that assessment of my performance, but I understand you are terminating my employment. What details…

Nah, she did well by frustrating the process. Next time they’ll think twice before gaslighting and humiliating an employee. Telling her she was getting fired due to her own performance is just that. In my books she did well, hope she starts a gig on her own to never have to deal with NPCs such as those two. They feed on people’s misery.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#104
Honestly, I don't get why HR should be allowed to take such calls independently, or even be granted any independent function as such. Granted, most of my work experience was at (relatively) small companies (although one was a multi-billion dollar asset manager). HR is mostly a redundant department that folks from admin and legal can and should easily do. In fact, this was exactly the case at one of my internships in Japan at a billion dollar corpo.

HR has two jobs - managing the supply and outflow of talent, and preventing a bad look of the company while doing so. On both fronts, HR fails miserably, so imo they should be the ones to be axed first.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#105
post #25

I get why Brittany's mad: Cloudflare appears to be handling this about as bad as possible. But those two HR randos aren't gonna have anything worthwhile to say, either. I don't want to be judgmental of Brittany because it's a sucky call to have to take. But my recommendation in this situation is to say "I disagree with that assessment of my performance, but I understand you are terminating my employment. What details…

Is this a US thing where the company doesn't want to give any reasons for firing someone because that can be used in a lawsuit against them?

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#106
Good for her.

There isn't a "good" way to do layoffs, but "being laid off by someone you've never met before" is up there with the "bad" ways.

Also, there's absolutely no reason why, in the event of layoffs, you should EVER blame the employee or point to something they could have changed.

Layoffs happen because management fucked up. Own that and let the employee off the hook.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#107
Uploading a private conversation with HR to TikTok surely isn't going to help her job hunting. Prospective employers might view such behavior as a red flag... It might even be illegal given that the HR people are likely located in California, a "two-party consent" state.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is “firing” 50 people different from “laying off” 50 people?

Yes, you don't get severance if you're fired, in some cases.

You do unless you did something illegal or ethically wrong. Not meeting some company goal or expectation isn't enough. Killing a system with a rookie command isn't enough. Being an asshole isn't enough.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#109
I’ve been here. It sucks. I had a similar, shorter conversation, but I was deflated by the corporate stink of half-answers and weasel words after every questions.

Like her, I was doing awesome up until suddenly, I had no job. Fortunately I was given okay severance. I hope she lands okay.

This a strong signal for me to never work with Cloudflare. I doubt that matters to them, but hopefully this PR convinces someone who matters there to reconsider their handling of these situations.

Re: Cloudflare employee posts layoff call with HR and goes viral [video]

#110

This is why we need unions. Layoffs are unfortunately, sometimes, necessary. But when they happen, it's important that the right people are chosen, for the right reasons (whether that's performance based, voluntary, protecting certain groups, ensuring fairness, etc). That requires collective bargaining by representatives who are able to assess and change the criteria, and who are able to negotiate for better outcomes…

The person in this TikTok admits to having closed zero sales. They're also one of the most junior people on the team (4.5 months). They would be among the first to go under union rules, too. Unions are often worse at prioritizing things like tenure over performance, if anything. But even under those rules she was one of the most junior people. There is basically no situation where a union would have prioritized this…

Stop sticking up for this garbage please. Have some empathy?

• Third quarter revenue totaled $335.6 million, representing an increase of 32% year-over-year

Do we need to feel sorry for cloudflare or something?

She says on the call, or her feedback has been positive, so why should she expect a negative outcome like this?

As a junior, she should be given the appropriate and valid feedback so she can learn and improve for her future. Not this dystopian, cold bullshit. Do you have any idea what this kind of thing does to a junior employees confidence? Wow.

We should never stand for it.

Post reply on HN