Live data from Hacker News

Cisco Acquires Splunk

splunk.com

101–110 of 525 posts

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#101

Does anyone have an example of an acquisition where the products of the acquired company then became better?

Webex is much better under Cisco than it was on it's own. Cisco's expertise in hardware made for a great combination and has kept the product aligned with interoperable standards more than Zoom and some of the others.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#103

Somebody: Splunk has exorbitant prices and locked-in enterprise customers! Cisco: Oh these guys are just like us. Better buy them up. We know this business.

when you read Hacker News thread - every single one of them feels like the world is falling apart. Splunk is a dud or so everyone here thinks: https://siliconangle.com/2023/08/23/splunk-shares-surge-stro...

Everything on HN should be taken with a big ol' bag of salt. To do otherwise will cause you to miss out on both employment and investment opportunities you won't find elsewhere.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#104

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

That “thousands of dollars per year” number seems quite a bit low for a Splunk license. Even for a small amount of data it’s more like thousands per month.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#105

I hated Splunk so much that I spent a couple days a few months ago writing a single 1200 line python script that does absolutely everything I need in terms of automatic log collection, ingestion, and analysis from a fleet of cloud instances. It pulls in all the log lines, enriches them with useful metadata like the IP address of the instance, the machine name, the log source, the datetime, etc. and stores it all in S…

I’m sure the Cisco CEO is quaking in his boots thinking about this cronjob

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#106
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think they’re trying to get off of it because it is so freaking expensive.

I used Splunk at a previous job and that’s one of my few/only complaints with it. Great tool but extremely expensive for what you get. Datadog is the same way as well as Pagerduty. There’s not enough competition in these spaces

Hmm, are you referring to their Observability product or SIEM capabilities? There's a wild amount of competition in the Observability side of things, but SIEM not so much.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#107

Building splunk has become very democratised in today's day and age. Back in the day, logging, metrics, event collection etc. was a hard problem that they solved. Esp. when there weren't any simple distributed storage operators. They have been a cockroach in the orgs, surviving every downturn. As a dev, you might hate it, CISO and CIOs love it. Orgs, often mandate it. The way they dominated the market is via creating…

When I first saw Splunk in like 2010 it was mind-blowing. Back then, standard practice was to tile 8 ssh terminal windows and log -f everything I needed. I'm sure it looked cool, but it was damn near impossible to find what I was looking for.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#108
To pile onto the Splunk "love" going on here. Splunk is one of those systems that's too "powerful" for small use-cases, but too expensive for the ones it's really designed for.

Anecdote, I once worked with a client that really wanted to get Splunk, but produced so much network traffic that the discounted annual costs were more than the entire budget for the rest of the organization combined. That's staff, the building, equipment, power, water, everything...the estimated Splunk cost was more than that.

They went with a combination of ELK and a small team of dedicated developers writing automation and analytics against Spark and some enterprise SQL database. Still expensive, still cheaper than Splunk.

Re: Cisco Acquires Splunk

#109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

they price-out medium customers so mind-share decreases

It's better -because it's easier to scale- to sell a single 1M$ license than selling a thousand 1000$ licenses.

More efficient considering the typically long and drawn out enterprise sales cycle efforts as well.
Post reply on HN