Live data from Hacker News

Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

wired.com

101–108 of 108 posts

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#101
post #95
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure it is. They own the root, they can return an RR marked as authoritative for any domain in the system.

Would that work in the face of caching? If my resolver already has .se cached, for example, it wouldn't consult the root at all when looking up thepiratebay.se, right?

No domain seizure works in the face of caching. Eventually your cache will time out, and then it hits.

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#102
post #35
post #16

What people fail to realize is that US DOJ paved the way for other countries who do not want free internet to do what the DOJ does..ie India can demand that any *.in domain has to follow Indian law and take down any posts that disparage its leaders, etc.. Its really a very bad long term move on DOJ's part and especially undercuts the US State department efforts

> ie India can demand that any .in domain has to follow Indian law and take down any posts that disparage its leaders, etc.. Why is it unreasonable for a .in domain to follow Indian law? Isn't that the whole point of country-specific domains?

Who decided that .com is for everyone? (serious question)

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#103
post #63

The USA should be careful about throwing it's weight around like this too much. Do it too much and the rest of the world will either (a) start using a different .com root server or (b) force the USA to give up power over .com

If the rest of the world sees it as such a problem, whey don't they do either a) or b) already? (serious question)

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#104
post #103
post #63

The USA should be careful about throwing it's weight around like this too much. Do it too much and the rest of the world will either (a) start using a different .com root server or (b) force the USA to give up power over .com

If the rest of the world sees it as such a problem, whey don't they do either a) or b) already? (serious question)

Cause it hasn't become a big problem yet. The main sites that have been taken down are minority or suspicious sites. Most of the countries that would care enough to do something about this (e.g. Europe) are mostly ideologically similar to USA on a lot of issues. The internet is still so very young, a lot could happen in the next 50 years.

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Both sides of the Left-Right debate want more control. Gay marriage is only an issue because some Republicans feel they have every right to control your personal relationships. A few Republicans also want to ban abortion, which is again a ridiculousness intrusive government control. Let alone tapping every form of communication, tightening immigration restrictions, increasing law enforcement funding etc. Even the ide…

> marriage is only an issue because some Republicans feel they have every right to control your personal relationships This is completely OT but marriage is by design, its very nature and tradition not a personal relationship. That's why you have a gathering (the wedding itself), someone usually perceived as important presiding, a party (the reception), why you take your vows in public, why its registered in often pu…

That's a vary western view of marriage, other cultures have a vary different view of similar concepts. In the US we pay lip service to the idea of separating church and state, but we don't actually do much to separate culture and state which means religion has a back door.

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#106
post #92
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoting a post on daringfireball (about a story on readwriteweb) that has confused some foreigners hardly proves that "more often they search or follow links".

Dismissal of an argument by laughing at foreigners doesn't do wonders for your point either. My observations of usage come from working in IT at a wide variety of companies, from corporates to small businesses, including doing customer support at an ISP. I also have been coding HTML since December '93, so am no novice when it comes to the habits of people online. Personally I would say that people use the location ba…

Where does "confused some foreigners" equal "laughing at foreigners"?

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#107
post #92
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoting a post on daringfireball (about a story on readwriteweb) that has confused some foreigners hardly proves that "more often they search or follow links".

Dismissal of an argument by laughing at foreigners doesn't do wonders for your point either. My observations of usage come from working in IT at a wide variety of companies, from corporates to small businesses, including doing customer support at an ISP. I also have been coding HTML since December '93, so am no novice when it comes to the habits of people online. Personally I would say that people use the location ba…

[deleted]

Re: Uncle Sam: If It Ends in .Com, It’s .Seizable

#108
post #106
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Dismissal of an argument by laughing at foreigners doesn't do wonders for your point either. My observations of usage come from working in IT at a wide variety of companies, from corporates to small businesses, including doing customer support at an ISP. I also have been coding HTML since December '93, so am no novice when it comes to the habits of people online. Personally I would say that people use the location ba…

Where does "confused some foreigners" equal "laughing at foreigners"?

In regards to your post, when it is part of a derisive comment and the aspect of 'foreignness' is used in an attempt to belittle the point you are arguing against, despite not being particularly relevant.

As in; 'X is not really an issue, because in example Y it was mainly happening to foreigners', is very rarely a good argument for the vast majority of values of X and Y.

Post reply on HN