Live data from Hacker News

More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

reproof.app

101–109 of 109 posts

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#101
post #46
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well sure you can also run a random string generator and get a short .com TLD, but that's not the point.

Today I realized how xkcd prob got it's name

There’s a faq on this on the site (find it yourself). It was created as an unpronounceable “acronym” (although it doen’t stand for anything) and the domain came later when Randall was still an unknown. It’s old enough that a lot of “normal” domain names were still available, but the name itself was one of the jokes.

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#102
post #7

From my perspective as a user, maybe someone who would visit your domain, I’m indifferent to the specific TLD used. You might be able to compose a clever word that grabs my attention, which I’ve seen a lot from .ly domains. However, from an email marketing perspective, TLDs are not interchangeable. Some TLDs (think .xyz) see a lot of abuse, tanking the reputation and deliverability for good actors using them too. So…

As a personal user of .xyz I couldn't agree more. People often get a chuckle at my web/email address when I give it out. Sometimes I have to repeat it because (especially non technical) people aren't expecting it to end in .xyz but often it works to my advantage. The repetition and uniqueness makes it memorable. Also .xyz is generic enough to be used for business and for personal sites. It's also not a ccTLD so I don…

The problem with .xyz is that it’s so cheap, it’s a common choice for spammers/scammers to the point where wikipedia has a blanket ban on links to any .xyz domains unless explicitly whitelisted, even on a user’s personal page.

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#103
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are artificially necessary in some cases. I have a personal .com and a gTLD based domain. THis is mostly to retain control of mailflow (I use workspace but can always move it, and have in the past) The number of services/online forms that wont accept a .email domain is still very high. I would imagine at a business level this would be equally difficult, even if its just for B2B type transactions/relationships.

Same. I have a .family domain which is great, but about 1/3rd of the registration flows claim it’s an “invalid email address”. I have an older .org to fall back on, but it would be nice to use one domain for everything.

Imagine spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to get your own TLD and then discovering that "username@tld" emails just won't be accepted by basically anything. RIP username@google :(

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#104
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well sure you can also run a random string generator and get a short .com TLD, but that's not the point.

No 3 letter.com domain is available to register (all combinations are registered, can only be bought). 4 letter mixed numbers letters are sure available. I am not sure of 4 letters only is available. 5 letters only sure is available.

I bought a three letter domain at one of the original TLDs for $3k or so, they can be surprisingly reasonable depending on your use case.

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#105
post #49
post #14

.com domain availability has dried up and alternate TLDs dropped the price of squatted .coms. .io was too popular for a while and now everyone seems to be going with a .ai even if their product is far from actual AI. For my startup, I went with .dev. Don’t know if that was a good idea, but I was able to readily get a simple three-letter TLD there.

I don't know much about the marketing potential for .dev vs others, but I think .dev is one of the safest TLDs in terms of registry management and longevity. It makes sense for Google to keep their TLDs priced reasonably to keep the web accessible and there are some big anchor domains on .dev; web.dev, pages,dev, etc..

Google's also the most likely to suddenly decide they don't want to be a registrar anymore and just graveyard the whole TLD. They've done similar to bigger things.

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#106
> 100% of the top 20 YC companies by valuation have the .com of their name. 94% of the top 50 do. But only 66% of companies in the current batch have the .com of their name. Which suggests there are lessons ahead for most of the rest, one way or another. [1]

I wonder what the updated figures would be.

[1] http://www.paulgraham.com/name.html

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#107
post #7

From my perspective as a user, maybe someone who would visit your domain, I’m indifferent to the specific TLD used. You might be able to compose a clever word that grabs my attention, which I’ve seen a lot from .ly domains. However, from an email marketing perspective, TLDs are not interchangeable. Some TLDs (think .xyz) see a lot of abuse, tanking the reputation and deliverability for good actors using them too. So…

As a personal user of .xyz I couldn't agree more. People often get a chuckle at my web/email address when I give it out. Sometimes I have to repeat it because (especially non technical) people aren't expecting it to end in .xyz but often it works to my advantage. The repetition and uniqueness makes it memorable. Also .xyz is generic enough to be used for business and for personal sites. It's also not a ccTLD so I don…

My company uses xyz for staging and one of my colleagues couldn't figure out why he couldn't get the app working locally (some local services reach out to staging) and we found his ISP was blocking xyz

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#108
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Today I realized how xkcd prob got it's name

Possibly, although the official explanation is that it's "just a word with no phonetic pronunciation". There's a "What does XKCD stand for?" section on the About page. https://xkcd.com/about/

Randall wanted a unique short string associated with all his work. That way he could Google "xkcd" and find everything he ever did online. I believe he had a script that generated all possible 4-letter combinations and filtered out ones with any search results, and settled on "xkcd". But he became a victim of his own success when the comic became so popular and "xkcd" is now synonymous with the comic.

Source: talk by Randall, might be this one but I'm not sure: https://youtu.be/zJOS0sV2a24.

Re: More than half of YC startups don't have a dot com

#109
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reminds me of nissan.com, which is now nearly worthless because Nissan Motors doesn't care anymore.

I thought that was what Nissan (the domain owner,not the motor company) wanted, that motor company leaves him alone, & don't bother him while he uses his lastname domain.

If I remember right he owned a computer company he used the domain for, but he pretty much devoted his domain to his anti-nissan campaign until he passed away.
Post reply on HN