Live data from Hacker News

The Philosophy of Computer Science

plato.stanford.edu

101–102 of 102 posts

Re: The Philosophy of Computer Science

#102
post #32
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AFAIK the AI winter was more related to the Minsky paper, and the hype and no delivery of the over-promisses made by the industry.

No, it was bigger than that. There were AI startups in the 1980s. They all went bust. Expert systems were just not very useful. Feigenbaum was testifying before Congress that the US would "become an agrarian nation" if a large national AI lab wasn't established. Japan had a "Fifth Generation" project, trying to do AI with Prolog. All that stuff hit the upper limit of what you can do with that technology, and it wasn'…

> Japan had a "Fifth Generation" project, trying to do AI with Prolog. All that stuff hit the upper limit of what you can do with that technology, and it wasn't a very high upper limit.

What was the limiting factor of the expert system approach? Something like the size of the search space or that the number of rules you’d have to write was just infeasibly large?

Post reply on HN