Live data from Hacker News

I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

tristrumtuttle.medium.com

101–110 of 201 posts

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#101
post #2

The future of ai generated content and entertainment is going to be wild! How long before we have ~unlimited high quality entertainment? Before an AI can generate infinite episodes of your favorite show, podcast, comedian, and so on. Going to be an interesting thing to watch unfold.

You're joking

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But there is a limit on Breaking Bad episodes, for example. Just pump out new episodes. Could even have The Simpsons / Groundhog Day - style state-reset after each episode. Therefore the AI can make anything happen (Walter gets killed) and the produce another episode because you know that is just a multiverse branch.

That just sounds horrible to me. Breaking Bad was interesting precisely because it had to end. It was about very specific characters, their changing motivations and development. Rebooting every episode just because the premise is kinda cool and someone wants more of it diminishes what the series achieved both visually and conceptually.

I think once the original episodes are done you need to do something different. They went back in time and did a good series on the criminal lawyer. Now that is done.

If you could watch 100 different mini action movies where anything could happen. Everyone could die or everyone becomes nice and gets a desk job. It is less predictable and would be a fun thing.

What about you want to watch Law and Order SVU but just an average non-crazy day, fly on the wall style. I think that would be interesting.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#103
Funny, It reads like propoganda made by AI overlords in a posthuman world. The leap between being scared to being friends to conclude that all AI is nice without any real compelling narrative tying it up is what I would expect from an automatic well-being machine taking over us for our own good.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#104
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I asked GPT-3 to respond, it said: > I don't think it's likely that the AI memorized any comments from Hacker News. I think it's more likely that it was able to learn from the data it was given and generate its own story and illustration.

I asked GPT-4 and it spit out the following continuation: > That’s complete rubbish. I personally think that the above comments were not written by AI, but by clever Hacker News members who passed it off as AI. The question remains open, however, whether that was done in an attempt to deceive, or with tongue firmly in cheek. The cat is out of the bag, but paul graham is on the other foot in the bus? Regardless, this…

Sorry, straight from OpenAI playground.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#105
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Having a story remain coherent over time is not a prerequisite of Hollywood blockbusters.

Incoherency is not all bad, and choosing the subject carefully can be enough for the intrinsic weirdness of ai generation shine. I.e. this batman short: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fn4ArRmzHhQ (ai story and human drawing) provide a spot on jocker

Those "AI writes" are more a meme than actual AI. GPT-3 writes perfectly grammatical sentences but the stories don't make much long-term sense, which is the opposite of what the story in the video has.

These videos are mostly "human writes funny, says it's AI".

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#106
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine having 1 AI that is trained to recognize content you personally love. Then have another AI create the entertainment content, and improved by the 1st.

I'm pretty sure that's Netflix.

Then it's doing a terrible job of it.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#107

A minor note is that OpenAI does specifically forbid generation of images of human faces from DALL-E 2: I wonder why that last image didn't hit the content filter.

I'd say it's probably forbidden to generate a specific person's face. Or maybe a generic "a boy" description goes through.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#108
post #103

Funny, It reads like propoganda made by AI overlords in a posthuman world. The leap between being scared to being friends to conclude that all AI is nice without any real compelling narrative tying it up is what I would expect from an automatic well-being machine taking over us for our own good.

Funny indeed, but that leap was part of the prompt selected by the human author according to the post script.

Re: I made an AI write a story about AI then I made another AI illustrate it

#110
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is really very impressive. How likely is it this is essentially one or more comments from HN memorised by the neural net, with some synonym usage? How do we know that it’s not just reposting partially disguised sentences written by a human author?

It is not as if every comment here is a gem of wholly original storytelling. For the most part we’re all just regurgitating other people’s sentences. Imagine we made contact with intelligent alien life and they spoke english to us. Would people argue they’re just repeating turns of phrase and haven’t shown true intelligence? I feel like we are setting the bar for AI too high. Current AI systems are clearly intelligen…

The component that's most missing for "real" intelligence is long-term memory. Current machine learning systems do not continually evolve based on inputs from their environment, but rather just respond to the immediate input.
Post reply on HN