Live data from Hacker News

Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

kevinmarks.com

101–110 of 254 posts

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#101
post #90

I've never understood why people even wanted to use this. For the styling? So you can just copy some random stuff from Twitter and it looks like Twitter but is also interactive? Just with the Facebook like-Button, you're exposing your visitors to the tracking of Twitter. For what? Just so you can quickly copy one snippet and be done with it, instead of manually copying author name, content and link and spending 10 se…

> For what? Just so you can quickly copy one snippet and be done with it, instead of manually copying author name, content and link and spending 10 seconds to format this yourself. Unfortunately copyright law is not going to be happy with that one. [0] It's insanely complicated, but basically, as things are at the moment, the original poster has a right to retract the publication at any time. You may find yourself in…

Under US law, you’d likely be covered by fair-use so long as you’re reporting on the tweet as a news-worthy event (versus, say, asking for lols).

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#102
post #30

Just screenshot them instead of embedding them. If you cared about JS injection why would you embed anything?!

How are you supposed to prove the tweet actually happened if you just post a screenshot? It's trivial to forge a screenshot of a tweet to say whatever you want.

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#103

It's a shame there's no better way to preserve a tweet than taking a screenshot -- there's no way to prove that an individual said something, save for perhaps trusting the record on archive.org It doesn't have to be this way. Either the individual or the platform could cryptographically sign content to prove that it really happened. I guess Twitter would prefer a plausible deniability. If anyone screenshots you sayin…

I've never had my name dragged through the mud on twitter or anything but I'm super glad knowing that if I do make a mistake I can delete it rather than having it immortalised on the internet to be used as a weapon against me forever.

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#104

It's a shame there's no better way to preserve a tweet than taking a screenshot -- there's no way to prove that an individual said something, save for perhaps trusting the record on archive.org It doesn't have to be this way. Either the individual or the platform could cryptographically sign content to prove that it really happened. I guess Twitter would prefer a plausible deniability. If anyone screenshots you sayin…

What a shame that Jack left. We could live in a utopia where every tweet is an NFT in the Twitter Blockchain...

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#108
post #30

Just screenshot them instead of embedding them. If you cared about JS injection why would you embed anything?!

How are you supposed to prove the tweet actually happened if you just post a screenshot? It's trivial to forge a screenshot of a tweet to say whatever you want.

You search it. If it is deleted, you move on with your life and stop worrying about the past.

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#109
post #30

Just screenshot them instead of embedding them. If you cared about JS injection why would you embed anything?!

How are you supposed to prove the tweet actually happened if you just post a screenshot? It's trivial to forge a screenshot of a tweet to say whatever you want.

You can't prove it happened after twitter deleted it, either.

Re: Twitter is using its embedded JavaScript to hide tweets that have been deleted

#110
post #33

Why not just copy paste or screenshot the Tweet? It's bizarre to reference a script from twitter.com directly in your site's source code and then complain that the script is doing exactly what it is supposed to.

- copy paste the content of the tweet - meta data is lost (date and time, author, obv it is possible to copy paste the text and add links to original tweet and link to an author; - screenshot - now you dont have to add custom styles, meta data exists, but it is not usable - you can make is to click on tweet will open a tweet, but click on tweet author will open authors profile. Also screenreaders and bots - they dont…

Do web browsers nowadays have a way to save a part of html dom with every style inlined?

If not, that is a huge opportunity.

Post reply on HN