Live data from Hacker News

How to get the most out of your 1:1s

erik.wiffin.com

101–110 of 212 posts

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#101
One-to-ones seem like yet another of these cargo-culted management trends that add needless ceremony and develop into an end-in-themselves. At least anywhere that I've been that's tried to implement them.

We chew up an amazing amount of time on this kind of theater.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#102
post #18
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have 30 minute 1:1’s every week with my team (8 engineers). I’m in weekly backlog grooming sessions, semi-weekly demos, retros and sprint planning and of course daily standups. I’m in weekly status calls with two separate customers and weekly prioritization calls with product. I’m in constant dozer mode trying to clear a path for my team to eliminate blockers, execute bullshit corp process and help them resolve iss…

Have you tried building trust ? The tone of your comment here makes me think you haven’t. If you build trust with people, they’ll just tell you things. If you just say they can tell you things, no rational employee will believe that. And pushing people to talk about their weekend or other aspects of their personal life is downright toxic IMO. Again, if you build trust and rapport, you won’t have to ask these rote, of…

Trust is the centerpiece of my job, I’m certain that I’m not perfect but it’s something I can use to contextualize every decision and steer towards the best answer.

I’m sure my words could evoke a notion of some bully creeping on employees but I am just trying to break habits. I don’t force anything and as others have mentioned sometimes a status update is exactly what folks want to discuss.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Seems to me that the job of the engineer manager is just too lightweight. Maybe you don't see other things they do. Their work isn't only 1:1 with you. For instance, hiring, evaluating employees, redirecting team efforts if new priority arises, fostering collaboration with other teams if needed, unblocking things, reporting to high management about the team whereabout, making sure every IC has what they need for th…

> For instance, hiring Yes, they screen CVs and join tech interviews. I also join tech interviews. > evaluating employees True. They use the 1:1s to keep track of the evaluation afaik. > redirecting team efforts if new priority arises As I said, our eng. manager doesn't usually join our planning nor has ever said anything regarding "X has more prio than Y"... Redirecting the team effort is mostly on the team itself (…

Everything is pretty light weight as long as things are running smoothly. It's not completely unlike an IT department: You only really figure out their value, when things go poorly.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#105
Here's some tips to better 1:1s on-top of what the article mentions:

- If you're a direct manager in the 1:1, it is your job to take notes. Period.

- 1:1s are business meetings about results, and sometimes personal matters are discussed.

- If you have role power, you need to be cautious with what you say during a 1:1. People will take things literally.

- Agendas should be simple. 10 minutes you, 10 minutes me, 10 minutes for the future. Most important thing first, always.

- To start a 1:1, make a statement or a question, sometimes the small talk is not wanted or dreaded. "How's it going", "How are you", "How are things" are all valid.

- Don't come with an agenda to a 1:1. People hate not being able to contribute.

- If you setup 1:1s as a tool to get to know the team members you work with regularly, follow a simple 15 minutes you, 15 minutes me type of deal. (Especially if you're a PM, TPM, or EM working with another discipline)

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#106
I used to be an inexperienced manager as I expect many managers are these days and my 1:1s were a waste of time. I didn't really know what to do, constructive criticism and suggestions are really hard to do - I found it really hard to say what I really thought. However as an employee you should be asking about how to stand out in the team and "make a difference".

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#107
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I don't have anything work-related to report, there are no concerns on either side, and there are no situational changes, we just chat with my manager for the whole half-hour about various life topics. Sometimes it may bring to memory something related to work, which we can discuss. Sometimes it will be completely unrelated to work for the whole meeting, but I think there is still value in that. It helps us buil…

I hate when this happens. It's been a recent revelation of mine that I'm happiest when my personal business remains personal. I hate having to scrape through my life sanitizing topics into conversational safe spaces just to get paid.

Very much agreed. Those personal anecdotes and stories shouldn't have any affect on the workplace. But often you'll find subtle biases coming from the other party, after sharing stuff they may not like or agree with. It's fine for everyone to have their own opinion and certainly feelings on things. I don't want to share anything personal, or not work related at any work function/meeting. I don't want someone else's opinion on my personal life affecting their opinions of my work.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#108

It's strange how so many informal conversations have become formalized. Phone call? Book a calendar invite. Talk to your manager? Schedule a one-on-one. Want to raise a technical comment? Issue a Jira ticket. Not to say that this is all bad, but wondering if it's really helpful.

Just to offer a counterpoint:

I used to just ping my direct reports for 1:1s each week when it suited me, and then realised that that's pretty disrespectful of other people's time. I switched to asking people to schedule time with me in my calendar out of respect for their schedule.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#109
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I don't have anything work-related to report, there are no concerns on either side, and there are no situational changes, we just chat with my manager for the whole half-hour about various life topics. Sometimes it may bring to memory something related to work, which we can discuss. Sometimes it will be completely unrelated to work for the whole meeting, but I think there is still value in that. It helps us buil…

I hate when this happens. It's been a recent revelation of mine that I'm happiest when my personal business remains personal. I hate having to scrape through my life sanitizing topics into conversational safe spaces just to get paid.

It is unfortunate, innit?

That's just how it goes with most people - you have to adjust yourself, almost the way you do with children.

Re: How to get the most out of your 1:1s

#110

It's strange how so many informal conversations have become formalized. Phone call? Book a calendar invite. Talk to your manager? Schedule a one-on-one. Want to raise a technical comment? Issue a Jira ticket. Not to say that this is all bad, but wondering if it's really helpful.

The intention matters.

If you're scheduling because you've seen over time that predictable schedules is what other co-workers prefer, then you're using the tools to improve everyone's lives.

If you're scheduling because you're supposed to schedule and you never gave it second thought - you're in good company, you're simply among the 99%.

Post reply on HN