Live data from Hacker News

Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

adilaijaz.medium.com

101–110 of 156 posts

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#101
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sidewalk is carrying all kinds of data from other users. You have absolutely no idea what. It’s a loosely defined system that Amazon controls remotely at their will. The encryption stops you from snooping like any other TLS traffic, but Amazon itself is the receiver on the other end. And it piggybacks on your own internet connection - 80Kbps is a huge amount of data. Find My identifiers have a single purpose, are use…

> You have absolutely no idea what. It’s a loosely defined system that Amazon controls remotely at their will. s/Amazon/Apple and you've got yourself the Airtag protocol. Obviously Airtags use less bandwidth, but both are proprietary and about equally as evil in my eyes.

We know exactly what goes in an airtag message. It’s very limited. https://positive.security/blog/send-my

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#102
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would argue there is a difference between "being opinionated about how to implement a use-case" + "being opinionated about focusing on a small set of use-cases" and "forcing new use-cases on the user". The article is about the former, Amazon Sidewalk about the later. Also nothing while being opinionated can be very use-full for product design there is no reason why people can't be opinionated in a "bad" way. What t…

"forcing" isn't the right word though. They do have an opt-out. Making it an opt-out vs. an opt-in is very much "the former".

Given that most people won't even know what is happening without their consent it's not that different from forcing.

Opt-out is NOT consent, consent requires you do know about it, at least somewhat understand it and then "say yes". Opt-out it's more like forcing with a way to defend yourself.

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#103
post #44

Amazon recently turned on support for Amazon Sidewalk on all of their hardware in my home (convention) and decided it was fine to do this because I could opt out (configuration). That decision was the final straw for me. Every Amazon device is now unplugged, Prime membership and Amazon music canceled, no longer shopping on their site. Doing what is "easy for the average user" is not sufficient for me, some configurat…

What grates me with these situations is that they have my data, which is one thing, but I don't have access to that data!

What grates me is that I can't turn it off by saying "Alexa, turnoff sidewalk". They make you go into the app and dig for it. IMHO, you should be able to access all of the settings via voice.

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#104

Amazon recently turned on support for Amazon Sidewalk on all of their hardware in my home (convention) and decided it was fine to do this because I could opt out (configuration). That decision was the final straw for me. Every Amazon device is now unplugged, Prime membership and Amazon music canceled, no longer shopping on their site. Doing what is "easy for the average user" is not sufficient for me, some configurat…

> easy for the average user

Turns out you are not average user. I am quite sure that Amazon's profit from Sidewalk will shadow losses from you and other leavers by couple magnitudes.

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#105
post #70
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wouldn't like if I would specifically keep my Samsung Smart TV offline because Samsung themselves advice not to talk about sensitive things in front of the telly [0], and then finding out that it did go online, via my neighbor's helpful Alexa... No thank you. [0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-31296188

Are there any indications that the Sidewalk network can be used to relay other than device control information?

Ofcouras not, they will just add it next week and you will have 2 hours to opt out

We need laws against this shit

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#107
The place for opinion in your product is in its configuration. Applications need to be flexible, otherwise they are useless to anyone who doesn't share your opinion.

Opinions are like estimates. The only things we can be sure of is that they are not exactly right and will likely drift over time.

Similar to a shortcut, opinions can be useful - but should not be a limiting factor.

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#108
post #77

I think the tweet in the opening screenshot is simply wrong. I would argue that you almost always want paste to preserve the pasteboard formatting. Most copy/paste is within the same document, where you obviously want the odd bolded or italicized word to retain its formatting. But you don't notice those cases, because everything is working as expected. What you notice is that when you paste from an external source, t…

I suspect that a more nuanced approach could suit general users the best. Retain boldness, italics and underlining, change to fit target colour and font. Boldness, italics and underlining actually denote meaning, whereas font and colour are generally just aesthetic

In real Desktop Publishing software, text (content) and its style (layout) are separate — the text usually comes in from an external source (e.g. a file on an SMB share; a document in a CMS) and can be updated independently of the layout.

The linked text format is usually Rich Text (RTF). This allows a lot of things, but the Desktop Publishing tools only interpret the tags for bold, italics, underline, and a few other things (strikeout, subscript, etc.) All other styling in the linked text, they throw away.

This is precisely because, as you say, those specific styles actually denote meaning. They're something the writer adds. No other styling is used from the linked text, because none of the other styling is the writer's job.

All other styling is instead applied to the block(s) within the layout where the text gets embedded into. It's the layout designer that gets to decide the font, size, spacing, etc. for the text. Those attributes aren't stored with the text; they're stored with the layout.

To me, this makes far more sense as a workflow, even if you're a single author. I constantly wish that "word processors" had restructured and absorbed ideas from Desktop Publishing software when it came about. Instead, we got the garbled hybrid: you can have "document styles" like Title, Heading, Body, List Item, etc.; but they are essentially markup, moving around with the text (rather than there being any concept of an "section of the document" that gets styled, that text can be moved into/out of, and where the styles of that section will apply to the text only while it remains inside that section, such that moving text out of that area doesn't copy the styles of the section, only the styles of the text.)

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#109

Amazon recently turned on support for Amazon Sidewalk on all of their hardware in my home (convention) and decided it was fine to do this because I could opt out (configuration). That decision was the final straw for me. Every Amazon device is now unplugged, Prime membership and Amazon music canceled, no longer shopping on their site. Doing what is "easy for the average user" is not sufficient for me, some configurat…

I've never understood this Amazon Sidewalk thing.

The vast majority of people already have internet at home and phone plans.

Also, what's in it for Amazon? How does it profit from something like this?

Re: Want a killer product? Become more opinionated

#110
post #66
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can someone explain why there’s so much outrage against Amazon Sidewalk when it’s doing a similar thing to Apple’s Find My/AirTags which was met with almost universal praise?

I wouldn't like if I would specifically keep my Samsung Smart TV offline because Samsung themselves advice not to talk about sensitive things in front of the telly [0], and then finding out that it did go online, via my neighbor's helpful Alexa... No thank you. [0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-31296188

Thank you fpr letting me know. This is incredulous - 1984 where tv watches you, has come, without communism, and noone has noticed.
Post reply on HN