Live data from Hacker News

Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

imgur.com

101–110 of 845 posts

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#101
post #73
post #23

I'm fine with paying for quality news.

That’s not really the point. It’s that once companies have your CC info they make it arbitrarily difficult to stop paying them. This kind of behavior should run afoul of consumer protection laws.

That is the point, that's why I subscribe, regardless of the unsubscribe difficulties.

The value is way higher than some inconvenience.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#102
post #48

I've never been able to cancel any subscription with ease, so nowadays I always use Privacy to get temporary credit cards. When I want the subscription cancelled, I try the provider's website, if it doesn't work, I just cancel the card all together.

Woah, I had no clue that Privacy existed before but it looks really cool! What do you think of the service? Have you had any problems with it?

I love it, I use it for the gyms, my internet provider, the laundry machine provider, any place that I don't trust their data storage, etc.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#103

Honestly only case where I'm willing to overlook it. It's so hard for them to stay in the black. I can't imagine, in this age. For a serious newspaper that does good investigative journalism, I'll accept some desperate measures to keep subscribers and not hold it against them. Any other company and I'd call them garbage, but the NYT does a lot of good. (Same would go for other top investigative journals that have pub…

A while back someone posted a look into their finances and business strategy. They were fumbling the ball a decade ago, but are now doing extremely well

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#104
For what it’s worth, I’ve been in and out of a few subscriptions several times (incl WaPo and NYer), but I promised myself to never again subscribe to the NYT after I went through their cancellation process the first and only time.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#105

Imagine having a business model so fragile that your only line of defense is to obscure the cancellation process through these tactics. Do they really think that they can curve their churn this way? I mean best you’re doing is getting maybe another month or so of revenue from a customer who is just pushing the pain of cancelling because they are busy or lazy. And at the end instead of getting what could be a dormant…

Back in 2006 an AOL subscriber recorded their conversation with an AOL customer service agent while trying to cancel the service. It was really bad, way worse than this NYTimes process. The NYT wrote an article about the debacle [1] and had this to say about Netflix's great customer service and ease of cancellation, compared to AOL's awful service: "Seeing how Netflix would be so protective of my time were I to leave…

AOL was great when you were on a free trial and called saying you wanted to cancel but forgot. They just kept giving me another month. I was given maybe 6 months free when it should have been 3.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#106
This is amusing but if you aren't trying to make memes, just email unsubscribe@nytimes.com, include all the necessary info about your account (account number, billing address), and in my experience they'll do it right away. Of course my experience has N=1, but there it is. Don't waste your time, use email.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#107

Imagine having a business model so fragile that your only line of defense is to obscure the cancellation process through these tactics. Do they really think that they can curve their churn this way? I mean best you’re doing is getting maybe another month or so of revenue from a customer who is just pushing the pain of cancelling because they are busy or lazy. And at the end instead of getting what could be a dormant…

> Do they really think that they can curve their churn this way?

I don't know. Ask Amazon[1] I guess?

My point is that it's wrong to attribute this to a "fragile" business model. It's just plain, old greed and contempt for the customer.

[1] https://www.techtimes.com/articles/255977/20210114/amazon-pr...

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#108
post #36

Imagine having a business model so fragile that your only line of defense is to obscure the cancellation process through these tactics. Do they really think that they can curve their churn this way? I mean best you’re doing is getting maybe another month or so of revenue from a customer who is just pushing the pain of cancelling because they are busy or lazy. And at the end instead of getting what could be a dormant…

This happened to me with audible. They didn't have the cancel subscription on the app. Had to hunt for it on the site. Was asked if i was suuuuuuure i wanted to leave, 3 separate times before it canceled. Definitely not thinking of doing that again, or like i do for some streaming services, pay for a couple months, stop, then pay for a few more. Utterly rediculous.

The other issue with audible cancellation is that you throw away your credits...but then if you try to spend 5-10 credits quickly it becomes challenging...so you don't cancel. lol

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#109
post #101
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That’s not really the point. It’s that once companies have your CC info they make it arbitrarily difficult to stop paying them. This kind of behavior should run afoul of consumer protection laws.

That is the point, that's why I subscribe, regardless of the unsubscribe difficulties. The value is way higher than some inconvenience.

Irrespective of the quality of the publication or whether one wants to support a specific industry or publication by default, there's no good-faith reason why canceling a subscription has to be difficult.

Re: Before buying a NYT subscription, here's what it'll take to cancel it

#110
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This happened to me with audible. They didn't have the cancel subscription on the app. Had to hunt for it on the site. Was asked if i was suuuuuuure i wanted to leave, 3 separate times before it canceled. Definitely not thinking of doing that again, or like i do for some streaming services, pay for a couple months, stop, then pay for a few more. Utterly rediculous.

Another related dark pattern: When cancelling a Prime trial, Amazon makes it appear as if you're going to lose the Prime benefits immediately, not at the end of the trial, to keep you from cancelling early. (It seems like you DO keep them until the end of the trial, but you only get told that after cancelling) Together with their decreased support quality (agents barely understanding what I write + the typical "tell…

I've experienced the opposite with Amazon. If you complain about a product you've gotten they simply refund the full purchase price, no need to return the item or anything. I've even gotten months of prime refunded by telling them I forgot to cancel.

I assume that eating the cost of a bad purchase is cheaper for them than upsetting a long-term customer.

Post reply on HN