Live data from Hacker News

Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

onezero.medium.com

101–110 of 136 posts

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#101
Originally, our Nextdoor "group" was maybe 75 nearby neighbors, 50% of which I knew. Low traffic, high quality. (No ads)

Later they opened things up to maybe 5000 "nearby" neighbors, 1% of which I know. That totally changed the dynamic.

And yes, a few dozen who dominate every discussion. No thanks.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#102
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I live in a suburban area where you cannot get a house under $2 million. It is extraordinarily safe. Yet if you read the NextDoor it seems like 1970s New York, with crime and danger around every corner. Eyeball-oriented media always algorithmically boosts sensational news, which simply doesn’t reflect reality. Traditional print media, which would be owned by an independently wealthy elitist family, didn’t need those…

We had a post with short video of a 'suspicious white car, casing the neighborhood' several days in a row at 4am. A dozen posts about how things are going to hell, etc, followed by a post: Hi mark, it's my car. I've delivered your newspaper every morning for 5 years now.

What happened after that? That sounds like the beginnings of a really great movie about an unexpected duo becoming friends.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#103
Of course, this is not ideal. There is a big difference between journalism and message boards -- though that isn't to say, of course, that there can't room for both.

We've been working on a platform reimagining how local news can operate -- taking whats good from social media (the format and distribution), but maintaining journalistic rigor.

We cannot lose journalism.

https://blog.nillium.com/defending-journalism-to-defend-the-...

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#104
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We had a post with short video of a 'suspicious white car, casing the neighborhood' several days in a row at 4am. A dozen posts about how things are going to hell, etc, followed by a post: Hi mark, it's my car. I've delivered your newspaper every morning for 5 years now.

What happened after that? That sounds like the beginnings of a really great movie about an unexpected duo becoming friends.

Or a BBC news at 10 segment "American postman found dead in driveway" (Guns and paranoia don't mix)

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#106
NEXTDOOR IS AWESOME WE HAVE SOME NEIGHBOURS IN RURAL COLORADO THAT MOVED FROM NEW YORK OR SOMEWHERE LIKE THAT AND THEY COMPLAINED ABOUT THE ANIMALS IT WAS LIKE LIVING IN A ZOO THEY SAID OTHER NEIGHBOURS SAIDTHEY COULD MOVE BACKJ TO NEW YORK IF THEY DIDNT LIKE ANIMALS AND THEY SAID SORRY AND THEY DIDNT KNOW ANIMALS LIVED IN THEMONTAINS AND THEY GOT A CAMERA AND EVERYTHING WAS OK

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#107
post #106

NEXTDOOR IS AWESOME WE HAVE SOME NEIGHBOURS IN RURAL COLORADO THAT MOVED FROM NEW YORK OR SOMEWHERE LIKE THAT AND THEY COMPLAINED ABOUT THE ANIMALS IT WAS LIKE LIVING IN A ZOO THEY SAID OTHER NEIGHBOURS SAIDTHEY COULD MOVE BACKJ TO NEW YORK IF THEY DIDNT LIKE ANIMALS AND THEY SAID SORRY AND THEY DIDNT KNOW ANIMALS LIVED IN THEMONTAINS AND THEY GOT A CAMERA AND EVERYTHING WAS OK

Only slightly paraphrased but gave up on it after that.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#109
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Many places have exactly zero local daily papers. My town had a labor of love for a few years before the publisher fell ill. Now there's basically nothing unless something is big enough to hit a more broadly targeted audience. So Next Door/Facebook. (7K person town.)

How is the quality of news sources for your area that you find on facebook? I try to get as little news from fb as possible.

I hate to say it, but FB is invaluable for those of us in rural areas. There is a local paper, but it's mostly an exercise in stenography. Small county of 8,000 people. Everyone knows everyone. And the paper is probably hanging by a thread, so they don't want to piss anyone off.

So I rely more on FB. Follow all the local government agencies. Every one of them has an FB page. That gives a rough idea of what's going on. Comments on those pages are usually uncensored. Most of the comments are in agreement or cranks, but sometimes you get a nugget of truth that goes against whatever the agency said. That's been especially valuable in the pandemic. My local health agency hasn't behaved well, and the critics with inside knowledge frequently comment.

There's also local groups for my zip code that help piece together what happened. Another good, though often overlooked source, are pages from members of the opposition party. In my area, that's unsurprisingly the Democrats. They'll frequently highlight what's going wrong locally.

All of this doesn't replace the value created by a local paper that's willing to at least occasionally be critical or investigative. But it's much better than either nothing, or relying solely on the in-person gossip from neighbors. Pity it has to be on Facebook, but there isn't an alternative. Nextdoor in my area is pretty much worthless.

Re: Nextdoor is replacing the small-town paper

#110

I don't remember local or small-town papers to [generally] being toxic or cesspools of hate. However, one of my True Jokes is "NextDoor: Hate Your Neighbors" just as "Facebook: Hate Your Family & Friends" and "Twitter: Hate Your Heroes". NextDoor sounds good, but it generally proves not. Everything from "suspicious teenagers on the sidewalk again" [meaning: local kids walking to their local home from the local school…

My new home comes with a Ring I haven’t bothered to replace yet. Apparently Ring has some sort of Next Door like thing built into it now. The moment I saw someone accusing a UPS delivery man of being a porch pirate is the moment I realized these people were nuts and not worth my time.
Post reply on HN