Live data from Hacker News

An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

old.reddit.com

101–110 of 376 posts

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#101

This is classic shortermism. Reddit is, in the short term, driving more external users towards creating user accounts while in the long term removing one of the major value funnels for why they would (i.e. the quality of comments, particularly in certain niche communities/about niche topics). This will give them a short term "bump" at the cost of the site's long term relevance (as it falls down Google's search result…

same thing quora did, which made it hated by the masses.

[deleted]

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#102
post #51

It feels to me like social media has been imploding recently. It seems like I am seeing more and more efforts to overtly force people use an app, associate browsing with an account, and link their account with a real world identity (e.g. via phone number). This in turn makes the platforms less useful and more hostile to users and presumably at some point that will cause users to leave the system. It also feels like s…

If you have thick skin, anonymous imageboards have been here forever, altough the quality of discussion varies.

The board that shall not be named was very interesting back in the day. There was always garbage, but even a simple battle toads thread could be a lot of fun to follow.

I never knew if the interesting people found a new home, or disbanded, but I sure miss when fun stuff happened there.

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#103

It feels to me like social media has been imploding recently. It seems like I am seeing more and more efforts to overtly force people use an app, associate browsing with an account, and link their account with a real world identity (e.g. via phone number). This in turn makes the platforms less useful and more hostile to users and presumably at some point that will cause users to leave the system. It also feels like s…

Even my mother realizes how lame Facebook is now. It's what her generation is familiar with, so it'll take an act of Congress to get them off of it.

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#104

This is classic shortermism. Reddit is, in the short term, driving more external users towards creating user accounts while in the long term removing one of the major value funnels for why they would (i.e. the quality of comments, particularly in certain niche communities/about niche topics). This will give them a short term "bump" at the cost of the site's long term relevance (as it falls down Google's search result…

I wish Reddit had gone the way of VLC -- keep your core product, the thing people liked, and stop chasing profits. Why do so many of these companies fall to the profit motive and lose their "soul"?

Greed?

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I'm not going to install a dedicated app in order to read a forum Apollo (iOS) provides a nice and clean design, as does Joey (Android) which copies the style of the former. Even on the desktop, the experience is smooth and manageable, by using uMatrix and RES, whether you are browsing old.reddit or not. I don't understand the hesitancy in using these enhancements to enrich your user experience.

> I don't understand your hesitancy in using these enhancements to enrich your user experience. Not your parent, but I know of no mobile app that allows me certain enhancements that are simply standard on my (mobile) web browser: tabs, ad-blocking, & accessibility. Tabs: because I multi-task, and I compartmentalise my reading. If all I have is an app, then the app either needs to re-invent tabs within it (none I've f…

"reddit is fun" for android has few ads (text only, obvious difference from content) and has an easy way to copy, share, find in page, find on site, etc. And if you have a reddit account, you can save pages ala HN to quickly go back. Not as good as tabs, I get it. RIF is of the few apps I have for content.

This is compared to the Washington Post mobile app, which is essentially a wrapper around the mobile site that prevents copying text, has annoying ads despite being a subscriber, and has no redeeming functionality.

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#106

This is classic shortermism. Reddit is, in the short term, driving more external users towards creating user accounts while in the long term removing one of the major value funnels for why they would (i.e. the quality of comments, particularly in certain niche communities/about niche topics). This will give them a short term "bump" at the cost of the site's long term relevance (as it falls down Google's search result…

I wish Reddit had gone the way of VLC -- keep your core product, the thing people liked, and stop chasing profits. Why do so many of these companies fall to the profit motive and lose their "soul"?

Paying staff? Hosting costs? Recouping money for the time they spent on it?

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#107
I guess there will be accounts which are shared just to read the content. Although it requires 1 malicious user to get such account closed, it makes the profiling much more difficult.

That, or impersonate a search engine to access. They wouldn't block that, would they?

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#108
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think quality of the conversation will always trump "privacy, openness and ad-free". We have to pay for quality. If we're not going to pay with dollar bills, we pay with privacy.

Until you are like in HK and need to organize yourselves for some reason. > If we're not going to pay with dollar bills, we pay with privacy. Paying with ads is also possible.

But if you pay with ads, don't you need to see a LOT of ads, unless your privacy is compromised and they use trackers about you to give you targeted (i.e. more lucrative) ads?

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#109
post #103

It feels to me like social media has been imploding recently. It seems like I am seeing more and more efforts to overtly force people use an app, associate browsing with an account, and link their account with a real world identity (e.g. via phone number). This in turn makes the platforms less useful and more hostile to users and presumably at some point that will cause users to leave the system. It also feels like s…

Even my mother realizes how lame Facebook is now. It's what her generation is familiar with, so it'll take an act of Congress to get them off of it.

Facebook was always lame, it was a utilitarian communication tool. It's like calling hammers or wall calendars or trash bags lame.

It's similar to the argument you here when people say "they youth arent into facebook anymore, now they use xxxx." That's nice and all, but as long as they get facebook when they graduate high school or go to college, facebook wins. It doesnt need to be hip and cool if its the network gluing everyone together. Did the white pages or yellow pages need to be cool to be useful?

Re: An account is now required to read Reddit comment threads?

#110
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I'm not going to install a dedicated app in order to read a forum Apollo (iOS) provides a nice and clean design, as does Joey (Android) which copies the style of the former. Even on the desktop, the experience is smooth and manageable, by using uMatrix and RES, whether you are browsing old.reddit or not. I don't understand the hesitancy in using these enhancements to enrich your user experience.

> Reddit closes comments to non-accounts > some people stick to third-party apps to evade Reddit's tactics Guess what goes away next. (My bet is old.reddit first, because no one supports two versions of a site for the same platform—other than for accessibility.)

Mobile is not the same "platform" as desktop, but yeah, probably...
Post reply on HN