Live data from Hacker News

The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

businessinsider.com

101–107 of 107 posts

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#101
This map is really hit and miss for me. As a Missourian, I agree with the way Missouri is split up, right down the counties.

But the Upper Midwest (sans Chicago) is way closer to the rest of the Midwest than it is to New England. It has its own distinct flavor compared to the Lower Midwest. But not in "Yankee" way--more like "pre-Canada."

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#102
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are some mild differences in vocabulary and pronunciation (the Cajun 'R' is way more difficult) but they're mutually intelligible.

Good to know! Where do you find people speaking Cajun French in Louisiana? We went to the Festivals Acadiens et Créoles a few months ago, the only time I heard French was in the music, no one seemed to use French during a conversation.

Mainly Lafayette for me. Vermillionville has French speakers as well. There are a couple of French meetups in the Baton Rouge area as well.

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#103
I find it to be a sizeable crock.

Look through the descriptions of the regions. Some are lauded for 'valuing education', 'hard work', etc. Others are tied to slavery, are "intensely suspicious", and so on.

This is a bunch of sorry tropes that don't hold water. It would have been just as easy to characterize the lauded regions as homeless poop-havens and the other parts 'eco-friendly' because the tree-to-human ratio is so much better.

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#104
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Switzerland seems to be doing OK as a counterexample. Its cantons have a high level of self-government and a history as independent states and cultures. Yet Switzerland is a prosperous country with a strong national identity and minimal talk of secession by the cantons.

Smaller countries are far less likely to suffer from secessionist or identitarian agitations, especially small and wealthy countries like Switzerland. Comparison to Switzerland and similar countries is not instructive. This is especially true for language. Linguistic division within countries is often a source of tension, even in smaller countries. In larger countries, it is almost assuredly going to lead to tension,…

A counter example is India. Every state is divided along language and cultural lines. The individual states look more like countries in the EU. But there is no strong separatist movement.

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#105
post #43

The author hasn’t spent much time in Utah, if he didn’t split it out.

The article aggregates. But outside of Salt Lake City, what did the author miss? Nevada is different from Las Vegas as well. I was impressed with the north/south divide in Missouri and the east/west divide in Tennessee. However, I wouldn't put Santa Barbara, Los Angeles and San Diego in El Norte. The author may have had better reasons though.

The buzzing beehive? The state is predominantly LDS. It’s one step away from being a theocracy.

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#106
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article aggregates. But outside of Salt Lake City, what did the author miss? Nevada is different from Las Vegas as well. I was impressed with the north/south divide in Missouri and the east/west divide in Tennessee. However, I wouldn't put Santa Barbara, Los Angeles and San Diego in El Norte. The author may have had better reasons though.

The buzzing beehive? The state is predominantly LDS. It’s one step away from being a theocracy.

But there are strong patches of LDS in Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and Idaho. Harry Reid was LDS. Crapo and Udall are. I'd say LDS is an element of Far West culture in the way Protestantism is part of New England.

Re: The eleven nations of the United States and their cultures

#107
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The buzzing beehive? The state is predominantly LDS. It’s one step away from being a theocracy.

But there are strong patches of LDS in Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and Idaho. Harry Reid was LDS. Crapo and Udall are. I'd say LDS is an element of Far West culture in the way Protestantism is part of New England.

True, but there’s balance in the other states.
Post reply on HN