Live data from Hacker News

Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

drop.com

101–108 of 108 posts

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#101
post #96
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

very cool, and also the most 90s looking piece of electronics i've seen in a while

true! I'm very tempted to finish mine with custom airbrushed patina á la "abandoned soviet cold war bunker" :)

They sell different color cases.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/97hqt4...

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#102
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Personally for myself, I found the best option to be MS Natural 4000's backward tilt (down at the back)—I'd like it to tilt even more at low desk heights but oh well. That way, the wrists stay straight while the fingers drop downwards a bit, in a feeble emulation of Kinesis Advantage's pits. I even use a wrist brace sometimes, which pads the wrist on the palm's side giving even more of a raise—feels really great for…

On a tall desk with a low chair, a “backward” tilt to the keyboard almost inevitably causes some uncomfortable hand/arm positioning. If you have a high desk and low chair and you can’t change the furniture, you want the keyboard to be tilted (sometimes very aggressively) “forward” so that the plane of the keyboard is parallel to the plane of the forearms. The keyboard should be kept close to the torso so that the upp…

> My personal opinion is that the Kinesis Advantage is not the most biomechanically sound design

I agree. I use an Advantage, and while it's certainly better than traditional keyboards, I think it has a couple of flaws in terms of ergonomics:

• the keywells are not rotated inward and the distance between them is not adjustable. Therefore, unless your shoulder width is exactly right for this keyboard, you have to rotate your hands in- or outwards

• the thumb clusters are too far away. For me, if I relax my thumbs, they drop right in that little space between the space/backspace keys and the keywells.

• the thumb clusters are also too high, making it somewhat painful to rest the thumbs on the keys for longer periods of time

• the tenting angle is insufficient

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#103
post #49

I’ve wanted to make a keyboard, but I’m not sure it’s possible to make something materially better than the kinesis advantage. I switched to it 10 years after my hands would feel numb after typing. I think I might have some problem other people don’t, but even for normal people, I find it hard to believe that a kinesis wouldn’t be better for them as well. I’ve seen some split diy keyboards, but none of them have the…

Dactyl https://github.com/adereth/dactyl-keyboard is split and curved. Been thinking about building one, though I'd probably use wood as casing material and I know it will be a lot of work, so it may or may not materialize...

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#104
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Why are so many mechanical keyboards tiny? They don't want to spend the money for more switches? Yes, to some extent at least. But maybe more the pcb, plate, case etc. I have a pcb for a ms natural style keyboard (without the numpad) and the effective size is 40x15 cm (16x6 inches). Not that expensive to get in China, but I guess it is has also become fashion with smaller boards now. I think the whole thing sort of…

That sounds like exactly what I want. Are you selling a keyboard around it? I don't need the numpad, but after 10+ years of ms natural, I'm used to the remainder of the layout.

Unfortunately not in the foreseeable future. It is a couple of years old at this point, and I haven't really tested it either. I think you would also need palm rests to recreate the experience well enough.

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, increasing resistance has reduced my strain from typing. After a few minutes of typing, I start to bottom out less and less, and instead I feel like I have little shock absorbers under each key, reducing the impact of every press. As for the community, most seem to dislike high resistance switches, which is why my preference for MX Clears leaves me with few brands to purchase from, and my dream ideal of a h…

You can install some BKE Redux domes. I hate those, so you'll probably love them.

I actually like the domes as they are. What I want is, somehow, to increase the spring tension after the dome collapses, so that I don't slam into the baseplate.

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#106
post #49

I’ve wanted to make a keyboard, but I’m not sure it’s possible to make something materially better than the kinesis advantage. I switched to it 10 years after my hands would feel numb after typing. I think I might have some problem other people don’t, but even for normal people, I find it hard to believe that a kinesis wouldn’t be better for them as well. I’ve seen some split diy keyboards, but none of them have the…

> Being able to type your password with one button is super cool! Do you really have a button on your keyboard mapped to type your password? If that's the case, I'm horrified. But I secretely wish I had a button like that too...

You can have exactly that if you set your password to "a"!

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#107
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

true! I'm very tempted to finish mine with custom airbrushed patina á la "abandoned soviet cold war bunker" :)

They sell different color cases. https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/97hqt4...

yes, i have the yellow one. it looks awesome, but i'm really longing for some post-apocalyptic touches (think Metro rather than Fallout). don't have an airbrush though, nor do I know how to use one. So this will have to wait...

Re: Anatomy of a Mechanical Keyboard (2018)

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I have a keyboard with silent black MX switches and I never felt any need for clickyness. I had a red keyboard and I never felt that it was necessary. But then I got a blue and I would never go back. Just because the sound isn't necessary or helpful doesn't mean it's pleasing to have it. Like a big moon roof in a car, if you've never had one you may not really see the point, but once you get one the feeling of havi…

I'm having a little trouble following. Do I have this right: - blues are louder than reds - You had a red keyboard and you didn't think you needed the noise - but then you got the blue which was much louder and you enjoyed this If that's what you mean, what did you mean by this: >Just because the sound isn't necessary or helpful doesn't mean it's pleasing to have it. do you mean "just because it isn't necessary doesn…

I know a lot of people who dislike the reds, they give the least feedback of all the cherry MX switches (be it force feedback or acoustic feedback). They are basically very light linear switches.

They are however popular in gaming, because the linearity of the force curve allows for fast repeat rates. In fact they made a silver variant, which is basically a red switch with a shorter travel way.

Post reply on HN