Live data from Hacker News

The New ‘Dream Home’ Should Be a Condo

nytimes.com

101–104 of 104 posts

Re: The New ‘Dream Home’ Should Be a Condo

#101
post #96
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, they are, and that's why I responded by pointing out that consumers generally don't think about that factor, they only think about initial costs.

It's hard to blame consumers if they are buying the average sized homes for their area that are still huge in operational and maintenance costs. In most newer SFH developments, house size is usually dictated by exclusionary zoning (i.e minimum lot and house sizes) and developer business priorities, not by what is financially prudent for buyers. And as your SUV example illustrates, bigger sells better. Choosing not to…

The consumers are always at fault, as they're the ones with the purchasing power, and the voting power.

>And as your SUV example illustrates, bigger sells better.

There's no such thing as "vehicle zoning"; if consumers wanted to buy smaller vehicles, they're out there on the market. No one's forcing them to buy and drive huge SUVs.

>In most newer SFH developments, house size is usually dictated by exclusionary zoning (i.e minimum lot and house sizes) and developer business priorities, not by what is financially prudent for buyers.

This is controlled by the local government, which is controlled by the voters, who are the consumers.

They don't have these problems in Japan, because they don't have exclusionary zoning. If you own the lot, you can build whatever the heck you want on it, and the neighbors have no power to stop you.

Re: The New ‘Dream Home’ Should Be a Condo

#102
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again, you didn't answer my question. Who exactly are you going to get them to vote for, if you don't like the guy who's running the place now? And yes, talking to 50 neighbors sounds like a big PITA to me, when you aren't even on the board and don't have a way to contact everyone and arrange a meeting; you'll have to go door-to-door and hope to catch people when they're home. That's a significant project. You don't…

What do you mean, I didn't answer your question? I am volunteering, yes. I literally already do this. I would tell them to vote for me. I am very aware of what being on a HOA requires because I already do it and yes I think it is not that hard. So to be clear: ME. (I might use magical technology like mailboxes to facilitate asynchronous communication if I didn't already have access to the email address of every homeo…

>I would tell them to vote for me. I am very aware of what being on a HOA requires because I already do it and yes I think it is not that hard. So to be clear: ME.

Maybe you're willing to volunteer your time for another job, but I'm not. Moreover, I'm under no illusion that people would vote for me; I'm not highly charismatic.

So who is someone like me supposed to get people to vote for? Where's this magic person in every subdivision who has the time and talent to take on this thankless job? Your solution doesn't scale.

Re: The New ‘Dream Home’ Should Be a Condo

#103

Granted I only skimmed the article, but it seemed rather myopic to me. Why is the "dream home" assumed to be in an urban/suburban area? Why not in a small town or rural area? In January 2018, we moved back from Charlottesville, VA (which itself isn't even "urban") to Harrison, AR. I was able to buy a five bedroom, two bath home on a half acre in a quiet neighborhood for under $125k. My wife and I are beginning to put…

Not many people outside of HN have opportunities for remote work. Most people don't want to be trapped into a situation where there's only one dominant employer in their area.
Post reply on HN