Live data from Hacker News

'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

npr.org

101–110 of 110 posts

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Worry about your own problems. > men, men, more men So should we worry about our own problems, or about men's problems?

Our own. I'm a man and virtually everyone here is a man too.

> virtually everyone here is a man too.

Unsurprisnig when we consider the absolutely toxic arseholes who flood threads like these.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calling blood "the symbol of the period" is overreaching a bit. Keep in mind that the blood drop was the only thing the Unicode working group accepted. The more explicit symbol was more popular in the UK but rejected by the Unicode folks. If you're uncomfortable with a blood drop emoji being used in this way maybe you should direct your discomfort at the Unicode folks.

I'm not uncomfortable with a blood drop emoji being used this way. I'm calling the activists stupid for saying that this very general symbol is specifically symbolic of menstruation.

They haven't said that though. You misread the article.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#103
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the first place it is sad that "emojis", "emoticons", etc. are so broadly used. It only shows how writing skills are deteriorating. Mark Twain or Hemingway didn't need emojis to express sadness or humor.

Are you kidding? Pictures and "emojis" are far more informationally dense than words are. If anything this shows how quickly language is evolving when facilitated by instantaneous information transfer of near unlimited amounts of data.

Which is why we have standards for conveying any conceivable image in raster or vector form.

Instead of selecting an easily compressible format for embedding any small image inline with text, we're trying to force a writing system into a kind of general-purpose icon library.

We could've had a world where carriers and phone manufacturers each had their own "common" images easily entered from some list like now, but still allowing cross-platform transmission without information loss, and enabling users to easily add their own custom images.

Now Unicode is stuck trying to define a finite set of popular words which every platform renders slightly differently, and will always leave something out or offend someone.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#104
post #23

I'm not sure I understand why people think that we should add the other emojis that were suggested. Emojis are in no way supposed to represent every single thing that you could possibly want to talk about; that's why many of them end up representing other things based on context (for example, the eggplant or peach emojis). The blood emoji is fine, but the soiled underwear is just…weird. That would be like asking for…

This isn't "every single thing that you could possibly want to talk about". This is something that half of the world population experiences roughly monthly for some number of years. Certainly it's more frequently experienced than the emojis - though I appreciate those. So it's clearly something that should exist. The underwear might seem odd but it's no weirder than the smiling poop emoji...

And 100% of the world's population has an ass, but we're still stuck with the peach emoji.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#105
post #97
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Code inflation" talks about programs expanding even when they already can do everything needed (e.g. true going from empty to 8k bytes). That's not the case here. These combinations didn't exist before, so the functionality is expanded, not just the code size.

I love emoji but they aren't needed for anything. You can always discuss periods using ordinary words. I have to admit that whilst emoji are fun the apparently endless growth in them combined with the way they break essentially every assumed invariant about text and thus create explosions of bugs all over previously working software is ... a bit concerning. At this point, why not just define a set of code points that…

> embed an SVG into the character stream

I really think that we should've gone this direction as soon as it became clear people would never be satisfied with any finite set of emoji. SVG might be a bit verbose for transmission over SMS, so there's room for figuring out some simplified and more compact encoding, but this would've prevented the almost all the problems we're having with emojis today.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#106

While countries with traditional ideograph-based languages (China, Japan, etc) are slowly turning to the alphabet to simplify their written language, we are reinventing ideographs, poorly and politically. Quite fascinating, but also incredibly sad.

Actually, it's more like hieroglyphics.[0]

0) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gardiner's_sign_list

Edit: And there are tons of Unicode characters.[1]

1) https://www.unicode.org/charts/PDF/U13000.pdf

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#107
post #80

While countries with traditional ideograph-based languages (China, Japan, etc) are slowly turning to the alphabet to simplify their written language, we are reinventing ideographs, poorly and politically. Quite fascinating, but also incredibly sad.

No. A) Emojis are better ideographs than CJK characters, not poorer ones. This is a horse, recognisably: [imagine the horse emoji here... :-) ]. This not so much in my view: 馬. B) Nobody is proposing to replace all words with hackneyed emojis. (“Although” sort of sounds like “old owl”, so let’s replace it by an owl with gray hair, maybe sitting on top of a mouth so we can disambiguate it from a reference to an owl.)…

Egyptian hieroglyph for "horse": https://en.wikipedia.org/w/extensions/wikihiero/img/hiero_E6...

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#109
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. That's when I disconnect from the discussion. I think everyone deserves an equal stab at life. Nobody should be discriminated against for their beliefs or what's in their trousers... But the methods used by some to reach that end are appalling. Equality isn't accomplished by publicly shaming everyone for every little social infraction. It deliberately excludes the people you need to improve to achieve equali…

> That's when I disconnect from the discussion. That might be good for you, but each rational being we lose in the fight against extremism weakens our overall chances of escaping this madness within our lifetimes. If someone tells me I shouldn't be participating in a discussion about womens' or transgender rights because I'm a cis white male, walking away from the discussion doesn't do anything. It's like quitting yo…

I don't disagree that moderates are required, but —as you highlight— these causes can only police themselves. Anything else is seen as an attack on the cause itself.

It'd be great if our humanity allowed us to accept criticism and contradiction at face value, but that is demonstrably not the case.

I don't know a way around this.

Re: 'Drop of Blood' Emoji, Symbol of the Period, Is Praised by Activists

#110
post #30
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The existence of this story and any flaws that may or may not exist in it do not represent the state of journalism as a whole.

Actually they do; this kind of click-bait yellow journalism has become the norm, not the exception. From Breitbart to Huffington Post, they all do it.

Neither Beritbart nor Huffington post are particularly reputable journalistic outlets, they're both at the extremes of the political spectrum. My point is that you can't condemn the entire discipline of journalism based on a single story.
Post reply on HN