Live data from Hacker News

Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

daringfireball.net

101–110 of 177 posts

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#101
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd argue that if the competitors didn't have Android, the tablets would just run on x86 processors. And run either windows or linux. I believe that the presence of ARM early in this market is actually good on the OS side, because it doesn't lead to shoehorning windows onto a tablet. x86 tablets aren't going to succeed both because of the pressure to run desktop OSes, but also because x86 processor companies only see…

With the failure of Linux netbooks, I don't think it'd do any better on tablets, ARM or x86.

I never said it was going to do any better.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#102
post #88
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> - significantly better battery life than any Windows lapt I've ever seen (due in part to software admittedly); My 11 month old Acer Timeline gets me 8+ hours of battery life with constant Wifi use. I easily work full days without recharges.

Your Acer Timeline also uses a CULV (Ultra Low Voltage) CPU. Apples and oranges. Find me a Core 2 Duo (non-ULV) or i3/i5/i7 laptop with equivalent battery life. The Timelines are a good budget laptop and much better than the Atom-based netbooks (imho). Personally I prefer the Asus UL30A (etc) range but that's really nitpicking.

Thanks for teaching me something new today. I did not mean to criticize your arguments on why MBP is a great choice. I just had a personal counter-example to the laptop battery point. Now that you explained why, it makes the reason more evident.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#103
post #99
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The industry has changed and is continuing to change into a world that suits Apple better. Getting in early and big (eg iphones & ipads) is letting them influence the change even more in their favour. What caught my eye in this article was: "Nobody knows what kind of CPU they have in their phones." That's a world that suits Apple. Interestingly, PCs are unique in that people take an interest in components. Do people…

What you're describing is essentially the computer turning into an appliance, and I agree this is what Apple is gaining tremendously from (and of course encouraging). I think you'd find that most enthusiasts or hobbyists have in-depth knowledge of the components of their hobby and that "computer people" are no different. Most people have no idea what is inside their computer - I think the majority of PC owners don't…

I don't how "appliance" became the way people describe this, but yeah.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#104
post #23

The 2nd paragraph: "Now, even putting quality aside, competitors can’t match Apple’s prices." Does not jive with the prices mentioned later: Apple Ipad - $599/$699 for the 16/32 GB models Samsung Galaxy S - $594 HTC A8181 Desire - $527 I don't know what the author's definition of "match" is, but seems to me Android tablet makers have matched prices quite well. *Edit: fixed my formatting

His definition of "match" seems to be device dimensions, performance, and battery life. Juxtaposing the iPad with a smartphone in an attempt to compare the prices doesn't seem right (you linked to an HTC A8181, but mentioned the Galaxy S). Did you mean to compare it to the Tab?

The author is the one comparing to Galaxy S, I was just pointing out:

"These prices compare quite well to the competition. The Samsung Galaxy S — a decent choice for the current “Best Android Phone on the Market” title (check back next week, though) — costs about $600 unlocked from Amazon, and only has only 8 GB of built-in storage. The HTC Desire costs just under $600. Google’s Nexus One, while they were selling it, cost $529."

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#105
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point, you should probably remember that Android came out 2 years ago and managed to overtake the iPhone in that short time frame. I highly doubt Apple will have even a plularity (let alone a majority) of the tablet market in 2 years.

> At this point, you should probably remember that Android came out 2 years ago and managed to overtake the iPhone in that short time frame. I highly doubt Apple will have even a plularity (let alone a majority) of the tablet market in 2 years. More Android devices are sold than iPhones, yes. Add the iPod Touch to that and I'm pretty sure Apple still has a substantial lead (and possibly growing). Also, how many of th…

Only 30% of iOS devices are iPod Touch. At android's growth rate, that'll maybe stave it off a quarter or two.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#106
Apple priced iPad very aggressively. No question about this. This is a brand new product category and Apple wanted to own it, and priced it that competitors find hard to compete. In fact, Jobs had warned about this, saying margins with iPad will be lower (i.e. no Apple tax). It was on the strength of this comment that I bought an iPad, something I would not normally do. In contrast, all the Windows tablet systems are still priced in the 3k mark.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#107

First, Apple is the world’s leading volume buyer of a precious, expensive component: flash storage. They get better prices and priority availability from suppliers. Do they get better prices than Samsung? Because Samsung is who designs and makes the flash memory. (Also, Wikipedia seems to say that Sony buys more than Apple.)

If Apple has a long-standing contract for deliveries of flash, Samsung probably can't easily say that they'd prefer to keep the flash memory for use in their own gadgets. Considering that at times Apple has placed orders for more than half of Samsung's annual output, such a contract is likely to exist.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#108
post #87
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And this, ladies and gentlemen, just proves Gruber's argument that many people buy PCs based on bullet point specs having never seen the enclosure. With MacBook Pros you get: - a backlit keyboard with ambient light sensor; - a high quality display; - significantly better battery life than any Windows lapt I've ever seen (due in part to software admittedly); - the best trackpad I've seen on any laptop ever (seriously.…

I've seen a lot of MBPs. I've used them. They're really nice. I don't dispute that at all. My Fedora/Win7 laptop has a backlit keyboard, stunning display, and a great industrial design with an aluminum body. The trackpad is dodgy and the battery life isn't as good as an MBP's, but it also has two batteries that are user-swappable. It doesn't run OS X. It also has HDMI out and a Blu-Ray drive, two "premium" features y…

What laptop is that, may I ask? I'm in the market for a new one.

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#109

The 2nd paragraph: "Now, even putting quality aside, competitors can’t match Apple’s prices." Does not jive with the prices mentioned later: Apple Ipad - $599/$699 for the 16/32 GB models Samsung Galaxy S - $594 HTC A8181 Desire - $527 I don't know what the author's definition of "match" is, but seems to me Android tablet makers have matched prices quite well. *Edit: fixed my formatting

For the record, the iPad is $499/$599 for 16/32 GB (WiFi) models, not $599/$699 as you stated:

www.apple.com/ipad

http://store.apple.com/us/browse/home/shop_ipad/family/ipad?...

Re: Daring Fireball: Apple's Pricing Advantage

#110
apple tax is no more in price of the device, as those are cheap for apple now.

Apple tax today is control!

While mobiles are moving farther from the locked-in model (i get my phones unlocked for some 5 yrs, and before that, used to unlock them) apple is moving computers to it.

An apple store on the desktop, with DRMed software, is a full circle to mainframe in computer history.

Heck! the iphone, with subsided price along with mandatory monthly bills and approved catalog of software and only one choice of network is already as close the main frame as you can get!

It would be interesting to compare the at&t iphone contract with a 70's IBM mainframe lease one. anybody has one around? :)

Post reply on HN