Live data from Hacker News

My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

themission.co

101–110 of 159 posts

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#101
post #3

Problem number one, that girl in the opening picture has a ring on her left hand. Perhaps try again with single girls?

It's a stock photo, you're reading into it too much. I doubt the guy went on a date and then asked the gal to strike a pose: "I'm writing an article about how I'm dating 150 girls, can you please pose for a photograph?"

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#102
> I’m a fat, bald, short guy whose only quality is that he isn’t an ax murderer... But I’m bad at small talk, and I jump too fast to intellectual conversations, making it awkward.

None of the engineering addressed root causes. Solve the confidence first, and then hack your way to a better physique, and maybe pick up some interests that are universal and easy to chat about.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#103
post #36

From my friend group there are two types of individuals: 1. Individuals who date many people, breaking up if they find something non-optimal. These include minor things like, not cleaning up on occasion, or not liking something you do. 2. Someone who dates very few (1-3) individuals, sticking with them until a serious, fatal flaw appears, like being racist or physically harming others, etc. If you define a successful…

What about people who date few individuals (2-3), break up 1-2 times and their partners were neither closet racists nor violent nor anything that grave. That would describe majority of people I know.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#104
post #89

Ehh... the issue is mostly that online dating doesn't go very well for the vast, vast majority of people. On the other hand, I know plenty of not-particularly-attractive people who've met partners through all sorts of weird and whacky situations. Fact of the matter is that finding potential partners, like finding anyone, is about constantly growing the network of people you interact with. I meet new people nearly eve…

In my opinion going on a date is also too big of an investment to find out whether or not you 'match' with somebody. When you are at a party you can potentially speak to 10 (20 maybe even 30) women/men in one night, and probably find out that you do not match with 90% of them. If you are using apps like Tinder it will take you 10 nights to date 10 women/men, which is a significantly bigger time investment. Recently I…

I suppose it's a compromise. Using your example, a LOT of people simply don't enjoy going to parties with rooms full of people to try and talk to maybe 30 women/men in one night. Sometimes they find it boring, sometimes they get anxious, sometimes they find it intimidating and wouldn't know how to signal interest without being weird (parties can be confusing that way; most people aren't there to meet a date or hook up). Contrast it with Tinder and similar apps: while people sometimes pretend "a friend installed Tinder on my phone, I never use it!", everyone knows what everyone else is there for, and what they're signalling when they swipe right or start chatting with someone.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#105
post #31

Not a bad strategy even if it didn't work, dating is often purely a numbers game. Meet as many people as possible, be as social as possible, create as many opportunities to meet new people as possible. Also if you're a single male and you want to meet a female partner, I'd recommend moving away from the west coast. The south and midwest have far more women, and a generally friendlier culture which can make the entire…

The women in the South are generally far more religious and conservative. West-coast men might not be too interested in that stuff. The "friendlier culture" of the South thing is a myth. They're not that friendly to people who don't fit their preferred mold. Source: grew up in the South. There's a reason so many young people move out of the South as soon as they can.

> The "friendlier culture" of the South thing is a myth. They're not that friendly to people who don't fit their preferred mold.

Heh... Ain't that the truth.

Completely anecdotally, I got a LOT more Tinder matches when I was in the West/East Coast than in my home state of Texas (I'm a Nonwhite Male).

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#106
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Also, speaking personally... the sort of person who thinks it's fun to spend their time automating personal interaction is not the sort of person I want to date. forgive me for waxing poetical but i've thought about this a lot - since i have tinder and okcupid accounts - online dating is one of the most nihilistic enterprises to come out of the digital revolution. take one of the most personally rewarding and edifyi…

>online dating is one of the most nihilistic enterprises >approaching people you're attracted to (not on the street you pua twats) is one of the few "scary" things still available to us as denizens of modernity Online dating is good for people who simply have NO other avenue to meet people. If you're not supposed to try to pick up people on the street, then where would you apply this advice? Work? I don't know about…

"Extracurricular activities? Sure, but the number of single women at these things tends to be pretty small,"

Different extracurricular activities? Like dancing class or climbing - both being social and popular among women.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#107
post #35

Step 1, for success, is moving away from the Bay Area.

> Step 1, for success, is moving away from the west coast FTFY. I'm not joking either, for straight single men they will certainly have better odds in the midwest or south. Demographics plus minor cultural differences matter.

Not true. LA definitely has a lot of the kind of women that nerdy engineers like: career focused, successful, intelligent etc.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#108
post #3

Problem number one, that girl in the opening picture has a ring on her left hand. Perhaps try again with single girls?

It's a stock photo, you're reading into it too much. I doubt the guy went on a date and then asked the gal to strike a pose: "I'm writing an article about how I'm dating 150 girls, can you please pose for a photograph?"

He did online dating, meaning all the girls had already published their photos in the internet before he met them. Just right click and "Save as" would do the trick, if he really wanted to include real photos in the article :)

But yes, I also think that's a stock photo.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#109
post #78
post #51

It's like the programmer who applies to 150 jobs. The programmer cannot do the research on all 150 so the interviews lack the personal connection. Far better to focus on the 10 you really want do the research and put in the effort to really wow the interviewer.

> Far better to focus on the 10 you really want do the research and put in the effort to really wow the interviewer. Sounds like you haven't been on online dating before.

I have and been successful but maybe things have changed in the last 10 years.

You never meet someone right away, first you instant message on the platform. At some point you move into a chat program offsite and in a month you started talking on the phone. 6 months later you meet. Over that half year you develop a friendship when you meet you have tons to talk about. The buildup adds excitement and unless you look nothing like your picture your looks are already accepted and seeing you in person increases that attraction.

If you try to rush the process you better have outstanding physical qualities or great style or money or luck because every relationship needs a base. You are better off going to a local minecraft meetup. Everyone attending will feel they have someone in common and you can build off of that.

Start by building a low risk relationship with daily contact points. That will create the base for a successful friendship which is what you need for a successful relationship.

Re: My Failed Attempt at Engineering Love

#110
post #51

It's like the programmer who applies to 150 jobs. The programmer cannot do the research on all 150 so the interviews lack the personal connection. Far better to focus on the 10 you really want do the research and put in the effort to really wow the interviewer.

Online dating has the wrinkle that focusing on the 10 you really want and putting in the effort to really wow the interviewer doesn't always produce a higher success rate. The rise of Tinder has accentuated this.
Post reply on HN