Live data from Hacker News

Nevertheless, She Coded

dev.to

101–110 of 398 posts

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#101
post #6

Virtue Signalling and attempting to divide the genders in the opening, before the quotes from women in tech. I expect better from The Practical Dev, you don't have to paint men in a derogatory light to bring up women.

The phrase "Virtue Signaling", along with "SJWs" and "AllLivesMatter" are signals that the person using them doesn't actually understand what's going on, and likely does not want to understand, and wants things to stay the way they are.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#102
post #6

Virtue Signalling and attempting to divide the genders in the opening, before the quotes from women in tech. I expect better from The Practical Dev, you don't have to paint men in a derogatory light to bring up women.

PSA: at this point, making comments complaining about "virtue signalling" is virtue signalling. And I suggest investing in new talking points -- "this is just as (insert -ism) as what they're fighting against" has been retired.

So if A are fighting against B on behalf of C, but are doing B to D, we're supposed to just keep silent because you say that "talking point" has been "retired"?

I don't think so...

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#103
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Equality scares people when inequality is all they have to lean on. It makes them do strange things to re-frame discussions.

The problem is that this turns into women demanding equal pay for inferior work. If their boss thinks they don't do as good work, why should they get paid the same? And who are you to decide how good the person is at working? Experience and education are not the sole determiners of a persons efficiency

How do you know they didn't do as good of work? You and I both know that objectively judging "quality of work" in this industry is extremely difficult, and more often it just comes down to someone's biased opinion.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#104
If ever I had a notion that an expression of solidarity for women in tech was unnecessary or quixotic, the response to this article on this very forum would be sufficient to dispel it.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#105

I'm frankly quite surprised by the initial wave of comments disparaging this message. The facts are that women are poorly represented in the tech community[1], and do make less than men[2]. Any attempt to let women feel more accepted and bring about much needed change should be championed, not picked apart and belittled because you feel like you are personally being attacked when people are just asking for help. 1. h…

You really have to ask yourself: Why would women, as a cohort, make the same amount per individual as men? Do you assume that nothing can be different enough between men and women to reasonably justify the statistics? I know of women who are paid more than me in tech, and I know why. I know of women who are paid less than me, and I can think of n reasons why. As for sheer numbers, ask yourself: are there any industri…

> As for sheer numbers, ask yourself: are there any industries where there are considerably fewer men than women? The answer is, of course, yes. Look at nursing.

Do the men employed as nurses make less money on average than their women colleagues?

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#106
post #8
post #4

"continued pay disparity" here we go...

It would be interesting to see the data on this. I've worked in software development for 20 years and hired tons of people (maybe over 100). I think that professional jobs have the lowest pay disparity. I would imagine it's really hard to measure the pay gap between programmers because there are literally coders that are 2x or 5x more productive than other coders. So I don't think it's as simple as checking all the p…

I've seen data local to my country that had showed it, but the problem was they grouped all IT workers together. Withe first level technical support being much more gender neutral you couldn't really read much into it.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#107
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.cnet.com/news/biggest-pay-gap-in-america-compute...

This is all self-reported and not-representative data. So while an interesting story, is not evidence of a pay gap. There should be a statistical paper with a proper analysis somewhere, I'll try looking for it.

It's not proof of a pay gap, but it's evidence of a pay gap.

Loads of other evidence of a pay gap is trivially available. I won't entertain the ignorance articulated here on that. You can Google. But I will add an aside that is less obvious.

It's entirely possible to have perfectly even pay between every member of your team and still have an overall pay gap if you don't have good diversity in the upper levels of your organization. Many otherwise very good and well-meaning organizations fall prey to this.

My position for example, as a distributed systems engineer, is very hard to get into. You don't learn about it in college, you don't find a ton of great books about it, and the field changes rapidly using terms and concepts that were only recently overturned. The way I got into it: a pair of very smart men decided to mentor me when I was younger.

But were it not for that apprenticeship/mentorship, I would not be in the field. Women claim they have fewer opportunities for this and that follows with my observations. Therefore, my (higher paying and more in-demand) position is more difficult for many women to acquire.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#108

I'm frankly quite surprised by the initial wave of comments disparaging this message. The facts are that women are poorly represented in the tech community[1], and do make less than men[2]. Any attempt to let women feel more accepted and bring about much needed change should be championed, not picked apart and belittled because you feel like you are personally being attacked when people are just asking for help. 1. h…

Perhaps there are disparaging comments because people love to quote misleading statistics... kind of just like you did.

From the glassdoor wage gap study you mentioned in [2]:

> After taking into account differences in education and experience, men working at tech companies overall make 5.9 percent more than women do

From a brief scan of the study they didn't control for hours worked and they are already down to 5.9%

Since full-time men work 5% longer than full-time women[3] just adjusting for hours worked almost entirely eliminates the gap.

[3] https://www.forbes.com/sites/karinagness/2016/06/30/new-repo...

Edit: Sorry I put the overall adjusted US pay gap of 5.4% when I meant to put the adjusted tech pay gap of 5.9% from the glassdoor study.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#109
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's the little things. For example, the inclusion of Elizabeth Warren and McConnell's line. What McConnell did (attempt to shut down resistance of the opposite party) was wrong-headed and undemocratic, but the only thing it had to do with gender was the use of a pronoun (edit: yodon is right). Nobody would have paid much attention to it if he'd said "nevertheless he persisted", but a partisan attack was made into so…

"What McConnell did (attempt to shut down resistance of the opposite party) was wrong-headed and undemocratic, but the only thing it had to do with gender was the use of a pronoun" If that were true, then why were the several men who spoke after her, and read the exact same letter, not disciplined?

They did not read the part that McConnell objected to as that was already read by Warren.

Re: Nevertheless, She Coded

#110
Also because the issue essentially doesnt exist. A victim complex is a real thing and there are real victims. You must acknowledge both, not just the latter (or just the former for that matter.)

Sexism is real but severely overblown in my experience.

Post reply on HN