Live data from Hacker News

LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

engadget.com

101–110 of 177 posts

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#101
post #64

Interesting phone, horrible article. Typical of the modern Engadget, the article is light on facts and heavy on superlatives. For instance, I had to head over to some random Android website (androidHeadlines) to find out that yes, it does have Micro SD card support, and that it has 32GB of built-in storage (pathetic, Engadget). I do really like the idea of extensive expandability, but I wish it could be standardized…

We can change the URL to that one if people agree that it's better.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#102
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is why phone makers should make some variety here. Make thin phones for people who prioritize size, make thick phones for people who prioritize battery life. I'm not saying every single phone on the planet should be the kind I want....

On the plus side, you can always stick a bulky battery case onto a thin phone. Now if only there were more variety in phones with small screens; now that iPhones are big, what are people with small hands supposed to buy?

> On the plus side, you can always stick a bulky battery case onto a thin phone.

That depends on a third party bothering to make a case for the device at all.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#103
post #2

I'm so glad LG are sticking with a switchable battery - it's a must have feature for me. Lots of people have forgotten what it's like to grab a wall-charged battery, slip it in and run out the door with 100% power in a few seconds. Tethering your phone to the wall sucks. Clunky portable battery packs are the worst. I hope this phone sells well, it has my support.

Honestly that sounds rubbish compared to just having a phone with a decent battery life in the first place. I used to think it was impossible (I had a Nexus 4) but my Z3C has an impressively good battery life - so much so that I rarely think about it. I don't even bother plugging it in for satnav duties. Also it charges at a pretty decent rate - probably takes an hour to fully charge from 0%. Battery swapping is a wo…

Depends how long you plan to keep your phone. Lithium-ion cells have finite lifespans, and if you plan to keep your phone for years at a time, or if (like me) you tend to purchase slightly older phones, removable batteries are a godsend.

FWIW, though I'm not happy about the non-removable battery, I currently use a Nexus 4. It's gotten worse over time, but I used to be able to comfortably get about 2 days of runtime on a full charge. Now it's about a full day, though it sometimes needs a little help if I'm in an area where reception is weak.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#104
post #95

I wonder if the bootloader will be unlockable. I've been spoiled by Nexus devices for years and I remember how much work the Galaxy S3 I briefly owned was. What's LG's track record like with releasing sources? Nexus devices don't count.

Looking around on forums like XDA, one sees that LG typically has different models depending on the market. The tech specs are identical, but it has more to do with carrier branding and lockdown. For instance, in markets such as the EU, LG G4 shipped with an unlockable bootloader while in the US and Asia it was not. Workarounds and custom ROMs exist, but you also see plenty of stories about bricked phones. Put simply…

Sigh. I wish I could love the Nexus 5X, but it just didn't represent a big enough jump to justify a 2x price difference from the 5 (in Australia).

I'm not sure who "lg-devs" are, but they seem to have a full source tree for the G4 at https://github.com/lg-devs/android_device_lge_h811. No idea if it boots, though.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly that sounds rubbish compared to just having a phone with a decent battery life in the first place. I used to think it was impossible (I had a Nexus 4) but my Z3C has an impressively good battery life - so much so that I rarely think about it. I don't even bother plugging it in for satnav duties. Also it charges at a pretty decent rate - probably takes an hour to fully charge from 0%. Battery swapping is a wo…

Depends how long you plan to keep your phone. Lithium-ion cells have finite lifespans, and if you plan to keep your phone for years at a time, or if (like me) you tend to purchase slightly older phones, removable batteries are a godsend. FWIW, though I'm not happy about the non-removable battery, I currently use a Nexus 4. It's gotten worse over time, but I used to be able to comfortably get about 2 days of runtime o…

[deleted]

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly that sounds rubbish compared to just having a phone with a decent battery life in the first place. I used to think it was impossible (I had a Nexus 4) but my Z3C has an impressively good battery life - so much so that I rarely think about it. I don't even bother plugging it in for satnav duties. Also it charges at a pretty decent rate - probably takes an hour to fully charge from 0%. Battery swapping is a wo…

Depends how long you plan to keep your phone. Lithium-ion cells have finite lifespans, and if you plan to keep your phone for years at a time, or if (like me) you tend to purchase slightly older phones, removable batteries are a godsend. FWIW, though I'm not happy about the non-removable battery, I currently use a Nexus 4. It's gotten worse over time, but I used to be able to comfortably get about 2 days of runtime o…

Well, if you're talking about giving an old phone a new lease on life with a replacement battery as a once-in-a-lifetime service operation, it's fine to break out the tools to replace the battery.

If you do battery swaps as a nightly workflow so you can have a day battery and a night battery, then yeah pop-out replacement is the only option

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Android 6 (the version of Android that is installed on the device this thread is about) SD cards with high enough speeds can be adopted onto the system storage and the combined size appears as a single block of internal storage to apps, they don't know they're running off an SD Card.

I'm iffy about that adoption system, as it also makes the cards useless as removable/swappable storage. This because the adoption process formats and encrypts the card, thus anything stored on it can only be accessed from within the device that adopted it.

With SD cards so cheap nowadays I don't see why this should even be an issue.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#108
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depends how long you plan to keep your phone. Lithium-ion cells have finite lifespans, and if you plan to keep your phone for years at a time, or if (like me) you tend to purchase slightly older phones, removable batteries are a godsend. FWIW, though I'm not happy about the non-removable battery, I currently use a Nexus 4. It's gotten worse over time, but I used to be able to comfortably get about 2 days of runtime o…

Well, if you're talking about giving an old phone a new lease on life with a replacement battery as a once-in-a-lifetime service operation, it's fine to break out the tools to replace the battery. If you do battery swaps as a nightly workflow so you can have a day battery and a night battery, then yeah pop-out replacement is the only option

While it is of course possible to replace the battery in most phones with specialized tools, for some of the newer models it's very difficult to do without damaging the device. When we're talking about a phone you just bought on eBay with the intention of making it your daily driver, that's a hard sell.

All other things equal, I will always pick the slightly thicker phone with a removable battery over the one that might have me breaking out the spudger.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#109
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, if you're talking about giving an old phone a new lease on life with a replacement battery as a once-in-a-lifetime service operation, it's fine to break out the tools to replace the battery. If you do battery swaps as a nightly workflow so you can have a day battery and a night battery, then yeah pop-out replacement is the only option

While it is of course possible to replace the battery in most phones with specialized tools, for some of the newer models it's very difficult to do without damaging the device. When we're talking about a phone you just bought on eBay with the intention of making it your daily driver, that's a hard sell. All other things equal, I will always pick the slightly thicker phone with a removable battery over the one that mi…

The specialized tools are a tiny screwdriver and a plastic pry knife on some phones - the adhesive doesn't come in until screen replacement. You can buy battery replacement kits with that stuff included.

Re: LG G5 modular phone: Hi-Fi DAC, battery slide out, connection interface

#110
post #58

I think its good of LG to design a phone that is good for the environment in the sense that users can swap the battery and upgrade the storage instead of having to buy a whole new phone when those run out of capacity. Global warming dictates that we as consumers not only our politicians are responsible for the future we create. If manufacturers can help make devices that last longer I´m going to choose such a device…

I agree, I think phone manufacturers should be punished for not making batteries replaceable and contributing to waste. Having a few screws to get to a battery is OK but gluing it in such a way that it requires special tools is just idiotic. Same goes for laptops.
Post reply on HN