Live data from Hacker News

Light-based computers in development

kutv.com

11–16 of 16 posts

Re: Light-based computers in development

#11
post #4

> The key advantage of light, made of photo[n]s, is it’s the fastest thing you can use to transfer information according to the professor. I wish people would stop spreading this exaggeration. ~~Electrons~~ Electronic signals move at 0.66c. In practice 1c is unlikely to provide the most significant gains. The key benefit is actually the energy efficiency that the article barely mentions, as well as massive reduction…

You're right that there's a pretty limited benefit to simple signal transmission, but when it comes to switching and capacitance, there could very well be more significant gains.

Re: Light-based computers in development

#12

> Light-based computers in development, to be millions of times faster When will we see this millions time faster computers commercially available? Maybe around the time when the thousands-times faster internet and 100 times larger batteries from articles I read years ago are available...

Are you being optimistic or pessimistic? It's only been 15-20 years since 56kb dialup was the norm, and Tesla are doing pretty well at the moment.

Re: Light-based computers in development

#13

> Light-based computers in development, to be millions of times faster When will we see this millions time faster computers commercially available? Maybe around the time when the thousands-times faster internet and 100 times larger batteries from articles I read years ago are available...

it's research and it's still valuable, even though yours truly might not yet be able to buy it at fry's yet.

some research might become available on the end-user, some won't. Often HN worthy stuff isn't really end-user though.

For me personally, it's good enough if it manages to inspire and interest others.

Re: Light-based computers in development

#14

> Light-based computers in development, to be millions of times faster When will we see this millions time faster computers commercially available? Maybe around the time when the thousands-times faster internet and 100 times larger batteries from articles I read years ago are available...

Are you being optimistic or pessimistic? It's only been 15-20 years since 56kb dialup was the norm, and Tesla are doing pretty well at the moment.

Not pessimistic about technology, but about exaggerated article titles :)

Re: Light-based computers in development

#15

The main problem is still getting strong optical nonlinearity to build optical only transistors. Right now best case 1 in 100 photons will be affected by most "switches". There's been some research using various resonators to enhance the nonlinearities, but that's really the big problem to solve right now. There's also scaling issues - we have 20nm electrical switches, which is almost 50 times smaller than the wavele…

If efficiency is vastly improved, we can stack the layers and increase frequency by quite a bit. Even if the processor becomes a 10cm x 10cm x 10cm cube, it's okay as a proof of concept. It's an interesting approach to overcome the inherient limitations of electron based circuits.

Again, right now 1 in 100 photons will interact with an optical switch. This effect multiplies with each level of transistors. This means you have to "run" your circuit potentially something like 10^100 times to get all of the transistors in your path to work on the same photon.

That's pretty rough.

Re: Light-based computers in development

#16

> Light-based computers in development, to be millions of times faster When will we see this millions time faster computers commercially available? Maybe around the time when the thousands-times faster internet and 100 times larger batteries from articles I read years ago are available...

Soon I hope, I want to write software that runs a million times as slow.
Post reply on HN