Live data from Hacker News

Why would a front-end developer on OS X use any editor besides BBEdit?

news.ycombinator.com

11–13 of 13 posts

Re: Why would a front-end developer on OS X use any editor besides BBEdit?

#11
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have the nasty feeling I'm being trolled, but ... try watching these to get a feel of what a proper programmable editor is capable of: * https://vimeo.com/13158054 * https://vimeo.com/30721952 Basically, the idea is that your editor becomes your entire world. News, email, chat, source control, code, running code ... everything merges into the one system, and efficiency gains in one area tend to be applicable to oth…

not trying to "troll", my question was genuine, though i admit i could have phrased it more narrowly. personally i prefer not having to learn new keyboard shortcuts to style a todo list for example as that first video discusses. i just write it out, use an asterisk or some easy system to show points, outline levels or whatever. if it's important to get done that day i note that in plain text. this is faster and easie…

Ah, but that's just the point. Emacs doesn't do many things badly, it does many things better than the alternatives :)

E.g. take one case, recurring appointments. You can do the usual (monthly, weekly, etc.) or embed a snippet of Lisp code in your org-mode file; if it evaluates true when your agenda is being generated, then the item is deemed to be repeating that day.

So, let's say you want your calendar to contain an event if the weather is forecast to be over 40 degrees C on that particular day[1]. Easy if you're using org-mode, but basically impossible with every other system I've seen.

The point behind using a programmable editor is that their programmability allows you to extend them in ways that their original creators never intended. Whereas, say, a conventional email client is designed to be used in just the way its creators intended, and never extended.

I gave a presentation on this topic (the power of programmable UIs) a while back:

https://github.com/duncan-bayne/presentations/blob/master/pr...

Edited to add: in fact, lack of programmability is basically what's broken about modern computing environments. People are so used to software being non-programmable that they don't know what they're missing. It's no accident that even rudimentary programmable environments like Excel are so popular.

[1] ... which is a reasonable requirement for me; the work done by the systems I help to build is highly dependant upon weather.

Re: Why would a front-end developer on OS X use any editor besides BBEdit?

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

not trying to "troll", my question was genuine, though i admit i could have phrased it more narrowly. personally i prefer not having to learn new keyboard shortcuts to style a todo list for example as that first video discusses. i just write it out, use an asterisk or some easy system to show points, outline levels or whatever. if it's important to get done that day i note that in plain text. this is faster and easie…

Ah, but that's just the point. Emacs doesn't do many things badly, it does many things better than the alternatives :) E.g. take one case, recurring appointments. You can do the usual (monthly, weekly, etc.) or embed a snippet of Lisp code in your org-mode file; if it evaluates true when your agenda is being generated, then the item is deemed to be repeating that day. So, let's say you want your calendar to contain a…

well i don't care about appointments from my text editor... i think i should delete this question and re-phrase it more narrowly, unfortunately it seems it's impossible to delete.

Re: Why would a front-end developer on OS X use any editor besides BBEdit?

#13
post #9
post #7

Because front end is so much more than vanilla html css etc. You have Sass, handlebars, svg and more to deal with. If you only use the basics, maybe a simpler solution works for you. But calling the others into question just because they don't work for you is pedantic.

i deal with all of those - sass, handlebars, svg.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN