Live data from Hacker News

Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

boingboing.net

11–20 of 105 posts

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#11
I really appreciate that prosecutor Candina Heath used secret evidence to convict, played on FUD, and in particular made it illegal to merely link to certain publicly-available information.

I will definitely sleep easier at night knowing that I better always agree with the government, no matter how corrupt it gets.

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#12

The US government's system of justice seems increasingly opaque, arbitrary, and solely for the purpose of maintaining the status quo and those already in power. Meanwhile, much worse crimes by those in power such as torture go unpunished.

It's frankly disgusting.

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#13
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure 5 < 100, but does that somehow change the morality of what's being done here?

That he threatened federal agent(s)? That he knowingly claimed to be part of a [mostly] criminal hacking group? That he knowingly and willfully obstructed an investigation? He did stupid, illegal things, and honestly it sounds like he got off pretty light, to me.

Have you heard his "threats" against federal agents?

God forbid journalists protect their sources.

https://wikileaks.org/Assange-statement-on-the.html

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#14

The US government's system of justice seems increasingly opaque, arbitrary, and solely for the purpose of maintaining the status quo and those already in power. Meanwhile, much worse crimes by those in power such as torture go unpunished.

"It is dangerous to be right in matters where established men are wrong."

-Voltaire

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#15
> 63 months in federal prison, minus 28 months already served. For count one in the case, he receives 48 months.

Does he not get any credit for time served in jail pre-trial [1] or is the 28 being subtracted 1-for-1?

In the Canadian criminal law code you get time-and-a-half for time served in jail so he'd only have 26 months in prison vs the 48 stated here. Historically it was often 2-for-1 of time served pre-trial which in this case would have mean only 12 additional months in prison.

In America I believe it is up to the judge to provide 'credit' during sentencing and there is no pre-defined ratio.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_served

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That he threatened federal agent(s)? That he knowingly claimed to be part of a [mostly] criminal hacking group? That he knowingly and willfully obstructed an investigation? He did stupid, illegal things, and honestly it sounds like he got off pretty light, to me.

Have you heard his "threats" against federal agents? God forbid journalists protect their sources. https://wikileaks.org/Assange-statement-on-the.html

His own sentencing allocution --- which was, to say the least, not a weak-kneed cowtowing to the DOJ to minimize his sentencing --- admitted fully to those threats and blamed them on withdrawal from Paxil and Suboxone. The threatening videos and tweets were the most unambiguous regret he expressed. Regrets he expressed moments before haranguing the DOJ, at length, for their misconduct during the case.

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#17
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The thing that bothers me is he's being sentenced for "aiding" LulzSec and "obstruction" of justice by reporting on and re-tweeting information about their hacking spree. This is the same LulzSec that was being secretly run by the FBI via their turncoat, Sabu, during some of LulzSec's highest profile hacks (such as the Stratfor hack) Also, in addition to his 5 year imprisonment, he's been ordered to pay nearly $900,0…

So, he plead guilty to these charges, that's why he's being sentenced for them. He chose not to take his chances and make those arguments.

He pled guilty to avoid getting reamed even worse.

There's no justice here. It's just an exercise in power in order to send a message.

Re: Barrett Brown sentenced to 63 months in prison

#18
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, he plead guilty to these charges, that's why he's being sentenced for them. He chose not to take his chances and make those arguments.

My guess is he plead guilty under advisement his case was hopeless. There's a significant likelihood evidence necessary to aide his case is locked away deep inside the FBI. A very a la NSA illegal wiretaps putting people in prison under guise of "confidential informant".

Do you have any cases where NSA illegal wiretaps were used as evidence in court in a standard trial like this against a U.S. citizen? If the FBI said well our evidence is a confidential informant that would not be valid as the defense has a right to cross examine witnesses and evidence.

This guy pled guilty. Maybe it was due to fear of courts handling tech cases, or maybe it was due to the fact that there was a large amount of evidence that he committed a crime that was not simply reporting.

Post reply on HN