Live data from Hacker News

Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

bbc.com

11–20 of 348 posts

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#11
post #2

Never heard of her before. Why is she so famous to elicit such an extreme reaction ?

It's part of the ongoing Gamergate issue; Wikipedia is probably a good starting point for that, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anita_Sarkeesian and currently https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamergate_controversy.

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#12
post #2

Never heard of her before. Why is she so famous to elicit such an extreme reaction ?

You don't have to be famous to elicit an extreme reaction, just well known to the right group of extremists.

In short, she has created a series of web videos discussing feminism in computer games, and how female characters are portrayed. This has led to her being target number one amongst a very odd "gamer" community that will seemingly stop at nothing to preserve their culture.

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#14
post #9
post #5

I probably watch too many shows, but wouldn't that kind of threat (real or manufactured) actually push the speaker further into the limelight? So if this an actual threat (most likely) the 'bully' is really playing into her hands, so to speak. If this threat is manufactured, well this would indeed be quite a Machiavellian PR stunt ...

> If this threat is manufactured, well this would indeed be quite a Machiavellian PR stunt ... That's a common accusation by the GamerGate folks, but given the number of other women in the gaming arena receiving similar harassment it's pretty believable that these are real.

Notice I did not accuse her of anything, simply stating two facts. Why the down votes? All I am saying is that whoever made the threats clearly doesn't want the issue to go away ... Come on guys!

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#15
post #2

Never heard of her before. Why is she so famous to elicit such an extreme reaction ?

She raised a bunch of money from a kickstarter to make a series of videos about women in video games. The videos got a lot of stuff wrong about video games and she really had to reach to get her point across.

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#16
Before this was cancelled, Utah State University police announced "enhanced security measures will now be in place, which include prohibiting backpacks and any large bags." But anyone who had a permit to carry a concealed firearm would be allowed to bring it to the venue.

I guess the theory is that anyone targeting Ms. Sarkeesian would have gone down in a hail of patriot bullets, but she wisely decided not to test this.

From http://www.usu.edu/ust/index.cfm?article=54178

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#17
post #8
post #5

I probably watch too many shows, but wouldn't that kind of threat (real or manufactured) actually push the speaker further into the limelight? So if this an actual threat (most likely) the 'bully' is really playing into her hands, so to speak. If this threat is manufactured, well this would indeed be quite a Machiavellian PR stunt ...

The whole of 'GamerGate' feels almost like a PR stunt to turn the world's media against gamers. The irony is almost palpable.

This is why it's best to ignore the whole thing, except to refer criminal threats to the police for investigation.

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#18
post #13

Her video series, which you can see on YouTube, is actually quite good and well-researched. You might disagree with her conclusions (I agree with them) but even if you disagree, you have to admit she's done a lot of legwork.

Even if they were poor or badly researched, death threats are just way out of scope. Like: NEVER, EVER, IN ANY INTERACTION ARE THEY OKAY, NO POINT TO ARGUE. They are also no joke.

(sorry for using all caps for once) (I take explanations for downvotes)

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#19
post #6
post #2

Never heard of her before. Why is she so famous to elicit such an extreme reaction ?

She runs a show called 'Feminist Frequency', dedicated to calling out sexist tropes in video games (amongst other things). She appears to have become one of the enemies of the movement known as "#GamerGate". Proponents of the movement will tell you it's about ethics in game journalism, but in reality it seems to have largely become corrupted by misogyny and the like. Several female game developers and journalists hav…

I think calling it "corrupted by misogyny" is a bit misleading. As far as I can tell, it is as pure and uncompromising in its misogyny as ever, the journalism thing has been a smokescreen from the beginning.

Re: Feminist video-games talk pulled after massacre threat

#20
post #2

Never heard of her before. Why is she so famous to elicit such an extreme reaction ?

She raised a bunch of money from a kickstarter to make a series of videos about women in video games. The videos got a lot of stuff wrong about video games and she really had to reach to get her point across.

Naturally, the appropriate reaction to that is death threats.

edit: Sorry, unclear. Not accusing the parent of this opinion.

Post reply on HN