Live data from Hacker News

Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

wired.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#11
promising that if Apple heeds his advice, he won’t sell off any of his approximately 53 million shares.

If he really thinks the stock is undervalued, why would he sell in the absence of a share buyback anyway? If he is right then surely he should be buying those shares himself and waiting as the buyback would only be bringing forward a rise, not creating it.

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#13

I think this is a much better url as it has the actual letter that the article is based on. http://www.businessinsider.com/carl-icahn-apple-letter-2014-... To be fair to him, he's not the only person who thinks apple should be doing more with their cash: http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/11/21/hedge-fund-manager... I'm sure most people have heard about Icahn. But if not check out his Wikipedia page to see a list of…

> to be clear, I'm not making a judgement on his character or if he's a net positive to the market.

I am. Herbalife is a Ponzi scheme.

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#14
post #8

I wonder if Tim Cook really reads that lengthy letter or some legal expert will just summarize the content. TL;DR version might be helpful.

I would be surprised if Cook did not read it. Its not that lengthy, and Icahn does own just a bit under 1% of the company, if I did my math right(53M shares * 100.98 / 596B market cap).

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#16
Michael Dell after his experience with Carl Icahn [1] and the bitter battle to take his company private.

“It’s a big poker game to him [Carl Icahn],” says Dell. “It’s not about the customers. It’s not about the people. It’s not about changing the world. He doesn’t give a crap about any of that. He didn’t know whether we made nuclear power plants or French fries. He didn’t care.”

http://www.forbes.com/sites/connieguglielmo/2013/10/30/you-w...

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#17
I might be in the minority here, but I want to see Icahn pump-and-dump Apple. Now that Jobs is gone, there is nobody running the ship that is competent enough to stop Icahn. He'll devalue the company, and bleed it dry if allowed, just like he's trying to do with eBay right now. And this makes me happy as a clam; Now that Microsoft is steadily marching toward irrelevance, it'd be peachy keen if we could take down the usurper to that throne (Apple), and give the GNU/Linux and BSD families the attention they rightfully deserve.

Could you imagine? if Icahn bled Apple to death, Ubuntu would be the 800lb Gorilla.

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#18
post #8

I wonder if Tim Cook really reads that lengthy letter or some legal expert will just summarize the content. TL;DR version might be helpful.

I would be surprised if Cook did not read it. Its not that lengthy, and Icahn does own just a bit under 1% of the company, if I did my math right(53M shares * 100.98 / 596B market cap).

Cook should read it and then do the opposite of whatever Icahn wants given Icahn's track record of wrecking companies.

Re: Carl Icahn Says Apple Is Massively Undervalued

#19

promising that if Apple heeds his advice, he won’t sell off any of his approximately 53 million shares. If he really thinks the stock is undervalued, why would he sell in the absence of a share buyback anyway? If he is right then surely he should be buying those shares himself and waiting as the buyback would only be bringing forward a rise, not creating it.

It's a good point, but investing more than a certain % of your assets (roughly proportional to your perceived edge) in any one thing, is a bad idea.
Post reply on HN