Live data from Hacker News

Is Google Making Students Stupid?

theatlantic.com

11–13 of 13 posts

Re: Is Google Making Students Stupid?

#11
Vision was one of the last senses to evolve in animals. And yet it's the most useful sense, significantly reducing our reliance on other senses. As a result, if I were to lose my vision, I might well be at a much larger disadvantage than if I'd never been able to see in the first place.

Instead of intentionally walking around blindfolded in preparation for a loss of vision that will hopefully never occur, I could thank my lucky stars that my eyes work and focus on using them to the fullest.

Re: Is Google Making Students Stupid?

#12
post #4

The author is well aware of the tradition of hand-wringing he is joining; He makes reference to Plato’s Phaedrus! But he doesn't actually make an argument for why it actually matters that students don't learn to spell English's arbitrary orthography. His introductory example of GPS and wilderness survival is the only compelling case.

I think it's ludicrous that spelling skills would be "eroded" by spell checkers and drop-downs. If anything, steady exposure to corrections to misspellings would teach one to spell correctly the first time (though errors like 'their' vs 'there' might still be an issue).

Re: Is Google Making Students Stupid?

#13
post #4

The author is well aware of the tradition of hand-wringing he is joining; He makes reference to Plato’s Phaedrus! But he doesn't actually make an argument for why it actually matters that students don't learn to spell English's arbitrary orthography. His introductory example of GPS and wilderness survival is the only compelling case.

I think it's ludicrous that spelling skills would be "eroded" by spell checkers and drop-downs. If anything, steady exposure to corrections to misspellings would teach one to spell correctly the first time (though errors like 'their' vs 'there' might still be an issue).

Indeed. Except for a few words like "exercise", which I can never figure out how to spell correctly on my own.
Post reply on HN