Live data from Hacker News

Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

secupwn.github.io

11–20 of 37 posts

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#11

Hello, everyone! Since Google does not seem to be interested in fixing the huge security hole of not showing a ciphering indicator on Android, it appears as if they get paid (or are forced to) not fix it. For all of you that are sick of getting spied on through IMSI-Catchers, Silent SMS and alike and want to do something about it, here's a great project you should check out: "The Android-IMSI-Catcher-Detector" (AIMSI…

Do you intend to add CDMA support?

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#12
It seems only 2G connection is crackable. Are we safe as long as the device is on 3G/4G network? We should just disable cellular radio when you see the device is on 2G suspiciously in the middle of city(around demonstrations, I suppose)

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#15
post #9

Hello, everyone! Since Google does not seem to be interested in fixing the huge security hole of not showing a ciphering indicator on Android, it appears as if they get paid (or are forced to) not fix it. For all of you that are sick of getting spied on through IMSI-Catchers, Silent SMS and alike and want to do something about it, here's a great project you should check out: "The Android-IMSI-Catcher-Detector" (AIMSI…

Thanks for working on this important project! Maybe I missed this in reading your site, but how do you know it detects fake base stations? Have you been able to test it against a Stingray, or are you basing the app on a set of assumptions derived from recently leaked product specs?

Their development roadmap has some details, not all of which seem viable. They want to make 2-3 apps:

1. Detect hidden SMS and (SIM card?) app installations through public APIs. I don't think this will work.

2. Send AT commands to the baseband processor and use the results to detect anomalies. My guess is that the baseband doesn't expose enough information for this to work.

3. Connect to an OsmocomBB phone running CatcherCatcher [0] via USB. This should work, since CatcherCatcher seems to work.

[0] https://opensource.srlabs.de/projects/mobile-network-assessm...

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#17

You probably shouldn't put the EFF, Guardian Project and Privacy International logos so prominently on your website if you are not affiliated with or supported by those projects.

Sadly, this Project is not yet officially supported by them. But it is one of the GOALS to support FF, Guardian Project and Privacy International. Not necessarily the other way around. :)

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#18
post #15
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for working on this important project! Maybe I missed this in reading your site, but how do you know it detects fake base stations? Have you been able to test it against a Stingray, or are you basing the app on a set of assumptions derived from recently leaked product specs?

Their development roadmap has some details, not all of which seem viable. They want to make 2-3 apps: 1. Detect hidden SMS and (SIM card?) app installations through public APIs. I don't think this will work. 2. Send AT commands to the baseband processor and use the results to detect anomalies. My guess is that the baseband doesn't expose enough information for this to work. 3. Connect to an OsmocomBB phone running Ca…

Well, the development roadmap is just what it says: A roadmap. Essentially this shall be one, unified App in the final end. And that is exactly the reason why it's open source: Your contributions shall help the project evolve and add all these things.

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#19
post #11

Hello, everyone! Since Google does not seem to be interested in fixing the huge security hole of not showing a ciphering indicator on Android, it appears as if they get paid (or are forced to) not fix it. For all of you that are sick of getting spied on through IMSI-Catchers, Silent SMS and alike and want to do something about it, here's a great project you should check out: "The Android-IMSI-Catcher-Detector" (AIMSI…

Do you intend to add CDMA support?

This entirely depends on peoples contributions on GitHub.

Re: Android IMSI-Catcher Detector

#20

It seems only 2G connection is crackable. Are we safe as long as the device is on 3G/4G network? We should just disable cellular radio when you see the device is on 2G suspiciously in the middle of city(around demonstrations, I suppose)

I'm just going to quote the GitHub README here: "Although A5/3 withstands passive eavesdropping, it can be bypassed by deploying an IMSI-Catcher which can force a mobile device into 2G mode and downgrade then the encryption to A5/1 or disable it."

Here is the best hint I can give you: LEAVE YOUR PHOEN AT HOME when you really have to participate in demonstrations! The main reason why the use of IMSI-Catchers, Stingrays and alike is such a popular tactic for law enforcement agencies is because people are not SMART ENOUGH to think ahaed and leave their phones at home!

No solution for you? Well then, at the very least make yourself your own signal blocking pouch to fully block all Silent SMS: www.killyourphone.com

Post reply on HN