Live data from Hacker News

Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

blog.wikimedia.org

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#11
post #2

I remember that there were multiple userbase attempts to lobby Wikimedia for this in the past. Looks like Coinbase's recent partnering successes have made the difference, in this case at least.

Some of these "userbase" attempts involved doing some things that people perceived as unethical (e.g. bribes) and caused damage that took effort to undo.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#14
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If this donation is tax deductible, I expect it is so they can send you a receipt. Still, an anonymous option would be nice.

They also are legally required to collect donor information for donations above $1,000 [1]. Mostly this is to ensure that nonprofits aren't playing weird games with funneling money around, e.g. being registered as a 501(c)(3) charity but actually being funded mainly by one person who also controls the board/spending. Maybe they can rework the donation flow so it allows anonymous donations below that limit? But if tha…

How are you going to ensure that you're legally compliant with "only $X per-year per-person" unless you keep track of who's making every Bitcoin donation to you?

If you don't do that you could trivially go over the limit by just donating >$X over multiple Bitcoin transactions.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#15
post #3

You mean, "Wikimedia now uses Coinbase as another payment provider to collect US currency for donations"?

It's that you can donate in BTC that matters, not that they're exchanging it for USD.

It matters. Automatically exchanging large amounts of BTC for USD creates a downward pressure on the BTC exchange rate.

Organizations which truly support Bitcoin would choose to keep it.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's that you can donate in BTC that matters, not that they're exchanging it for USD.

It matters. Automatically exchanging large amounts of BTC for USD creates a downward pressure on the BTC exchange rate. Organizations which truly support Bitcoin would choose to keep it.

Baby steps. Maybe an employee will ask to be paid partly in BTC which I'm sure they'll be happy to oblige to avoid the conversion fees.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#17
post #3

You mean, "Wikimedia now uses Coinbase as another payment provider to collect US currency for donations"?

Imagine they accepted Japanese Yen instead of Bitcoin. They would still convert it to USD, but would your opinion still make sense?

When I used to donate previously, my DKK were converted to USD. But I still use DKK every day.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's that you can donate in BTC that matters, not that they're exchanging it for USD.

It matters. Automatically exchanging large amounts of BTC for USD creates a downward pressure on the BTC exchange rate. Organizations which truly support Bitcoin would choose to keep it.

If what you said was true the exchange rate would have collapsed in the last 2 years (BitPay and Coinbase accumulated 60,000+ merchants who began accepting Bitcoin over the last 2 years and most of them automatically convert BTC to USD). But instead, the exchange rate rose from $10 to $580: http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg730ztgSzm1g10z...

Why? Because as Bitcoin is accepted in more and more places, it increases its subjective value, so more and more people are looking to get some bitcoins, which counterbalances the downward selling pressure.

Re: Wikimedia Foundation now accepts Bitcoin

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It matters. Automatically exchanging large amounts of BTC for USD creates a downward pressure on the BTC exchange rate. Organizations which truly support Bitcoin would choose to keep it.

If what you said was true the exchange rate would have collapsed in the last 2 years (BitPay and Coinbase accumulated 60,000+ merchants who began accepting Bitcoin over the last 2 years and most of them automatically convert BTC to USD). But instead, the exchange rate rose from $10 to $580: http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg730ztgSzm1g10z... Why? Because as Bitcoin is accepted in more and more places, it…

I'm not sure why you disagree. Of course there are multiple factors and some of them counterbalance. And of course what I mentioned is just one of these factors.
Post reply on HN