Live data from Hacker News

Comcast response to Netflix

corporate.comcast.com

11–20 of 111 posts

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#11
> Comcast has a multiplicity of other agreements just like the one Netflix approached us to negotiate, and so has every other Internet service provider for the last two decades.

I may just be ignorant here, but in what sense is Netflix an "Internet service provider?"

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#13

> Comcast has a multiplicity of other agreements just like the one Netflix approached us to negotiate, and so has every other Internet service provider for the last two decades. I may just be ignorant here, but in what sense is Netflix an "Internet service provider?"

I think it's a misplaced modifier:

"Comcast, as well as every other ISP for the last two decades, has a multiplicity of agreements just like the one Netflix approached Comcast to negotiate."

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#14

> Comcast has a multiplicity of other agreements just like the one Netflix approached us to negotiate, and so has every other Internet service provider for the last two decades. I may just be ignorant here, but in what sense is Netflix an "Internet service provider?"

I think it's a misplaced modifier: "Comcast, as well as every other ISP for the last two decades, has a multiplicity of agreements just like the one Netflix approached Comcast to negotiate."

Ah, that would make sense. Thanks!

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#15
The sentence "While it’s understandable for Netflix to try to make all Internet users pay for its costs of doing business" should probably end with "we would like to shift some of our cost of doing business back to Netflix"

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#17
What angers me most is FCC and Comcast both are spinning this whole thing as "improving" net-neutrality while in reality is is plain, simple and naked "net anti-neutrality". They are obviously behind this push as lobbyist. Do they think people are complete idiot to buy off statements like charging content providers actually reduces their cost?

Re: Comcast response to Netflix

#18
In summary:

NetFlix argument: Comcast is using its bully position to extra a toll from service providers and service subscribers. A Comcast-TwC merger would make it worse for Netflix and everyone else.

Comcast argument: Netflix is wrong. We bully all the content providers, not just Netflix. So, er, yeah, they're wrong.

Post reply on HN