Live data from Hacker News

Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

loomio.org

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#11

Speaking from experience, Loomio is a wonderfully effective decision making platform. :)

how does it ensure that only one person gets one account?

We're interested in exploring cryptographic anonymization. But the truth is, most groups don't need it.

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, it's not really fancy. In terms of discussion forums, Discourse is much more fancy than what we've built. But, unlike most forums, we've tailored every feature toward bringing discussions to consensus. And when you're trying to decide something online, that makes a big difference.

And from the looks of it, you did a great job!! Exploring your "how to make a decision on loomio" right now.

Thanks!! :)

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

how does it ensure that only one person gets one account?

We're interested in exploring cryptographic anonymization. But the truth is, most groups don't need it.

What about using SMS/Facebook auth?

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#14
I really like the platform. It enables people to conduct the decision making in a way that is followed in formal committees, and even the UN. People present options, everyone talks about them, then when it seems that the group is converging towards a solution, you present a proposal. And then everyone votes on it (and not just a yes or no!). So it's pretty cool.

I just have one concern, does only the leader present proposals? or can everyone do it? To me, letting only the leader (OP) do that makes sense. otherwise wouldn't everyone be just doing that instead of posting suggestions?

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#16

I really like the platform. It enables people to conduct the decision making in a way that is followed in formal committees, and even the UN. People present options, everyone talks about them, then when it seems that the group is converging towards a solution, you present a proposal. And then everyone votes on it (and not just a yes or no!). So it's pretty cool. I just have one concern, does only the leader present p…

Thanks! Yes anyone can start a discussion and a proposal, but we haven't experienced people just starting proposals without engaging in other ways. People start proposals but if you don't want to participate, you can just let them die. The big idea here is to build shared understanding through discussion before a proposal is suggested, that way the group has a solid foundation on which to create a decision.

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#17
My pet peeve is projects that don't describe what they do. Thought process while reading:

> Loomio is a user-friendly tool for collaborative decision-making:

Piqued my interest.

> not majority-rules polling, but actually coming up with solutions that work for everyone.

Skeptical because it promises to get rid of office politics. I want to know specifics how and why it works. Cold, hard, game-theory and/or economics. Maybe there is something useful behind that marketing-speak.

> We’re a small team in New Zealand, and we’ve built a prototype that people are already doing great things with.

Total non-sequitur. I don't care who you are. Convince me why the product works before I invest more effort.

> Now we’re crowdfunding so we can build the real thing: a new tool for truly inclusive decision-making.​

Ah, it doesn't work yet.

> Youtube video

Sorry, I'm not going to spend an hour of my time when you've already proved yourself a bad steward of the last five minutes.

Contrast this to xerophtye's comment: short, punchy explanation how Loomio works.

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#18

My pet peeve is projects that don't describe what they do. Thought process while reading: > Loomio is a user-friendly tool for collaborative decision-making: Piqued my interest. > not majority-rules polling, but actually coming up with solutions that work for everyone. Skeptical because it promises to get rid of office politics. I want to know specifics how and why it works. Cold, hard, game-theory and/or economics.…

Thanks for the feedback. We'll try to fix those points.

Checkout the explore page for a few examples of groups using the tool:

https://www.loomio.org/explore

Re: Loomio – Crowdfunding a better way to make decisions together

#19
post #15

Great project, have my $12. FYI - the website takes a very long time to load in Australia, I would suggest using a CDN to improve international load times.

Thank you so much! Your support means a lot :)

We've tried to optimise load times but we will try to improve them further.

Post reply on HN