Live data from Hacker News

U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

washingtonpost.com

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#11
post #7

Well, how about not diagnosing your kid with autism just because he's an uncontrollable little bastard, just to justify your bad parenting?(This includes ADD, ADHD, ASD). That should bring the stat down. Qualifier: not all obviously, but it has certainly become a way to remove personal responsibility as a parent.

Hopefully the CDC is a little more thorough than simply asking parents if their kids are autistic.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#12
post #7

Well, how about not diagnosing your kid with autism just because he's an uncontrollable little bastard, just to justify your bad parenting?(This includes ADD, ADHD, ASD). That should bring the stat down. Qualifier: not all obviously, but it has certainly become a way to remove personal responsibility as a parent.

We seriously thought we were bad parents until a doctor we saw in passing said we should have my daughter evaluated

This opened up options for medication and therapies that will help keep her from shooting up a daycare someday We hope - her tantrums are so bad the neighbors have called the police

That's the worst part of ASD to me, and frankly one of the least talked about

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#13
I'm weary of diagnosing behaviour that used to be considered within the norm, though maybe at the edge, as a medical condition.

Asperger's has no clear measurable part to diagnose, it is not treatable per se, and its symptoms are all within the normal spectrum of human behaviour.

There's nothing wrong with saying that a particular kid might need more support, but I wonder where it leads society if all not entirely within the norm behaviours start to be classified and handled as medical problems.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#14
post #2

> “It could be that doctors are getting better at identifying these children, there could be a growing number of children with high intelligence [who are autistic], or it could be both,” she said. The article doesn't mention that the DSM-5 went into force last year. The criteria for diagnosing Autism has changed since the DSM-IV, and this could also explain the jump in diagnoses. (This is alluded to with the line "Mi…

Having seen a lot of very successful, but somewhat autistic people working in tech (probably Asperger's), it seems a little strange to be classifying it as a "disorder"...

It's asperger's. You'll know if you meet someone with full-blown autism. They would never get into employment.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#16
Autism is the new ADHD. If 1 and 70 kids have a disorder that wasn't a thing 20 years ago, something is wrong.

I had some speech issues when I was a kid that led to shyness and difficulty making friends until I got a bit older. I'm sure that I would have been classified in the spectrum on today's standards. It's a hot diagnosis.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#18
post #2

> “It could be that doctors are getting better at identifying these children, there could be a growing number of children with high intelligence [who are autistic], or it could be both,” she said. The article doesn't mention that the DSM-5 went into force last year. The criteria for diagnosing Autism has changed since the DSM-IV, and this could also explain the jump in diagnoses. (This is alluded to with the line "Mi…

Having seen a lot of very successful, but somewhat autistic people working in tech (probably Asperger's), it seems a little strange to be classifying it as a "disorder"...

"Disorder" was the technical term in the DSM-IV-TR, which dates back to 2000. (I believe it dates even further than that but I'm not a psychiatrist.)

It really depends on the severity of the symptoms, and whether the individual has developed effective coping strategies.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#19
post #6

There is no "test" for autism, no blood market, no brain scan. What is the false positive number? This sounds like the diagnosis for "hysteria" in women 50 years ago .

Autism spectrum disorder diagnosed using a standardized "observation" (the ADOS) and/or a highly structured parental interview (the ADI-R). There are peer-reviewed papers which report on the validity and reliability of these instruments.

Re: U.S. autism rate surges, CDC reports (1 in 68)

#20
post #2

> “It could be that doctors are getting better at identifying these children, there could be a growing number of children with high intelligence [who are autistic], or it could be both,” she said. The article doesn't mention that the DSM-5 went into force last year. The criteria for diagnosing Autism has changed since the DSM-IV, and this could also explain the jump in diagnoses. (This is alluded to with the line "Mi…

Having seen a lot of very successful, but somewhat autistic people working in tech (probably Asperger's), it seems a little strange to be classifying it as a "disorder"...

Having seen a lot of children, including my own, (10 years old and unable to speak), I think you should do a little more research on the entire spectrum the disorder covers.

This is one of the major problems with the autism community and the diagnosis. Someone who doesn't make eye contact and perhaps fixates on certain topics (maybe comp Sci) has the same diagnosis as my child who will require lifelong care and never live independently.

We need the public to understand both sides. To some autism is considered a 'gift', and this study suggested 46% of their numbers were at or above average IQ. What they didn't highlight is that 31% have low IQ and are the ones (as I mentioned earlier) that will require lifelong care and put an unimaginable burden on families.

Edit spelling

Post reply on HN