Live data from Hacker News

A letter from Paper (FiftyThree) to Paper (Facebook)

news.fiftythree.com

11–20 of 162 posts

Re: A letter from Paper (FiftyThree) to Paper (Facebook)

#16
post #5

Can both not exist? I don't see how there could be overlap or confusion from potential customers.

"I always use Paper on my ipad for all my pictures, you should check it out" Which app would you download from the appstore ?

It just seems a bit melodramatic. Should Google Mail have been named Google Post, just because Yahoo Mail was first? They aren't operating in the same space; furthermore, Facebook didn't name it just "Paper" in the App Store, they've named it "Paper - stories from Facebook".

Re: A letter from Paper (FiftyThree) to Paper (Facebook)

#17
I think Facebook should change Paper's name mainly because Paper is a horrible name for this product, which is actually "Facebook without all the crap you never use". The fact that "Paper by FiftyThree" is a name already in use is another factor, why fight this battle when the name isn't even very good?

Re: A letter from Paper (FiftyThree) to Paper (Facebook)

#18
My first thought when I read the Facebook Paper announcement was along these lines.

This is a big social faux paus on Facebook's part - at least among the developer community - but I really don't see either company changing their Paper's name. I imagine it'll go similarly to Google's Go name collision[1].

How should the little guy in these situations be legally protected? On one hand it's clear that "candy" shouldn't be trademarked, but "paper" is just as generic a term. Maybe the lesson here is not to name your product generic nouns and avoid the trouble all together.

1. https://code.google.com/p/go/issues/detail?id=9

Re: A letter from Paper (FiftyThree) to Paper (Facebook)

#19
It's a matter of respect. Paper (FiftyThree) is a well known brand and app, so basically the Facebook developers were 100% aware that they were utilizing someone's name (at least they should have been), and therefore they went ahead to publish their new app with complete disregard for what already existed.
Post reply on HN