Live data from Hacker News

Why I'm Quitting Social Media

tapenoisediary.com

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#11
post #6

This is a classic "quitting an addiction" post. I've seen and heard this many times, from people playing wow to smokers to coffee drinkers. If you have to announce how and why you are quitting, then you probably are doing it too much.

http://www.newsweek.com/id/183180 here's a newsweek "I'm quitting FB" article and I'm certain I've seen one on slate.com Is Facebook really so all consuming for these people who have to quit it publicly? Personally I love FB. It's like auto-pilot for my social life. It reminds me about the birthdays about the people I only vaguely care about, leave them a one-line message on their wall and that's it until next year.…

it's great for making lots of people think that lots of people care about them

followed by

What's not to like?

Dude, I think you answered your own question: superficial relationships masquerading as genuine ones - you know, that does bother some people.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#12
post #11
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

http://www.newsweek.com/id/183180 here's a newsweek "I'm quitting FB" article and I'm certain I've seen one on slate.com Is Facebook really so all consuming for these people who have to quit it publicly? Personally I love FB. It's like auto-pilot for my social life. It reminds me about the birthdays about the people I only vaguely care about, leave them a one-line message on their wall and that's it until next year.…

it's great for making lots of people think that lots of people care about them followed by What's not to like? Dude, I think you answered your own question: superficial relationships masquerading as genuine ones - you know, that does bother some people.

But these are superficial relationships replacing non-relationships, not replacing genuine ones.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#13
post #12
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it's great for making lots of people think that lots of people care about them followed by What's not to like? Dude, I think you answered your own question: superficial relationships masquerading as genuine ones - you know, that does bother some people.

But these are superficial relationships replacing non- relationships, not replacing genuine ones.

Again, not everybody thinks the same. It is possible to prefer a non-relationship to a superficial relationship. Some people value authenticity for its own sake.

I'm not trying to convince anyone to change their mind, I just want to explain why the appeal of the social media is not universal (not that it has to be of course). For example there are some people I would call "intentional introverts" who quite genuinely would prefer not to have a happy birthday greeting from someone they are not close to. Others obviously are delighted by the same thing. It takes all kinds to make the world, etc etc.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#14
post #6

This is a classic "quitting an addiction" post. I've seen and heard this many times, from people playing wow to smokers to coffee drinkers. If you have to announce how and why you are quitting, then you probably are doing it too much.

http://www.newsweek.com/id/183180 here's a newsweek "I'm quitting FB" article and I'm certain I've seen one on slate.com Is Facebook really so all consuming for these people who have to quit it publicly? Personally I love FB. It's like auto-pilot for my social life. It reminds me about the birthdays about the people I only vaguely care about, leave them a one-line message on their wall and that's it until next year.…

"It reminds me about the birthdays about the people I only vaguely care about, leave them a one-line message on their wall and that's it until next year."

you could easily automate that :)

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#15

I've been thinking about doing something like this for weeks. It seems like at the start of my day I'll log onto Hacker News and read 5 or 6 interesting articles. However, without even trying, by the end of the day, all the links will be grey instead of black. I'll end up clicking on every link, even the links I really don't give a shit about. It's a time sink - it really is like surfing channels without feeling as g…

Have you discovered the 'noprocast' setting yet ? It's in your profile.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#16

"illusion of an audience" What about those who use this illusion to drive traffic to their website or front door? Just because you use Twitter for useless chatter doesn't mean everyone else does. Or am I missing the point of the article? If you spend x hours Tweeting every week and can track it all the way to measurable 'results', you can still get a sense of accomplishment that the author seems to be searching for.

I'm not saying there are none, but what 'results' can you achieve from tweeting (that aren't achievable more efficiently elsewhere)?

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#17
post #7
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe he's trying to make a commitment he will be held to.

Like mr. "I can write stackoverflow in a weekend"? Also, haven't there been a dozen articles posted here about how publicly stating your intent hinders your ability to achieve it? It was in reference to startups, but it's the same psychology at work I imagine.

Maybe saying you're going to do something is different from saying you're not going to do something. One is easier to verify than the other.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#18

I've been thinking about doing something like this for weeks. It seems like at the start of my day I'll log onto Hacker News and read 5 or 6 interesting articles. However, without even trying, by the end of the day, all the links will be grey instead of black. I'll end up clicking on every link, even the links I really don't give a shit about. It's a time sink - it really is like surfing channels without feeling as g…

Have you discovered the 'noprocast' setting yet ? It's in your profile.

I just enabled that.

It is utterly PATHETIC that I need to limit myself so. However .. humans are weak. You have to trick yourself.

I was thinking of writing a daemon to rewrite HN's IP before I found out about noprocrast ... good feature.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#19

"illusion of an audience" What about those who use this illusion to drive traffic to their website or front door? Just because you use Twitter for useless chatter doesn't mean everyone else does. Or am I missing the point of the article? If you spend x hours Tweeting every week and can track it all the way to measurable 'results', you can still get a sense of accomplishment that the author seems to be searching for.

I'm not saying there are none, but what 'results' can you achieve from tweeting (that aren't achievable more efficiently elsewhere)?

Well I'm saying there are none! Twitter is just a centralised blogging service with a gimmick.

Re: Why I'm Quitting Social Media

#20
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, but there is a seed of truth here in how social media has upped the engagement factor so much that it's easy for it to become a time sink with the user not even realizing it. I think society needs another 10 years to absorb the implications of social media and how to use it effectively (and for the filters to get better).

No one's denying the addiction. However, I'm sure nicotine and caffeine (not to mention wow) are even worse for most people. It's a combination of the stimulus and each individual's reaction to it. I'm sure that the vast, vast majority of people have no problems releasing themselves from social media.

I found my way of doing it was simply to block reddit, digg, and slashdot from my /etc/hosts. Otherwise I'd just go back if I was bored ("oh, I have nothing better to do for the next 10 minutes anyways...")

My life has improved immeasurably.

Post reply on HN