Live data from Hacker News

Ethereum: A Turing-Complete Cryptocurrency

ethereum.org

11–20 of 88 posts

Re: Ethereum: A Turing-Complete Cryptocurrency

#11
post #6

Note that Bitcoin is purposefully not turing complete. http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/17258/turing-comp...

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Script wiki here

First paragraph:

>It is purposefully not Turing-complete, with no loops.

Re: Ethereum: A Turing-Complete Cryptocurrency

#17
post #12

I don't understand who does all the turing complete contract computation. Presumably the miners, but they're paid to do some useless proof-of-work work, not the turning complete computation of the contract.

The fee goes to the miner who happens to find the containing block, yes. But not to the thousands of validating nodes integral to the network. And over time fees are given proportional to hashpower... which doesn't make any kind of sense. The incentives are all messed up.

Re: Ethereum: A Turing-Complete Cryptocurrency

#18
post #17
post #12

I don't understand who does all the turing complete contract computation. Presumably the miners, but they're paid to do some useless proof-of-work work, not the turning complete computation of the contract.

The fee goes to the miner who happens to find the containing block, yes. But not to the thousands of validating nodes integral to the network. And over time fees are given proportional to hashpower... which doesn't make any kind of sense. The incentives are all messed up.

Hey, I like your assessment ability. Contact me at jkwon.work@gmail.com, I have an idea I want to share with you.

Re: Ethereum: A Turing-Complete Cryptocurrency

#19
post #5

I think the clever idea here (IMO) are the fees. An argument against implementing a Turing complete language inside Bitcoin or an Altcoin might be that it's hard to determine when execution should end. The fees allow arbitrarily complex constructs without any hard cap, while preventing abuse.

Maybe, but not the way its implemented here. The fee needs to go to all the nodes which perform the validation, not to the miners.
Post reply on HN