Live data from Hacker News

Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

kickstarter.com

11–20 of 64 posts

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#11
I don't understand. $50K being asked by professors and PhD students? They certainly enjoy funds orders of magnitude more. $50K is like two YC startups' seed money.

Why do they want it? Can't they self-fund it? Or do they just want other people to share the glory? Isn't the equipment shown in the video worth as much, or probably more?

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#13
post #8
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Portal 2 reference: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xeKMS62GrTI Edit: It's clear that someone in NASA is a Portal fan - they sent a laser-etched image of Wheatley up with an HTV-3 resupply craft: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/118637-NASA-Sends-...

Their menu items on the left are even spelled that way. http://www.nasa.gov/content/blue-origin-test-fires-new-rocke...

Yeah, I'm pretty sure you're running a http://xkcd.com/1288/ browser extension.

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#14
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their menu items on the left are even spelled that way. http://www.nasa.gov/content/blue-origin-test-fires-new-rocke...

Yeah, I'm pretty sure you're running a http://xkcd.com/1288/ browser extension.

!!!!

Doh haha you are totally right. Completely forgot about it.

Thanks.

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#15

I don't understand. $50K being asked by professors and PhD students? They certainly enjoy funds orders of magnitude more. $50K is like two YC startups' seed money. Why do they want it? Can't they self-fund it? Or do they just want other people to share the glory? Isn't the equipment shown in the video worth as much, or probably more?

$50k is also a rounding error in the budgets of national space agencies and private sector players in the space industry, many of whom might be interested in a magical and revolutionary propulsion technology that could - if possible to extend to larger satellites - dramatically increase the design life of existing satellites and reduce the risk of failing to attain the desired orbit.

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#17

I don't understand. $50K being asked by professors and PhD students? They certainly enjoy funds orders of magnitude more. $50K is like two YC startups' seed money. Why do they want it? Can't they self-fund it? Or do they just want other people to share the glory? Isn't the equipment shown in the video worth as much, or probably more?

"While we have obtained some external funding, this mission may never happen without your help."

I suppose I get it, but I thought Kickstarter campaigns required a deliverable end result as a result of contributions?

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#19
> CAT is currently at NASA Technology Readiness Level (TRL) 3, meaning we are in the midst of performing experiments to probe its feasibility, thanks to private sponsorship

Clicking on the link, 3 is a really far way from actually flying. Like, they haven't successfully demonstrated this in a lab yet. For reference, there are 9 stages, the final one being "it's in space".

It seems like an interesting idea, but I'm with the other commenters in asking why this needs money from outside the traditional channels. It's the kind of long-winded and technical writeup I would expect from a grant proposal, not a Kickstarter.

Re: Launch a Water-Propelled Satellite into Deep Space

#20
post #17

I don't understand. $50K being asked by professors and PhD students? They certainly enjoy funds orders of magnitude more. $50K is like two YC startups' seed money. Why do they want it? Can't they self-fund it? Or do they just want other people to share the glory? Isn't the equipment shown in the video worth as much, or probably more?

"While we have obtained some external funding, this mission may never happen without your help." I suppose I get it, but I thought Kickstarter campaigns required a deliverable end result as a result of contributions?

What do you mean by deliverable? "There will be a camera for science" is an end result.
Post reply on HN