Live data from Hacker News

Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

searchengineland.com

11–20 of 46 posts

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#11

The first thought that came to my mind was that she was unable to game the system anymore. Turns out I wasn't the only one. gettheyayo (dead comment) remarked > What's more likely to have happened: she lost her way of making money. She charged money and had to deliver. She no longer can thanks to Google.

Yes, I reckon that is what she meant by "my work here is done". It's a good thing, assuming it's true, but I have no idea whether it is.

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#12
post #10

I might be able to take comments like "rewarding content more" seriously if w3schools wasn't still at the top of almost every HTML, CSS, and JavaScript search query. I realized one day that I just use Google to quickly navigate a few websites I actually do use. This is something like the 99.9% case. At that point, I realized my search queries where I include the website I want and keywords I want to find in that site…

My experience isn't too different, but keep in mind that probably none of us here are close to the typical Google user as far as their typical expectations and how well those expectations are being met by their searches. (Most of us probably never click on Google's ads either, even though they somehow continue to earn Google millions of dollars. Not saying Google isn't becoming more irrelevant to average users, but our experiences don't necessarily give us a healthy perspective on that.)

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#13
Google only works well for English content. It is broken for other languages other than English. In my case, front page is full of spam content for a Turkish keyword that I want to compete. Even some sites are stealing my own unique content and somehow they are achieving better results than me. I suspect that Google needs more semantic data about language itself. I believe it will become more sophisticated as time goes. I understand that is not easy job to classify billions of keywords combinations for all languages.

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#14

"The tricks to beat and spam Google, Whalen said, no longer work as well." LOL. I know a half dozen guys who build millions of automated links every day. They say an easy term and they're in the top 5 results after 5 days, a hard term (a variety of diet pills, etc.) and it takes them a month. They get manually banned from time to time, but they just pull another URL from their pool and start over. It's gotten more so…

Google Engineers > "SEO" Monkeys

Note: I mean no slight to the folks who provide a genuine optimization service, just those who are essentially scammers.

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#15

"The tricks to beat and spam Google, Whalen said, no longer work as well." LOL. I know a half dozen guys who build millions of automated links every day. They say an easy term and they're in the top 5 results after 5 days, a hard term (a variety of diet pills, etc.) and it takes them a month. They get manually banned from time to time, but they just pull another URL from their pool and start over. It's gotten more so…

Hey Austen, if you'd be interested in sharing any specifics (companies, keywords, people, etc.) regarding people spamming by leaving millions of links gumming up the web, my team would be happy to investigate in more detail.

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#16

"The tricks to beat and spam Google, Whalen said, no longer work as well." LOL. I know a half dozen guys who build millions of automated links every day. They say an easy term and they're in the top 5 results after 5 days, a hard term (a variety of diet pills, etc.) and it takes them a month. They get manually banned from time to time, but they just pull another URL from their pool and start over. It's gotten more so…

Hey Austen, if you'd be interested in sharing any specifics (companies, keywords, people, etc.) regarding people spamming by leaving millions of links gumming up the web, my team would be happy to investigate in more detail.

Email me - email address in HN profile

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#17

"The tricks to beat and spam Google, Whalen said, no longer work as well." LOL. I know a half dozen guys who build millions of automated links every day. They say an easy term and they're in the top 5 results after 5 days, a hard term (a variety of diet pills, etc.) and it takes them a month. They get manually banned from time to time, but they just pull another URL from their pool and start over. It's gotten more so…

Hey Austen, if you'd be interested in sharing any specifics (companies, keywords, people, etc.) regarding people spamming by leaving millions of links gumming up the web, my team would be happy to investigate in more detail.

Hahaha do you seriously think he's gonna give up the keywords these guys are making money off.

Spamming sites still worked pre-hummingbird and infact it works even better now.

Even Negative SEO works just as well. Have a competitor you don't like? Give him 100k blog comments with "Buy Viagra" and suddenly he will be de indexed in 3 months or less.

I think half the reason she quit is that SEO is so damn unpredictable now. You can make a spammy site and might rank or might get de-indexed. But at the same time you can make a 100% whitehat site and it probably won't even rank and can get just as easily de-indexed as a blackhat spam site.

You need to read up on BlackHatWorld a bit more Mr Cutts.

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Austen, if you'd be interested in sharing any specifics (companies, keywords, people, etc.) regarding people spamming by leaving millions of links gumming up the web, my team would be happy to investigate in more detail.

Hahaha do you seriously think he's gonna give up the keywords these guys are making money off. Spamming sites still worked pre-hummingbird and infact it works even better now. Even Negative SEO works just as well. Have a competitor you don't like? Give him 100k blog comments with "Buy Viagra" and suddenly he will be de indexed in 3 months or less. I think half the reason she quit is that SEO is so damn unpredictable…

[deleted]

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#19
post #18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hahaha do you seriously think he's gonna give up the keywords these guys are making money off. Spamming sites still worked pre-hummingbird and infact it works even better now. Even Negative SEO works just as well. Have a competitor you don't like? Give him 100k blog comments with "Buy Viagra" and suddenly he will be de indexed in 3 months or less. I think half the reason she quit is that SEO is so damn unpredictable…

[deleted]

[deleted]

Re: Long-Time SEO Jill Whalen Moves On, Praises Google For Rewarding Content More

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Austen, if you'd be interested in sharing any specifics (companies, keywords, people, etc.) regarding people spamming by leaving millions of links gumming up the web, my team would be happy to investigate in more detail.

Email me - email address in HN profile

No one likes a snitch.
Post reply on HN