Live data from Hacker News

Building The Mac Pro

dylanreeve.com

11–20 of 27 posts

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#11

You can buy and modify a Toyota Supra to go faster than a Ferrari for much less money. Thats why nobody buys Ferrari's - there is just no point. And people buying Ferraris are just stupid for wasting their money when they could have a Toyota Supra instead.

I'm not sure why you are being sarcastic.

The article is just about the Mac Pro price. Conclusion: it's a fair price.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#12
post #10
post #3

I don't get why he speced the E5 CPU vs. the i7 but then also didn't use ECC RAM.

>"The only ECC-supporting motherboard I could find compatible with the CPU has no USB3, only supports 1600MHz RAM and only offers 3 PCIe slots."

Right, but I mean he should have dropped the CPU if he wasn't going to use ECC; the big advantages of the E5 are SMP and ECC, neither of which he was using. An i7 will be clocked higher and cost less, and come on a more useful motherboard for most workstations.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#13
So by dropping EEC, thunderbolt, the second ethernet port, wifi & bluetooth, he managed to shave $24 off the starting price?

I'm not sure what the take-away is here.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#14

You can buy and modify a Toyota Supra to go faster than a Ferrari for much less money. Thats why nobody buys Ferrari's - there is just no point. And people buying Ferraris are just stupid for wasting their money when they could have a Toyota Supra instead.

My take on the article is that its saying; you can buy a Toyota Supra and modify it but for about the same amount of money you could just get a Ferrari instead.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#15
The guy is using 4GB GPUs when comparing to the Pro's 2GB. Stating the obvious, but price is a big extrapolation of multiple apples to oranges comparisons.

I'd like to see this replicated based on benchmarks when the Pro gets here, and compare it to a real Hackintosh.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#16
Let's see what price Apple can negotiate for the 8 and 12 core options. This is where intel usually charges big. Those CPUs may be useful for high density computing in a datacenter, but not so much for a desktop where the user could have gotten two hexa cores for less money.

Personally I'm not excited about a Mac Pro with not much more CPU power than an iMac, other thant it is quite nifty. It's also nice to see workstations a little less dead than I'm used to, so I'm keeping my fingers crossed for the competitors.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#17
post #8

After reading the article, my takeaway was: 1. You can't build a Mac Pro equivalent with off the shelf parts (yet). 2. You can get kinda close, but you're not saving that much money. 3. The less close you're willing to get, the less money you'll spend, which is absolutely not interesting, surprising or relevant. In summary, the new Mac Pro is pretty awesomely priced and I'm going to order one for my lead dev.

just curious, what do you develop with it? I think the new Mac Pro is pretty awesome, but i dont really need that kind of power to work.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#19

The guy is using 4GB GPUs when comparing to the Pro's 2GB. Stating the obvious, but price is a big extrapolation of multiple apples to oranges comparisons. I'd like to see this replicated based on benchmarks when the Pro gets here, and compare it to a real Hackintosh.

If you are just looking for numbers, you can spec a pc for a much lower price to match those numbers. Just use a consumer CPU, non-ECC Ram and a Radeon GPU and you will probably match the processing power for half the price. Imo that comparison doesnt make alot of sense though, its apples vs oranges.

Re: Building The Mac Pro

#20
post #14

You can buy and modify a Toyota Supra to go faster than a Ferrari for much less money. Thats why nobody buys Ferrari's - there is just no point. And people buying Ferraris are just stupid for wasting their money when they could have a Toyota Supra instead.

My take on the article is that its saying; you can buy a Toyota Supra and modify it but for about the same amount of money you could just get a Ferrari instead.

its more like: If you buy a toyota supra and drop a ferrari engine and other ferrari performance parts into it, you will end up with the same price but a toyota supra instead of a ferrari.

You can certainly spec a PC with the same amount of processing power for much less than $3000

Post reply on HN