Live data from Hacker News

Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

blogs.smithsonianmag.com

11–20 of 59 posts

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#11
It's interesting to learn that movie theaters originally tried to establish themselves as highbrow institutions that drew inspiration from actual theaters. Sadly, not much is left of this ambition today.

The introduction of popcorn may have been one of the first steps of movie theaters to "open up to wider audiences", but as another thread points out, the artificial flavor and smells that surround the product today has not just found friends. Movie theaters, in their fight for customers, have had to lower their standards so drastically to attract new movie goers that others turned away in bewilderment. With the advent of home entertainment technology, both for audio and video, a fair amount of people now prefer the quiet, clean, comfortable, distraction-free screening in their own living room to a night at the movies.

At the same time, we're witnessing a big cultural landmark of the 20th century is dying out. It already has in some forms that had to make space for the mega multiplexes and super blockbusters.

In this context, the introduction of popcorn may have marked the beginning of a development in which the original attraction, the movie, became just one factor among many in the "movie going experience", thereby being devalued. In the end, movie theaters will have to answer to the question why they expect their customers to pay premium prices for these factors.

The business model of movie theaters, with or without popcorn, is not sustainable any more. Whether the disappearance of the cultural entity "movie theater" in its present form would still constitute a big cultural loss, or whether that loss has already happened long ago, is certainly worth debating.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#13
post #9

To me cinemas / movie theaters are about the film. I never eat or drink while I'm there... maybe I missed the memo.

To me, it depends on the film. If it's some brainless Hollywood sequel to a sequel of some action flick, I don't mind eating some popcorn every now and then. But that's not the only kind of movie I watch so, plus I'm getting older and more calorie-aware now, so more often than not I don't eat anything during a movie either.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#16

> Popcorn wasn’t widely eaten in homes, mostly due to how difficult it was to make: consumers needed a popper, oil, butter, salt... That's wrong, it's insanely easy to make. You don't need a "popper", just a pot with a lid. Any pot. And what kitchen doesn't have oil, butter and salt around? But since TV wasn't around yet, what were you going to eat it to? ;)

I have never actually seen a popcorn maker in anyone's home. Either people have used pots or microwaves, and it is very easy to use a pot.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#17

I can never eat popcorn at the movies because it's gone by the time the previews are over. Am I the only one?

Gone? I've never heard of it running out before. In fact I've heard of staff leaving their shift with trash-bags filled with extra popcorn they didn't sell.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#18
post #16

> Popcorn wasn’t widely eaten in homes, mostly due to how difficult it was to make: consumers needed a popper, oil, butter, salt... That's wrong, it's insanely easy to make. You don't need a "popper", just a pot with a lid. Any pot. And what kitchen doesn't have oil, butter and salt around? But since TV wasn't around yet, what were you going to eat it to? ;)

I have never actually seen a popcorn maker in anyone's home. Either people have used pots or microwaves, and it is very easy to use a pot.

I bought an air popper for popcorn on clearance a while ago. Has a few advantages to the "stove and pot," but it's not necessary really. Mostly it keeps the popcorn from burning if you're not paying close enough attention and the ratio of unpopped kernels is much lower.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#19
My wife pointed out is that one of the disposable lines in the article mentioned that until "talkies," movies were less of a "bread and circuses" pasttime - the illiterate don't get the full experience of a silent film.

Considering the storylines of many silent films, I'm rather amused to contemplate what that implies. Seriously, "Keystone Cops" is kind of like the "America's Got Talent" of its day - "Othello" it ain't.

Re: Why Do We Eat Popcorn at the Movies?

#20
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never actually seen a popcorn maker in anyone's home. Either people have used pots or microwaves, and it is very easy to use a pot.

I bought an air popper for popcorn on clearance a while ago. Has a few advantages to the "stove and pot," but it's not necessary really. Mostly it keeps the popcorn from burning if you're not paying close enough attention and the ratio of unpopped kernels is much lower.

I have an air popper, a stove-top popcorn popper (complete with a wire stirrer that you crank around with the lid closed), and a microwave. When I was growing up we had a popcorn popper that you held over a fire for fireplace popping. That was circa 1970.
Post reply on HN