Live data from Hacker News

Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

thelittleappfactory.com

11–20 of 48 posts

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#14
I love it. I can just drag my Youtube links from the browser address bar over to the Evom dock icon and it queues it up for download. It would be nice to be able to set a "default" capture type so it was automatic.

Also, some kind of bookmarklet would be nice. Maybe you can set your own system url handler which would make it easy to catch the links.

The popups are royally screwed up. There's no way to get rid of them (close). Examples are the beta notice, and the "Register..." popup.

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#15

May I suggest packaging it as a dmg instead of a zip? Doesn't make much difference other than that's what's usually expected

I hate DMGs. I know it seems to be the most common way of installing stuff, but, really, what's the point? I have to mount, drag, unmount. Zip's automatically get extracted by Safari, and you just drag it where you want it (or launch it from Downloads). One step, vs 3 steps.

A short example: my uncle's been using a mac for 5 years and still has absolutely no idea how to install programs on mac because of this convoluted process. DMGs need to die.

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#16
post #6

I have seen a few of this types of apps come through the Business of Software forums. Generally, a large portion of the enthusiasm for applications like this seems to be that people want to go to Youtube and download movies for free. These people are, for obvious reasons, not the best people in the world to sell software to.

Thats a good point. There's tons of free youtube downloaders anyways (I especially like keepvid.com). But I sort of like how Evom is a dual way helper, plus it'll re-encode the video for iPod.

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#17
post #15

May I suggest packaging it as a dmg instead of a zip? Doesn't make much difference other than that's what's usually expected

I hate DMGs. I know it seems to be the most common way of installing stuff, but, really, what's the point? I have to mount, drag, unmount. Zip's automatically get extracted by Safari, and you just drag it where you want it (or launch it from Downloads). One step, vs 3 steps. A short example: my uncle's been using a mac for 5 years and still has absolutely no idea how to install programs on mac because of this convolu…

You make an interesting point although our target market for Evom is people who aren't necessarily the most competent at using their Macs. We may consider switching to DMGs in this instance... may being the key word. :)

Thanks for your feedback though!

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#18
A couple of things...

First, great app. Very useful.

But, since most of these videos are already H.264 mpeg-4's, why the need for the conversion step, instead of simply wrapping it up in a quicktime container (if you even need to do that)? Conversion is painfully slow.

The popup dialogs are annoying.

Is there a bookmarklet? That would be awesome.

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#19
OK, after testing I have mixed thoughts. The interface is OK (though you really need a way to close the registration pane / beta warning), but the conversion process is painfully slow. It's been converting a 22 minute movie for the past 40 minutes now, and the bar is only at ~15%.

Also, do you really need the 'step 1 of 2' thing? Can't you just leave that out, and adjust the progress bar accordingly? Using multiple steps is confusing, as you have no idea how far the conversion really is.

Re: Dear News.YC: please review my Mac app, Evom

#20
post #18

A couple of things... First, great app. Very useful. But, since most of these videos are already H.264 mpeg-4's, why the need for the conversion step, instead of simply wrapping it up in a quicktime container (if you even need to do that)? Conversion is painfully slow. The popup dialogs are annoying. Is there a bookmarklet? That would be awesome.

The conversion is useful so the videos take up less space on iPhones / iPods. I use TubeTV, and I definitely appreciate the feature, because most of my iPhone's memory is taken up by music videos off of YouTube right now.
Post reply on HN