Live data from Hacker News

Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 84 posts

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#11
post #7

Did someone told him about « windows » ?

Wow, I didn’t think there’d be two comments saying this. This is about slums in Brazil and the Philippines, you should look up the conditions of the housing the people there live in. This is pretty high on the disconnection from reality scale.

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#12
post #8

Or you could just open a window.

I think you’re not really understanding the kind of housing this is made for. Shacks in slums don’t generally have nice triple glassed windows.

Yes, the alternative would be going outdoors. But in the tropics you don't want to do that during the midday sun.

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#14
I live off-grid, and have done so for nearly 20 years, and I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours.

I also dislike the idea of poking holes in my roof, for any reason.

I'm much more intersted in the gravity light which was featured here a few months ago.

http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gravitylight-lighting-for-...

Although the initial cost may be prohibitive for the poverty stricken, it may be well within the acceptable price range for many others, and the gravity light has the added bonus of not requiring any fuel, nor does it require punching holes in one's roof.

(I live in an upland rainforest)

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#15
The title of this article bothers me since the article focuses much more on the bottle and light and rather than how poor and proud Alfredo Moser is. Regardless, pretty cool exposure of life in the slums, I'd bet there are more 'hacks' as a means of survival that are necessary there, but we wouldn't think twice about.

I will say the article is good, just don't like the title.

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#16
post #14

I live off-grid, and have done so for nearly 20 years, and I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours. I also dislike the idea of poking holes in my roof, for any reason. I'm much more intersted in the gravity light which was featured here a few months ago. http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gravitylight-lighting-for-... Although the initial cost may be prohibitive for the poverty stricken, it may be well wi…

Lights are used indoors all day long in much of the world. If you don't like poking holes in your roof, then you probably don't like sun windows either.

The gravity light requires manual labor to produce light, has moving parts that are more likely to fail, is more costly, and produces less light.

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#17
post #14

I live off-grid, and have done so for nearly 20 years, and I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours. I also dislike the idea of poking holes in my roof, for any reason. I'm much more intersted in the gravity light which was featured here a few months ago. http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gravitylight-lighting-for-... Although the initial cost may be prohibitive for the poverty stricken, it may be well wi…

Would you share a bit more about your off-grid setup? (Power, water, sanitation etc...)

Or do you have any pictures you've shared or would like to share publicly?

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#18
post #14

I live off-grid, and have done so for nearly 20 years, and I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours. I also dislike the idea of poking holes in my roof, for any reason. I'm much more intersted in the gravity light which was featured here a few months ago. http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gravitylight-lighting-for-... Although the initial cost may be prohibitive for the poverty stricken, it may be well wi…

I see how a gadget might be more appealing to someone living off-grid by choice, but you can't beat a bottle filled with water.

Re: Bottle light inventor proud to be poor

#19
post #14

I live off-grid, and have done so for nearly 20 years, and I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours. I also dislike the idea of poking holes in my roof, for any reason. I'm much more intersted in the gravity light which was featured here a few months ago. http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/gravitylight-lighting-for-... Although the initial cost may be prohibitive for the poverty stricken, it may be well wi…

> I never needed indoor lighting during daylight hours

The way I figure, people in need of one of these lights probably won't have windows to let light into their homes, so it makes a bit more sense for their application.

Just my .02

Post reply on HN