Live data from Hacker News

How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

medium.com

11–20 of 162 posts

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#11
Seems to be a lengthy yet incomplete summary of the first 1/5th of The Four Hour Body (cited, at least).

Likewise I don't know where the 'I don't know how' bit fits in, given there's a massive explanation of how provided.

I am guessing written by a North American, given the 'we' in "I am frustrated with the lack of understanding that we have around nutrition, exercise and health". I shall assume the 'we' refers to 'people near me'.

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#12
There is a real problem for a subset of people regarding food addiction - particularly to sugar and certain carbohydrates. I am personally aware of people who have lost 50 to as much as 300+ lbs through a 12 step program called FA. It is not for everyone, but for some it has been a life-saver. http://www.foodaddicts.org/

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#14
post #3

I thought the article was going somewhere different, but it appears the answer is "diet and exercise"...

It's tough to for any author to reduce the concepts of weight management beyond 'calories in' and 'calories out.' I've been on a weight rollercoaster for the past 10 years, varying between 180 and 230 lbs and I've read many of the same books the author names, and while they all may lead to self-discovery on what makes YOUR body tick, none of them contain the mystical ONE THING that will cause you to lose 20 lbs in on…

It's also not very hard to lose 5lb if you are morbidly obese.

Harris-Benedict predicts that an individual should have an equilibrium bodyweight depending on their activity level and mean caloric intake. When your actual weight deviates from equilibrium, you will approach it along an exponential curve.

This means that if you alter your diet, your initial loss (or gain) will be rapid, while later losses/gains will be very slow. Graphs here:

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/weight_stability.html

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#18
He doesn't know how but he knows he loses weight by dieting and exercise, link bait title.

Furthermore, what he describes is a typical low-carb diet which works by suppressing your immune system (my experience with a low-carb diet, and the experiences of most people I know who have done a low-carb diet for long enough). After burning all your fat, you will get sick as hell (I had a 1 month fever at my lowest weight before deciding to stop it).

People with great metabolism can be fine on low-carb. But if you're seriously overweight, your metabolism is probably not great.

Slow carb diet by Tim Ferriss is a bit better because you ingest more carbs (and the cheating day maintain your immune system).

If you have cold feets/hands, inflammation (swollen gums for example), bloating, slow pulse, low libido or anything not normal, then your diet is not the right one.

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#19
post #3

I thought the article was going somewhere different, but it appears the answer is "diet and exercise"...

It's tough to for any author to reduce the concepts of weight management beyond 'calories in' and 'calories out.' I've been on a weight rollercoaster for the past 10 years, varying between 180 and 230 lbs and I've read many of the same books the author names, and while they all may lead to self-discovery on what makes YOUR body tick, none of them contain the mystical ONE THING that will cause you to lose 20 lbs in on…

I didn't lose 20 lbs in 1 week, but cutting wheat, corn, and dairy from my diet and upping my vegetable intake to 5-7 servings/day has caused me to lose 30 lbs over the past 4 months.

Re: How I have lost over 100 pounds and don’t know how

#20
post #3

I thought the article was going somewhere different, but it appears the answer is "diet and exercise"...

"diet and exercise"

He went in the "personality diet" direction, not just diet, which was pretty weird because he basically went paleo although is being very careful not to use the phrase. Tip toe all around it. I don't know if there's a legal explosion going on or what about the term, because I've noticed this elsewhere.

The Paleo thing is pretty easy to implement if you know anything about food, most of the time, the more recently it was added to the rich western diet, the less of it you should be eating. Just make a ranking and try to reasonably optimize at the store. Pretty simple and cheap and easy to implement. Tastes pretty good too.

It really pisses people off because there's no diet industry personalities to make money, no guilt inducing neo-puritanism, no weird expensive foods to buy. Kind of a post-capitalism diet, other than I have to haunt my produce aisle at the store about twice a week rather than once a week back when I mostly ate "psuedo-food" out of freezer boxes. I do spend less money on food, so what I waste in extra gasoline becomes just a rounding error.

Post reply on HN