Live data from Hacker News

Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

cbc.ca

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#11
post #7

So it's already an "illegal" protest? They could make all protesting illegal and then they've got the population headed towards 3 felonies a day. Fun fact: Canada has two oil pipeline spills a day, minimum. Just don't protest it. Sometimes I wonder if we are exporting our legal and political insanity up there. Does Canada have a "right to assembly" like we supposedly (but not actually) do in the US ?

> Fun fact Source?

Many sources, here is one

http://globalnews.ca/news/571494/introduction-37-years-of-oi...

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#13
post #12
post #10

Time to break out the wigs, face paint and glasses?

Just use Groucho Glasses? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groucho_glasses https://www.google.com/search?q=Groucho+glasses&prmdo=1&gbv=...

I don't know, those may constitute a mask.

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#15

In Germany wearing masks (and protective gear) to even legal protests is outlawed, too. Though you get 'only' max 1 year and not 10 years for doing so. For the riot police it's inverse: They don't have to be uniquely identifiable [2]. I personally don't think that such laws should exist in democratic systems. [1] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermummungsverbot (in german) [2] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kennzeichnung…

The same is true in Denmark, although I don't recall anyone being charged for doing so.

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#18
Maybe there's an argument for making masks illegal at protests (even though it doesn't feel right) - but 10 years in prison just for showing up at a protest with a mask?! What's the penalty for actually vandalizing a store with a mask during a protest then? 30 years?

This penalty makes me think that it's just the government really not wanting people to protest, and trying to restrict protests as much as possible. The "western" governments are seeing what's happening in other countries and how easily revolutions could start now, so they are working on ways to limit protests and drastically punish protesters as soon as they show up for one, to try and prevent future such protests in their countries, too.

Too bad they don't realize that this will only make people increasingly angrier with their governments over time, and they're just asking for a violent revolution if they do that. The more they deny their citizens peaceful protests, and the more they back them into a corner, the more the citizens will feel like they have no choice but respond with violence at a mass protest (especially if there's police brutality). They're asking for it. Good democracies allow protests for a reason, but I think when certain politicians get to power, they forget why.

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#19
post #18

Maybe there's an argument for making masks illegal at protests (even though it doesn't feel right) - but 10 years in prison just for showing up at a protest with a mask?! What's the penalty for actually vandalizing a store with a mask during a protest then? 30 years? This penalty makes me think that it's just the government really not wanting people to protest, and trying to restrict protests as much as possible. The…

Too bad they don't realize that this will only make people increasingly angrier...

I'm pretty sure that people who propose and enact laws like this genuinely believe they'll cause people to change their behavior, and that the people whose behavior it won't change should be locked up, anyway.

It's the same kind of fantasy as believing that DRM actually has a meaningful impact on piracy.

Re: Wearing a mask at an illegal protest is now a crime in Canada

#20
If everyone driving down a highway is going above the speed limit, are they all doing the wrong thing? Do they all risk being singled out by the highway patrol?

If everyone wears a mask, or at least the majority, can those being singled out for wearing one use some sort of argument that everyone was wearing one? At what point does a "lawful protest" become an "illegal riot" because if the former turns into the latter all of a sudden, can you argue your way out of it?

In any event, seems as ridiculous as charging illegal downloaders hundreds of thousands, rather than something reasonable, for downloading an album, or what-have-you.

Post reply on HN