Live data from Hacker News

Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

code.google.com

11–20 of 60 posts

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#11
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quebec's case is rather their laws regarding contests, lotteries etc. Basically any contest from outside Canada won't give a damn about working all of those rules in (if it's even possible at all), so they are simply banned from essentially all international competitions of this kind :)

Since the competition is being held by a company outside of Quebec, do they need to abide to these laws at all?

In their interactions with Quebec residents, apparently yes.

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#12
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quebec's case is rather their laws regarding contests, lotteries etc. Basically any contest from outside Canada won't give a damn about working all of those rules in (if it's even possible at all), so they are simply banned from essentially all international competitions of this kind :)

Since the competition is being held by a company outside of Quebec, do they need to abide to these laws at all?

If they want to offer their contest to residents of Quebec, yes, they must abide by local laws and regulations.

Running a contest in a given jurisdiction is a form of doing business in that jurisdiction, and so of course the contest is subject to whatever regulations that jurisdiction applies to that activity (contests, in this case). Imagine if this were not the case, and anybody could avoid complying with local laws just by calling their activity a 'contest' and running it out of some foreign jurisdiction.

So, by saying people in Quebec can't play, Google is not required to abide the unusual laws that they have there around contests and lotteries.

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#13
post #10
post #3

Quebec has weird laws about competitions. ( http://www.advertisinglawyer.ca/advertising.htm ) ( http://business.financialpost.com/2011/09/08/why-many-contes... )

As Eastern European I am a little bit satisfied that even reasonable Canadians do stupid things. Still I hope they will reconsider this law.

[deleted]

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#14
Another example of Quebec being a totalitarian regime. A bit different from some others in this world though. A place where one can increase funding for a language Gestapo, who fines restaurant owners who don't properly translate pasta in their menu, while cutting social spending. All for the benefit of the residents. Go Quebec!

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#16
post #3

Quebec has weird laws about competitions. ( http://www.advertisinglawyer.ca/advertising.htm ) ( http://business.financialpost.com/2011/09/08/why-many-contes... )

I was humorously assuming it was because almost all programming languages have key words in English. The Imp of the Recursive in my head was imagining an alternate programming culture like a Quebec version of steam-punk.

there are some public and private institutions where we can't use an english keyword for our variables and functions name.....I'm not joking!!

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#17
post #3

Quebec has weird laws about competitions. ( http://www.advertisinglawyer.ca/advertising.htm ) ( http://business.financialpost.com/2011/09/08/why-many-contes... )

I was humorously assuming it was because almost all programming languages have key words in English. The Imp of the Recursive in my head was imagining an alternate programming culture like a Quebec version of steam-punk.

You're not too far off. Companies have to, with growing size, do more and more stuff in french. At large companies that aren't exempt you must have a french keyboard for example and code comments have to be in french.

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#18
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was humorously assuming it was because almost all programming languages have key words in English. The Imp of the Recursive in my head was imagining an alternate programming culture like a Quebec version of steam-punk.

there are some public and private institutions where we can't use an english keyword for our variables and functions name.....I'm not joking!!

Wow. I've heard that all of these "you have to use French" rules in Quebec are a reaction to years of French-Canadians in Quebec being treated as second class to the English-Canadians. Doesn't make them any less stupid.

Re: Why aren't Cubans, Quebecois, Saudis, Syrians allowed in Google Code Jam

#19
post #14

Another example of Quebec being a totalitarian regime. A bit different from some others in this world though. A place where one can increase funding for a language Gestapo, who fines restaurant owners who don't properly translate pasta in their menu, while cutting social spending. All for the benefit of the residents. Go Quebec!

Better post the French translation of this rant soon, or suffer the consequences :)
Post reply on HN