Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Creative Market for Photoshop

creativemarket.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#11

Post by TheCoreh »

mistercow wrote: post #4

While I appreciate that you're going for a Photoshop UI theme in the browser panel there (and I think it's very nice in terms of presentation), I think it's a big mistake to use decorative UI elements that don't actually work. It's impossible for a user to look at that panel and tell what is actual UI, and what is merely decoration, which is disorienting and frustrating.

I might be wrong, but I think if you're a heavy Photoshop user (their target demographic) you'll be already familiar with the panels Photoshop provides, and their custom panel will draw your attention. IMO, the "Try Me" banner also ensures the user keeps their attention focused on the demo.

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#12

Post by cwilson »

This idea is simply brilliant. You've reduced the friction it takes for me to buy an asset that I might not have otherwise purchased to essentially one click, at exactly the right moment (the moment I need it, without breaking my work-flow or concentration).

My first suggestion would be to figure out how to market the hell out of this. There are some really great Photoshop plugins out there that I've seen pop up on HN maybe once or twice at most and I've spoken to designer friends in person who have never heard of them. The first step would be to look into advertising on the design blogs and sites like http://beautifulpixels.com/. You might then look into a sponsored post on DaringFireball or similar site (from what I've heard, the ROI on his posts is pretty good).

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#13

Post by brianreavis »

mattrandle wrote: post #10

Nice idea and implementation. Was it difficult building the plugin for photoshop ? I ask because I have been toying with building a photoshop plugin for handling feedback on designs. i.e. the plugin allows you to upload a design to a website where customers can comment. The plugin would allow you to view the comments from within Photoshop.

Tomorrow I'm going to write a post on all that went into making it. To be honest, it's not difficult to get into—with extensions running on top of AIR, the learning curve isn't steep. The main difficulties come from random platform bugs and poor documentation. Things like:

- Occasionally when a panel starts, the wrapper from Adobe that loads in your extension will be incorrectly sized... which leaves the panel with a giant white space at the bottom. To fix it, increment then decrement the height by one to get it to recalculate its size.

- On CS5.0 (only), the panel is rendered darker than it should be (so if you set the background color to the color the SDK tells you it is, you'll end up something that doesn't match up with the Photoshop UI (this might be mx:HTML specific).

- On CS6, mx:HTML causes a hard Photoshop crash sometimes (no idea why, it's blackbox). Posted on Adobe Forums... no one seems to know.

TL;DR: Barrier of entry is low. Strange issues make it hard. Sadly many of them are out of your control as a 3rd-party developer.

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#14

Post by BSousa »

iconfinder wrote: post #5
bluetidepro wrote: post #3

This is an incredible idea coming from the Creative Market. Very well done. I wonder how long it takes Envato (Theme Forest, Code Canyon, etc.) to make a version of this for their products/sites.

Or Iconfinder :-D

I was sure www.iconfinder.com was your site, but I took a look at the profile just to see if I could copy paste it instead of typing it (I'm lazy).

You have the url as www.confinder.com there ;)

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#15

Post by binaryorganic »

I like this, but it also underscores one of the reasons I'm skeptical of this specific marketplace. I find it very difficult to actually know what I'm buying. Assets are often little more than a generic description with a few hard to see thumbnails tacked on to show you what you'll get.

I've definitely found myself hoping for more detail / product information. While this looks well-implemented I wonder if it won't take me a step further away from what I'm buying, which is the reverse of what I want.

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#16

Post by BHSPitMonkey »

brianreavis wrote: post #13
mattrandle wrote: post #10

Nice idea and implementation. Was it difficult building the plugin for photoshop ? I ask because I have been toying with building a photoshop plugin for handling feedback on designs. i.e. the plugin allows you to upload a design to a website where customers can comment. The plugin would allow you to view the comments from within Photoshop.

Tomorrow I'm going to write a post on all that went into making it. To be honest, it's not difficult to get into—with extensions running on top of AIR, the learning curve isn't steep. The main difficulties come from random platform bugs and poor documentation. Things like: - Occasionally when a panel starts, the wrapper from Adobe that loads in your extension will be incorrectly sized... which leaves the panel with a…

Thanks for sharing those!

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#18

Post by shuzchen »

brianreavis wrote: post #13
mattrandle wrote: post #10

Nice idea and implementation. Was it difficult building the plugin for photoshop ? I ask because I have been toying with building a photoshop plugin for handling feedback on designs. i.e. the plugin allows you to upload a design to a website where customers can comment. The plugin would allow you to view the comments from within Photoshop.

Tomorrow I'm going to write a post on all that went into making it. To be honest, it's not difficult to get into—with extensions running on top of AIR, the learning curve isn't steep. The main difficulties come from random platform bugs and poor documentation. Things like: - Occasionally when a panel starts, the wrapper from Adobe that loads in your extension will be incorrectly sized... which leaves the panel with a…

brian initially started work on the extension, then I did for a few months, now it's back on brian's plate. In my experience it was rough debugging anything within the webview after being used to the power of chrome dev tools and firebug. For the most part I was able to test the webview bits in an actual browser, but it was those times where the embedded browser behaved differently that really made things rough.

Debugging things within AIR was easy though, and although I had near-nil prior experience with actionscript my javascript background got me up and running right away.

Re: Creative Market for Photoshop

#19

Post by brianreavis »

mattrandle wrote: post #10

Nice idea and implementation. Was it difficult building the plugin for photoshop ? I ask because I have been toying with building a photoshop plugin for handling feedback on designs. i.e. the plugin allows you to upload a design to a website where customers can comment. The plugin would allow you to view the comments from within Photoshop.

Just put up a post that gives a complete breakdown of what went into it — https://creativemarket.com/blog/2013/04/12/how-we-built-a-ph...
Post reply on HN