Live data from Hacker News

I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

http

11–20 of 101 posts

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#11
I agree with all of sentiments in the blog post but this:

“Why should almost 40% of my time be taken up by adverts for something I am ALREADY paying for?”

Your cable subscription is a partial payment for viewing the shows. It's works in the same way as buying a newspaper or magazine: the revenues from newsstand sales are a fraction of what it costs to create and distribute the publication. The rest is paid through advertising. Even more, subscription prices are kept low so that the publishers can claim a certain degree of readership, thus being able to ask certain advertising rates.

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#12
Pirating has become a much higher quality entertainment experience than any other. The pace of development is insane, and the things you can do with pirated content these days are, in a word, wonderful.

Let's say I pirated a show called Fest of Kings. The hour Fest of Kings aired, it would already be on my home media server. It would have downloaded at about 6MB/second (that's MegaBytes) over a secure SSL connection and be done in about 5 minutes flat in 720p HD. The moment it finished downloading, it would be available to watch on a beautiful media center in my living room, as well as on any internet-connected computer, as well as on my phone (Plex is amazing).

This is better than DVR, it's better than On Demand, and it's a breeze to use (it's not a breeze to set up, but whatever).

It's also not free. You pay for certain services you download from, you pay for the Plex Pro subscription to be able to stream your content to your phone, you pay for the Plex app, you pay for various management apps. It's not ridiculously expensive, but it's not free.

If there was a legitimate content source that did all this well, and gave me the content I wanted when I wanted it (right when it airs), I would be paying for it. But there isn't. This is a far better experience than any alternative. It's just awesome.

And that's why piracy is a problem.

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#13

    People have always been, and always will be, willing 
    to pay for good products. We have always understood 
    Return on Investment, even if we don’t call it that.
Which is why World Of Goo[0], a fantastic indie game that was priced at $20, that has a 90 / 100 Metacritic score[1], that has absolutely no DRM is a game that had over 80% piracy rate at launch? The "People want to pay it's just the companies stopping them" argument is so much bunk it's insulting that people continue to write it.

People want stuff consequence free, if they have to pay to get rid of those consequences then they will. For a lot of people the consequences of media piracy are non-existant, they don't believe they will ever be caught (and it's not as if "getting caught" even matters) so the only result of media piracy is... saving money! So they do it. For me a consequence of media piracy is knowing I did not pay for something I have, that is why I don't engage in media piracy. For people that don't have this feeling that they should pay why would they?

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_Goo

[1] http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/world-of-goo

[2] http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2008/11/15/world-of-goo-pira...

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#14

I agree with all of sentiments in the blog post but this: “Why should almost 40% of my time be taken up by adverts for something I am ALREADY paying for?” Your cable subscription is a partial payment for viewing the shows. It's works in the same way as buying a newspaper or magazine: the revenues from newsstand sales are a fraction of what it costs to create and distribute the publication. The rest is paid through ad…

[deleted]

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#15
The argument of "I paid for it so I can pirate it" is especially funny when coupled with "Too many ads!"

When you watch a show on cable, you're not just paying with your subscription but with your eyeballs. Advertisements, shockingly, aren't designed merely to irritate the viewer but to bring in more revenues.

(What do you think is going to happen when Sky realizes that their viewership is down even if their membership is stable?)

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#16

I agree with all of sentiments in the blog post but this: “Why should almost 40% of my time be taken up by adverts for something I am ALREADY paying for?” Your cable subscription is a partial payment for viewing the shows. It's works in the same way as buying a newspaper or magazine: the revenues from newsstand sales are a fraction of what it costs to create and distribute the publication. The rest is paid through ad…

I wonder how much people would pay for advertising-free television?

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#17

I have a netflix subscription and find it more convenient than pirating. It's less of an effort for me to sit down, turn on my PS3 and run netflix than it is to find a torrent, download a huge file, transfer the file to a NAS, turn on my PVR and select the file to watch. Unfortunately netflix doesn't have everything and the netflix UK selection is sometimes really far behind what the US get so I have to either change…

Netflix is a good start, but what I want is Spotify for television.

Name your price, networks, I'd pay for a super-premium Netflix in a heartbeat. It just doesn't exist yet.

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#19
post #14

I agree with all of sentiments in the blog post but this: “Why should almost 40% of my time be taken up by adverts for something I am ALREADY paying for?” Your cable subscription is a partial payment for viewing the shows. It's works in the same way as buying a newspaper or magazine: the revenues from newsstand sales are a fraction of what it costs to create and distribute the publication. The rest is paid through ad…

[deleted]

EDIT: I don't know why parent deleted his post, but the message was that HBO doesn't run commercials. (Which is true, although it does run promotions for upcoming HBO programs in between programs.)

Right, which also explains both why a HBO subscription costs so much and why they air so many reruns. However, not in all locales can one order HBO without also having a cable subscription.

Re: I pirated Game of Thrones season premiere

#20
post #15

The argument of "I paid for it so I can pirate it" is especially funny when coupled with "Too many ads!" When you watch a show on cable, you're not just paying with your subscription but with your eyeballs. Advertisements, shockingly, aren't designed merely to irritate the viewer but to bring in more revenues. (What do you think is going to happen when Sky realizes that their viewership is down even if their membersh…

That's addressed in the article.

And Sky get this. If you wait another 24 hours, the show appears on “Sky Anytime”, and you can watch it with no adverts and at any time you please. The adverts are an additional tax on the consumer for having the audacity to watch the programme when Sky decides.

Are you playing by the rules? Yes? Are you paying for the show? Yes. Are you watching it when we say? Yes? Are you watching it where we say you can? Yes? Good for you, here’s some adverts as a punishment.

And people wonder why that business model is failing…

Post reply on HN