Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Formspring Shuts Down

techcrunch.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#11

Post by Hovertruck »

skore wrote: post #10
pbreit wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, actually Instagram had around 30 million users at the time of acquisition and according to the linked article Formspring also had around 30 million users at one point. Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had.

> Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had. Yeah, lies, damn lies and statistics ;-) I rarely ever saw a formspring Q&A that was bustling with activity while it was quite the opposite for Instagram. Not sure I like that, though, but I guess that's human nature. They claim 4 billion posts - would be interesting to see the Q to A ratio.

Back when formspring was "big" a few years ago I remember seeing it all over the place.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#12

Post by iampims »

skore wrote: post #10
pbreit wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, actually Instagram had around 30 million users at the time of acquisition and according to the linked article Formspring also had around 30 million users at one point. Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had.

> Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had. Yeah, lies, damn lies and statistics ;-) I rarely ever saw a formspring Q&A that was bustling with activity while it was quite the opposite for Instagram. Not sure I like that, though, but I guess that's human nature. They claim 4 billion posts - would be interesting to see the Q to A ratio.

We’re at 4+ billion responses. Obviously, many more questions were sent. If you were to guess 5Q/1R you wouldn’t be far.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#13

Post by spullara »

iampims wrote: post #12
skore wrote: post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had. Yeah, lies, damn lies and statistics ;-) I rarely ever saw a formspring Q&A that was bustling with activity while it was quite the opposite for Instagram. Not sure I like that, though, but I guess that's human nature. They claim 4 billion posts - would be interesting to see the Q to A ratio.

We’re at 4+ billion responses. Obviously, many more questions were sent. If you were to guess 5Q/1R you wouldn’t be far.

Brutal ROI for writing a Q.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#14

Post by neya »

unreal37 wrote: post #4

Formsprint raised $14 Million? I'd like to see that business plan.

Honestly, this was coming and everyone knew it. Only an illiterate would believe in someone trying to get rich building just forms. Sigh, I wish only one thing - That more people realized that you need to solve problems instead of trying to build the next cool thing! I wish this 14 million was donated to something else that could have impacted our lives - Like a new motor technology or an electric car. I can't imagine anyone rational funding 14 million on a company that had just forms (for consumers) as its business model.

Personally, I stopped using this service the moment it started spamming my inbox with boring questions.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#15

Post by scwu »

skore wrote: post #10
pbreit wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, actually Instagram had around 30 million users at the time of acquisition and according to the linked article Formspring also had around 30 million users at one point. Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had.

> Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had. Yeah, lies, damn lies and statistics ;-) I rarely ever saw a formspring Q&A that was bustling with activity while it was quite the opposite for Instagram. Not sure I like that, though, but I guess that's human nature. They claim 4 billion posts - would be interesting to see the Q to A ratio.

I was in high school when it was released. It was notoriously ubiquitous. Everyone had one. People said terrible things to each other - it was a free place to trash anyone you hated and really get them down.

Then, there was a rumor that Formspring was a huge fraud and was built as a complete joke and that they'd release the names of all the people who had posted questions on April Fool's. People freaked out and stopped posting, and those who had Formsprings released that they were happier without Formspring.

This is obviously a very microscopic look, but it wouldn't surprise me if Formspring did achieve the numbers they reported. I didn't know any peers of mine who didn't have one, back in the day and the "popular kids" at my school got hundreds of questions a week about everything.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#16

Post by yogo »

mattryanharris wrote: post #3

I'm really not surprised, Formspring was around when I was in high school and to be honest I stopped using it after day 3 because it got boring and there was nothing too interesting about it.

Lots of respect for what these guys have done and accomplished but at the end of the day I have to ask can it pass the Shark Tank test.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#17

Post by aptwebapps »

neya wrote: post #14
unreal37 wrote: post #4

Formsprint raised $14 Million? I'd like to see that business plan.

Honestly, this was coming and everyone knew it. Only an illiterate would believe in someone trying to get rich building just forms. Sigh, I wish only one thing - That more people realized that you need to solve problems instead of trying to build the next cool thing! I wish this 14 million was donated to something else that could have impacted our lives - Like a new motor technology or an electric car. I can't imagin…

Wufoo exited for 35 million. Although they didn't take 14 million in investment: just 118,000 according this:

http://techcrunch.com/2011/04/25/wufoo-35-million-surveymonk...

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#18

Post by neya »

aptwebapps wrote: post #17
neya wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly, this was coming and everyone knew it. Only an illiterate would believe in someone trying to get rich building just forms. Sigh, I wish only one thing - That more people realized that you need to solve problems instead of trying to build the next cool thing! I wish this 14 million was donated to something else that could have impacted our lives - Like a new motor technology or an electric car. I can't imagin…

Wufoo exited for 35 million. Although they didn't take 14 million in investment: just 118,000 according this: http://techcrunch.com/2011/04/25/wufoo-35-million-surveymonk...

I think Wufoo solves a REAL problem - Collection of useful data. That's why it appeals to businesses and enterprises.

Whereas Formspring was more like a third party Facebook status box that served no real purpose (Their slogan was "Formspring is the place to share your perspective on anything."). The difference lies in the target audience - One was aimed at the consumer and the other at the enterprise.

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#19

Post by iampims »

spullara wrote: post #13
iampims wrote: post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We’re at 4+ billion responses. Obviously, many more questions were sent. If you were to guess 5Q/1R you wouldn’t be far.

Brutal ROI for writing a Q.

Direct questions hover around 1/1. Questions sent to followers, 5/1. It’s probably a higher engagement, albeit different, than Tumblr/Twitter/FB.

When you ask a question on Twitter, how many of your followers respond? Very few. The nature of both sites is obviously different, but the engagement on Formspring remains pretty good.

Also, there’s only so many times you can answer a question about your favorite movie, or where you met your husband/wife before it gets boring. Original questions (with photos, links, tags) get a far higher response rate.

You really think 5/1 is bad?

Re: Formspring Shuts Down

#20

Post by iampims »

scwu wrote: post #15
skore wrote: post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Having said that, I never used Formspring and didn't know anyone who ever had. Yeah, lies, damn lies and statistics ;-) I rarely ever saw a formspring Q&A that was bustling with activity while it was quite the opposite for Instagram. Not sure I like that, though, but I guess that's human nature. They claim 4 billion posts - would be interesting to see the Q to A ratio.

I was in high school when it was released. It was notoriously ubiquitous. Everyone had one. People said terrible things to each other - it was a free place to trash anyone you hated and really get them down. Then, there was a rumor that Formspring was a huge fraud and was built as a complete joke and that they'd release the names of all the people who had posted questions on April Fool's. People freaked out and stopp…

Those numbers are real – even a tiny bit lower than the real ones just because round numbers are easier to remember.
Post reply on HN