Live data from Hacker News

Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 101 posts

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#11
Google has completely jumped the shark and is now being controlled by mindless business drones that will drive the company into the ground in just a few years. For your consideration:

They allow a patent troll to potentially set a legal precedent for what constitutes a big part of their app infrastructure. They probably figured that its cheaper to build around the patent and let this one developer eat shit.

They are killing net neutrality by saying mobile networks are somehow special and don't need it, a very obvious move to bolster Android and their telco relationships. They are now apparently paying Orange in France for mobile traffic related to services like YouTube [1], again trading short term business sense for eventually losing the net neutrality fight and turning the whole internet into many walled gardens at the hands of ISPs.

They have settled with news websites in France [2] to avert legal repercussions by a government that is essentially being blackmailed by press. 60 millions is pocket change for them, but the precedent this sets will endanger their business in many countries where press is dying and abusing their power to force governments to pass laws that will benefit their old business models very much to the detriment of Google. They are facing the same thing in Germany right now. News websites by the old printing press garde are the antithesis to the web. They do not understand hyperlinks, they do not understand the importance of giving access to raw material in a Wikileaks era. This move by Google perpetuates their dying business model and damages its own products like News or YouTube, which is thriving as an alternative to the old publisher model in media and music.

They let media companies patrol their data (and search rankings) and remove content by automatically generated requests, no questions asked, at exponentially growing scale [3]. They pretend to be under legal obligations to do so, but intentionally muddle the process to the point where if your content is contended, they give you no recourse under DMCA [4].

Sorry, I'm somewhat consumed by rage after reading the comments of the UniLoc persona non grata.

1: http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5ipkAQJJNg...

2: http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5ipwetvKBf...

3: http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/removals/copyright/

4: http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/12/youtube-universal-m...

  Universal said Google’s private system doesn’t count as an
  official takedown notice under the Digital Millennium
  Copyright Act, and thus it was immune from legal   liability.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#12
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand your feeling of helplessness, but supporting the people that stand up and fight against these patent trolls seems like a good place to start. Signing the petition costs nothing, and there's a chance that it could have a real and lasting impact on the patent system. Donating to Austin Meyer's legal defence fund is much cheaper—both financially and emotionally—than having to defend against a patent troll y…

I didn't see a link to donate. Wouldn't it be better for the FSF to create a generic fund that agressively went after these trolls? I'd give a couple hundred dollars a year.

I'd donate at least a couple hundred a year if the FSF/EFF did this exactly.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#14
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand your feeling of helplessness, but supporting the people that stand up and fight against these patent trolls seems like a good place to start. Signing the petition costs nothing, and there's a chance that it could have a real and lasting impact on the patent system. Donating to Austin Meyer's legal defence fund is much cheaper—both financially and emotionally—than having to defend against a patent troll y…

I didn't see a link to donate. Wouldn't it be better for the FSF to create a generic fund that agressively went after these trolls? I'd give a couple hundred dollars a year.

> Wouldn't it be better for the FSF to create a generic fund that agressively went after these trolls?

No, that only treats the symptoms. It would be much better to cure the disease -- the broken patent system.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#15

What if someone could get a patent on "a method of starting a business whose sole purpose is acquiring many patents and then suing large companies"? Could they destroy all patent trolls?

This is close: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/08/01/157743897/can-you-...

(In 2007 IBM and Haliburton filed for patents on being patent troll.)

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#16
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand your feeling of helplessness, but supporting the people that stand up and fight against these patent trolls seems like a good place to start. Signing the petition costs nothing, and there's a chance that it could have a real and lasting impact on the patent system. Donating to Austin Meyer's legal defence fund is much cheaper—both financially and emotionally—than having to defend against a patent troll y…

I didn't see a link to donate. Wouldn't it be better for the FSF to create a generic fund that agressively went after these trolls? I'd give a couple hundred dollars a year.

http://www.x-plane.com/x-world/lawsuit/

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#17

More detailed look at the patent: http://www.google.com/patents?id=K7MoAAAAEBAJ&printsec=a... If you want to check a unique serial number securely, either over the phone or net you are violating this patent. Seems a little broad.

20 years ago I (and many others) had shareware registration systems that did this kind of thing. ShareIt ring a bell with anyone?

There's absolutely no way that there isn't prior art for this.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#18
post #2

I honestly don't even know what to say when these things come up nowadays. It just seems like the bullshit won't end. I can't think of any options that even exist to fix this broken patent system.

I'm studying in Germany abroad and i have a u.s. green card. After reading so much crap about u.s. patent system, i'm really considering staying in Germany or immigrate to another country ( like Singapore ?? ) and start a business there.

I know, one person doesn't make a difference furthermore i'm not a "very important super mega top ninja hipster talented programmer" and every county has it's own problems. The thing is, i really don't like the idea that, my company can go to bankruptcy because law doesn't protect me and i have to live with fear and try to stay out of some patent troll's radar.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#19
post #12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't see a link to donate. Wouldn't it be better for the FSF to create a generic fund that agressively went after these trolls? I'd give a couple hundred dollars a year.

I'd donate at least a couple hundred a year if the FSF/EFF did this exactly.

Ditto.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#20

What if someone could get a patent on "a method of starting a business whose sole purpose is acquiring many patents and then suing large companies"? Could they destroy all patent trolls?

IBM did it.
Post reply on HN