Live data from Hacker News

GitLab v4.1 released

blog.gitlab.org

11–20 of 34 posts

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#11

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

I guess make a bad UI just for difference with github is a worse

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#12
post #10

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

I don't think they are actually driving any business away from github or I'd be more angry. This seems to fit a niche for people that would like to use github but legally can't put their code online (even in a private repository). It's github for intranets. Agree though, github deserves all the karma we can throw at it.

GitHub does cater to that niche: https://enterprise.github.com/

However, it starts at $5000 per year and the main group amongst people I've heard using GitLab has been companies not willing to pay that $5000 (but who otherwise would probably go with GitHub - that is, they're 'satisficing' rather than choosing GitLab as such).

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#13
post #5

I run GitLab on my development VPS and use it for all my projects (and everything to do with them, including client interaction via the wall and issues). It's quite brilliant. I nearly decided to hack in a Public Mode myself last year, I'm glad it's finally implemented! This has prompted me into getting back to work on my KanBan SPA, that hooks into GitLabs issues api. I do wish they gave the api a bit more love in t…

What do you use for the webmail/calendaring/contacts?

For webmail I can recommend roundcube + dovecot, for calendaring/contacts davical has all I need.

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#14

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

They have actually changed the UI from earlier versions, probably to make it look less like github, and it does look very different[1] to github now.

I like the new look (I think it's more usable than github). In particular I find the "Commits"-tab more intuitive for inspecting code across multiple branches, even though I can't exactly put my finger on the reason. On github I often have to double-check which branch I'm looking at, on GitLab it feels more natural to me.

Basically the only UI-change I would make at this point is on the project-homepage. I'd show those tooltips to the right of the filter-buttons (not above) so they don't cover the other buttons while you hover.

[1] http://demo.gitlabhq.com/

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#15

Finally. Resque is such a PITA with Gitlab. Hopefully the upgrade script will work properly now. I have to fix quite a few bits and pieces every upgrade. Top piece of software, though.

I've been recommending Sidekiq to people for the past few months and it's great to see it being picked up by more projects. It's quicker than Resque for everything I've tried it on.

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#16
post #14

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

They have actually changed the UI from earlier versions, probably to make it look less like github, and it does look very different[1] to github now. I like the new look (I think it's more usable than github). In particular I find the "Commits"-tab more intuitive for inspecting code across multiple branches, even though I can't exactly put my finger on the reason. On github I often have to double-check which branch I…

Looks pretty similar to GitHub for me http://gitlab.org/screenshots/

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#17
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They have actually changed the UI from earlier versions, probably to make it look less like github, and it does look very different[1] to github now. I like the new look (I think it's more usable than github). In particular I find the "Commits"-tab more intuitive for inspecting code across multiple branches, even though I can't exactly put my finger on the reason. On github I often have to double-check which branch I…

Looks pretty similar to GitHub for me http://gitlab.org/screenshots/

Well, of course it still looks similar (albeit not identical). Why should they change perfectly fine visual elements unless they can improve on them?

I see nothing questionable in copying a good layout anyway, as long as you don't try to fool the user into thinking you are the product that you are borrowing from. There is no point reinventing an existing wheel unless you can make it significantly rounder.

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#18

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

Github, as good as they are, aren't the only company doing what they do. Gitorious, Tigris, Bitbucket and Sourceforge (et al.) have all been around a long time. Suggesting Github have had their features "ripped off" is harsh, and more than a bit rude to the other developers.

Re: GitLab v4.1 released

#20

While I love that this is being built, am I the only one that feels a bit dirty about the blatant UI ripoff they are doing of GitHub. GitHub is a company that in my opinion can't get enough hacker karma, they have done a brilliant job of innovating time and time again and delivering a brilliant product that makes all our lives better. I can't even bring myself to use open source projects on Google Code, it just isn't…

Google docs and Open Office look very similar to MS Office... And why should it look different? :)
Post reply on HN