Live data from Hacker News

Algorithm improvement for Coca-Cola can shape recognition

stackoverflow.com

11–13 of 13 posts

Re: Algorithm improvement for Coca-Cola can shape recognition

#11
post #8

This computer vision stuff is so fascinating. Does anyone know what the career prospects are like if you specialize in this? Is there much consulting demand? What kind of fees do CV consultants charge?

The original post really highlights the "problem with computer vision" - finding the coke can is fairly easy (SIFT), although the author goes off on some other random approach that I doubt would work very well. The field certainly has its share of Do-It-Yourselfers, plus it's also quite common to outsource labour overseas. As for fees, it's entirely reflective of a) how much money the problem is costing the client an…

Hey that sounds like a cool job but why does the candidate need to know java and c++?

Re: Algorithm improvement for Coca-Cola can shape recognition

#12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The original post really highlights the "problem with computer vision" - finding the coke can is fairly easy (SIFT), although the author goes off on some other random approach that I doubt would work very well. The field certainly has its share of Do-It-Yourselfers, plus it's also quite common to outsource labour overseas. As for fees, it's entirely reflective of a) how much money the problem is costing the client an…

Hey that sounds like a cool job but why does the candidate need to know java and c++?

Well we do use both (and various others), but really what languages someone knows isn't such a big factor.

Re: Algorithm improvement for Coca-Cola can shape recognition

#13
post #10
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The original post really highlights the "problem with computer vision" - finding the coke can is fairly easy (SIFT), although the author goes off on some other random approach that I doubt would work very well. The field certainly has its share of Do-It-Yourselfers, plus it's also quite common to outsource labour overseas. As for fees, it's entirely reflective of a) how much money the problem is costing the client an…

I don't see any problem with the original solution. It is classic (but little bit old fashioned) way of detecting objects, far from random. I also think that you oversimplify the SIFT solution. You use sift, then what? Match the feature vectors, get bunch of possible correspondence points, prune outliers using 3D model of a cylinder (or assume that the face of the can is flat plane and just use homography) and robust…

You're right, it's ok for a project. I guess what I meant was it's quite easy compared to the problems my company deals with every day. 30 images in 24 hours (I think it said) is kind of a problem.

Given the constraints of the asker (all available in OpenCV), the solution I would suggest first is SIFT + homography, both easy to use and in OpenCV (sample code is around). Yes, there's a lot of other possibilities, but this would be an improvement over the original.

Post reply on HN