Live data from Hacker News

I don't want to download your app

newcome.wordpress.com

11–20 of 225 posts

Re: I don't want to download your app

#11
post #8
post #4

The culprit often is "Tapatalk", a forum app that pops up a notification on every iOS device for a lot of forums.

Tapatalk is still completely opt-in though. Those forums have to include Tapatalk software within their own.

And for the most part, Tapatalk does improve the experience of navigating message boards.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#13
post #10

I avoid this problem by instantly boycotting any site that does this. They clearly have absolutely no interest in serving me content or helping me do what I want to do, and there is always an alternative.

There is really no alternative to Linked In - there is other software that does the same thing but since no one in my network uses it, that would be worthless to me.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#14
post #10

I avoid this problem by instantly boycotting any site that does this. They clearly have absolutely no interest in serving me content or helping me do what I want to do, and there is always an alternative.

There is really no alternative to Linked In - there is other software that does the same thing but since no one in my network uses it, that would be worthless to me.

LinkedIn does this?! Yuck. I wonder if they A/B tested and found that this improves some sort of conversion ratio.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#16
Worst part is, most of these apps are essentially browsers. There is no additional content or interesting extra functionality being offered... just same old content, only formatted differently.

So, this concept of installing a new browser every time I visit an unfamiliar site, really is ridiculous.

This is almost as bad as "here's a mobile version of our site, opened automatically for your convenience".

If your site is designed peoperly, my iOS device can browse your "full" site just fine, thank you.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#18
post #10

I avoid this problem by instantly boycotting any site that does this. They clearly have absolutely no interest in serving me content or helping me do what I want to do, and there is always an alternative.

I understand the frustration w/the manner in which some mobile apps are advertised, but wrt this statement in particular ...

They clearly have absolutely no interest in serving me content or helping me do what I want to do

... coming from the site owner side of things, I'll offer a friendly counter argument (which has been rephrased in light of down votes): site owners are interested in serving you content, or helping you do what you want to do ... just in a better way.

I agree ads or prompts can be annoying, but to say site owners go through the trouble of developing a mobile app and advertising it b/c they have no interest in serving content or helping the user experience doesn't quite fit. To me, a site that offers a mobile app says the exact opposite.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#19

Worst part is, most of these apps are essentially browsers. There is no additional content or interesting extra functionality being offered... just same old content, only formatted differently. So, this concept of installing a new browser every time I visit an unfamiliar site, really is ridiculous. This is almost as bad as "here's a mobile version of our site, opened automatically for your convenience". If your site…

They want to have push/local notifications. It's like getting ahold of an email, but moreso. I've turned off Javascript to avoid them asking, now I constantly get "turn on your javascript" black overlays from Wordpress sites. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Re: I don't want to download your app

#20
post #10

I avoid this problem by instantly boycotting any site that does this. They clearly have absolutely no interest in serving me content or helping me do what I want to do, and there is always an alternative.

Yelp app seems like a tough one compared to their site on a mobile browser - they cache previously viewed places, your location, some graphics, embedded native maps, more streamlined search, and just overall offer a better experience.

But yeah, they're in 1% of the world where app is more useful than the site.

Post reply on HN